Some attractions never get old at the annual Pennsylvania Farm Show, and that includes the iconic butter sculpture.
Located smack in the center of the Main Hall at the Farm Show Complex in Harrisburg, it’s hard to overlook. The oleaginous sculpture is humongous, and it always lures a crowd — both the faithful and the curious. Made with 1,000 pounds of butter, it is designed to reflect the overall theme of the Farm Show.
But this year, there will be no butter sculpture. The display has been canceled, and it is the first time since its inception in 1991. However, the 105th indoor agricultural show will go on virtually from Saturday through Jan. 16. Among the virtual events is a Butter Up! contest for anyone 5 or older.
The butter sculpture cancellation is a disappointment not only to the half million visitors who attend the eight-day event but also for Jim Victor and Marie Pelton. The husband-and-wife food sculptors have been molding butter into life-size statues at the show every year since 2003.
The Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture had originally said the butter sculpture would take place but later decided against it, stating it didn’t want to compromise the safety of its staff, the sculptors and those involved in recording and broadcasting virtual events.
The sculptors got a call about the cancellation from agriculture secretary Russell Redding in early December. But it was at the eleventh hour, just as they were ready to make the steel armatures.
“We thought we were all clear and that everything was on a go. We had settled on a design. We had signed a contract. And then it all just fell apart,” Mr. Victor said. “But he was very nice to call, and we do understand. It is the way it is. It was a policy decision that was bigger than us. This historic pandemic has taken things over.”
The couple said they could not talk about the design, which is a collaboration between the Agriculture Department and American Dairy Association North East, because it could be a recurring theme for another time. But they shared what it takes to create the Farm Show’s famed sculpture.
Even in a typical year, things don’t always go seamlessly. It takes a lot of work even before the butter is sculpted over the steel frameworks. First the Agriculture Department and the dairy association have to sign off on the drawings for the design and that sets off a back-and-forth process for a couple of weeks.
“We don’t have complete freedom over the design. I wish we did. They come up with the theme for the sculpture, and we do the drawings,” Mr. Victor said. “Then it goes to them. They might object to something. It’s a process.”
“We give our opinions. But if they give us carte blanche that would be even better,” his wife added.
After the drawings are OK’d, the artists start making steel armatures for a strong structural and invisible foundation at their home studio in Conshohocken. She would weld figures out of steel pipes, and he would cover them with a wire screening. The armatures would then be loaded into their truck for the trip to Harrisburg.
At the Farm Show, they typically spend 10 days in a state-of-the art octagonal-shaped refrigerated booth sculpting the butter over the armatures. They start with fairly warm butter, around 65 degrees, to spread and cover large surfaces. When the sculpture is ready to be carved, the temperature is turned down to 55 degrees to help with working on the details.
They use butter that is unfit for consumption, and it comes from a Land O’Lakes plant in Carlisle. The butter not only gets recycled by the sculptors but also after the show is over. It is given to a dairy farm in Juniata County that has an anaerobic digester. The digester breaks down the butter and other organic refuse to produce biogas and generate energy.
Mr. Oliver’s first sculpture at the Farm Show was in 1995, and it featured three soldiers from the Battle of the Bulge with a carton of rationed butter and other dairy products. “The Pennsylvania 28th Division fought in that war and lost a lot of soldiers. It was a commemoration of how dairy farmers provided butter for the troops,” he said. “I was born at the end of World War II, and you could not get butter easily.”
One of their favorites is a sculpture they made for the show’s 100th anniversary in 2016. It reflected what the show is about, featuring a young farmer exhibiting her dairy cow, a 4-H member with baby chicks, a home baker with pies and a farmer with a basket of apples.
“We did something different there. There was an element of color to indicate the PA Preferred theme besides having just the yellow butter,” Ms. Pelton said. “I also loved all the characters that were represented.”
They remember the “Play 60” sculpture in 2011 not just because it represented a campaign between the NFL and dairy association to get children to be more physically active. It also was the year they got a new and bigger booth at the Farm Show. “Previously it was a trailer. It was more like a bowling alley — narrow and very long,” Mr. Victor said. “The space was challenging and awkward.”
Another favorite is the one they made last year. Mascots Gritty (Flyers), Swoop (Eagles) and Steely McBeam (Steelers) got a shout-out in a sculpture dubbed "East Meets West at the Pennsylvania Farm Show."
It has been kind of an East meets West life story for the couple, too, who met at the Pennsylvania Academy of Fine Arts in Philadelphia. Ms. Pelton, 55, was born in the Philippines and came to the States with her family in the 1970s. Mr. Victor, 75, was raised in Harrisburg. They got married in 2003.
When it comes to division of labor, they don’t follow any hard-and-fast rules. “Sometimes I might start on a drawing, and Jim might do the follow-up one. When we do the armatures, I do the welding. He knows how to weld. He just tells me I’m so good at it because he wants me to do it instead of him,” said Ms. Pelton, laughing.
Although they do a fair share of butter sculptures, they also sculpt with chocolate, cheese, candy, fruits, vegetables and bacon, showcasing their works at the Big E in Massachusetts, New York State Fair and Delaware County Fair in New York.
It is at the fairs where they get to mingle with the crowds and hear comments about their sculptures. They recalled one between a mother and daughter. “The woman said, ‘That’s the biggest waste of butter I have ever seen.’ The young girl, retorted, ‘No, it’s not.’”
People don’t realize that we don’t use edible butter, Ms. Pelton said, and if they do that objection might go away.
Does all that smell and sight of butter ever wear them out? Not at all, they said.
She loves the sweet and creamy smell of butter and never gets sick of it. He mentally disconnects from it.
“We never think about the stuff we sculpt with as being the stuff we eat. It’s just a different thing all together,” he said.
Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.