Like so many tasked with organizing the Pittsburgh spring ritual known as the Lenten fish fry, Frank McSorley was hugely disappointed when the Diocese of Pittsburgh abruptly canceled all of its fish fries last March amid the coronavirus outbreak.

St. Alphonsus Church in Pine counts on the 2,000 or so dinners that Mr. McSorley and dozens of volunteers prepare and sell each Friday during the six-week Lenten season. Served in Blessed Francis Seelos School’s cafeteria, the meals not only generate revenue for the church but also are an opportunity for fellowship among the community. It’s a big and delicious bang for a customer’s buck, with fried or baked fish or shrimp offered along with various side dishes, soups and condiments.

Last year’s cancellation hurt, Mr. McSorley said, but at least everyone’s back on track this next year, right?

The answer is mostly yes.

Advertise with us

With the coronavirus safety requirements and regulations still in place, the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh on Feb. 5 announced that parish fish fries can go forward this Lenten season starting Good Friday. But there’s a hitch — the fabulous fried fish will have to be a takeout.

What that further means for fish fry fans is that most churches are limiting their menus, in some cases drastically, to just a few gold standards. Many also are only taking orders in advance and/or requiring customers pay with a credit card out of concerns for the health and safety of both the organizers and guests.

A smaller number of volunteer cooks in the kitchens means that churches don’t have the means to prepare a wide variety of seafood dishes. Nor can they produce a multitude of side dishes that are often as much of a draw as the fish itself.

Fish Fry at St. Maximilian Kolbe Parish

In non-COVID years, St. John the Baptist in Plum featured weekly specials like shrimp scampi, crab cakes and eggplant Parmesan along with its baked or fried fish dinners, and haluski, mac and cheese, green beans, french fries and pizza as sides. This year the church, which is part of Holy Family Parish that includes Our Lady of Joy in Plum, St. Irenaeus in Oakmont and St. Joseph in Verona, will offer only fish dinners and just three sides — french fries, a roll and coleslaw.

St. Irenaeus, similarly, has downsized its one-of-a-kind to salad bar to just a single-serving side salad, said Joyce Doyle, an administrative assistant who has been a fish fry co-chair for more than a dozen years.

Advertise with us

“The smaller menu is so there are less people in the schools or buildings working, so we can remain socially distant,”  she said. Fish fry volunteers tend to be older, she added, so churches have to be extra careful.

In addition to being limited to takeout, Our Lady of Victory Maronite Catholic Church has an added wrinkle this year that’s led to a change in where their famed Lebanese side dishes are prepared. In August, it moved to a new location in Brookline, and the kitchen is not yet certified, said Lenten meal coordinator Anne Ayoob, who also is the church’s financial manager. So the parishioners/restaurateurs — including Jocelyn and Joe Chahine of Pitaland and Tony Kassab of Kassab’s — who for years made their donated ethnic sides in the church kitchen on the day of  will instead have to prepare them ahead in their restaurants. (The church has a temporary facility license to prepare the fish.)

“We’ve also had adjust pricing,” said Ms. Ayoob, because sides this year are a la carte instead of being included in the price of a dinner.

However, there is a bit of a silver lining to this year’s restrictions. Changing the format to preordered takeout meals  will allow the church to be better organized and waste less food, she said.

Dorothy Ikach, who organizes the fish fries at St. Serbian Orthodox Church in McKeesport, agreed that the pandemic has allowed churches to get more efficient. Limiting sides and taking preorders only “is just easier and quicker,” she said.

Advertise with us

Based on their experiences with an Advent fish fry the church held last December, people don’t seem to mind standing in line with a mask. “There were no complaints,” she said, and the church ended up selling almost 50 percent more fish than during a typical Friday in Lent.

Knowing exactly how many people it will be serving and what they want to eat also will free up the church to add sides like soup and Spanish rice on select dates and their famed nut rolls, strudels and palachinka, a type of Serbian crepe.

Speaking of homemade desserts, they are another casualty of this year’s fish fry restrictions. The diocese is cautioning against foods not made in a church’s kitchen to be offered at the fish fries.

Homemade desserts at St. Alphonsus, which became part of St. Aidan Parish in July, have been a crowd-pleaser at fish fries since their start in 2008. In fact, so many are offered, that the $1 slices of pie, pieces of cake, cookies and other baked goods fill an entire room.

This year, the church would have to either find a sponsor, as it did for its harvest dinner last fall, or buy everything at a bakery or Costco and then individually wrap them,  Mr. McSorley said. But the condiments, he noted, will still be homemade.

Advertise with us

At least one church is turning the coronavirus pandemic into an opportunity to do good. St. Albert the Great in Baldwin, which is part of Blessed Trinity Parish, is cancelling its fish fries. Instead, volunteers will hold a food distribution event in partnership with Greater Pittsburgh Community Food Bank on Feb. 26, where 500 boxes of food will be given to those in need. It will run from 11 am. to 2 p.m. in the church parking lot.

So many people are struggling and dealing with COVID, said Deacon Dan Nizan, “so we’re looking to give back to the community.”

In addition, the church is asking parishioners and others to support local restaurants struggling to stay in business  by ordering takeout. It will hold a cash raffle, and a  large portion of the proceeds will be given to the food bank in recognition of its efforts and hard work during the pandemic.

“It’s a win-win,” Mr. Nizan said.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter/IG @gtmckay.