Mike Mantsch grew up in a family of bakers, so perhaps it was preordained that he also would end up in the pastry business.
Since the early 1970s, he has supplied a variety of delectable baked goods at Mantsch Blue Bonnet Bakery, which his father, Elmer, took over in 1954. So it’s with a heavy heart that Mr. Mantsch will call it quits on Christmas Eve.
Blue Bonnet is the last independent bakery in Homestead, which once had four. But after 47 years, marked by long hours and hard physical work, Mr. Mantsch says, he’s done. “I’ve worked long enough.”
It has nothing to do with the coronavirus pandemic. Like most other small operations across the region and state, business was way down during the COVID-19 lockdown this spring.
But when places reopened, business had been pretty good, with orders coming in like wildfire for the bakery’s made-from-scratch birthday cakes and doughnuts. Customers were placing orders for holidays treats like kolache and bolbalki (balls of dough typically eaten with honey and poppy seeds as a dessert or as a savory dish with onion and sauerkraut on Christmas Eve).
“And they have the world’s best brownies,” says Gwen Phillips of Munhall, who has been going to the tiny bakery on East Eighth Avenue for as long as she can remember.
The reason that Mr. Mansch is closing Blue Bonnet is because he can’t find bakers to take over, even with so many people out of work.
“If we could find someone to open for us, we would,” he says, with a sigh. “But I haven’t been able to.”
As a teen, he spent summers mixing and baking ingredients, manning the counter and learning every aspect of the business. After graduating from St. Elizabeth High School in Pleasant Hills in 1972, he worked alongside his dad full time. He took over the business when his father’s heath started to fail in the early 2000s. His younger sister, Kathy, came on staff in the early 1980s, doing all the finishing and decorating work.
“My father taught me everything I know,” says the 66-year-old baker from West Mifflin.
His paternal uncles John and Gustav operated bakeries, too. John Mantsch owned a bakery in Donora until he was in his 80s while Gustav Mantsch — known as Gus — bought the first Blue Bonnet Bakery in Brookline with his wife, Laura Mae, in 1946.
They owe their lineage to baking to patriarch John Mantsch, who emigrated from Germany to Homestead in the 1920s and opened a corner store on Sarah Street and 13th Avenue. He and his wife, Regina, baked bread in a brick oven in the garage, Mr. Mantsch recalls.
“Their five sons would go out and sell bread door to door,” he says, first from wagons and then a truck after demand grew to include customers in Munhall and West Homestead.
Bakery hours are brutal. Items have to be mixed, baked and decorated before the store opens at 7 a.m., and the oven and freezer are only so big. One of his longtime assistant bakers has been out sick for months, and a new guy didn’t pan out.
“So I’m by myself,” he says.
On Monday, for example, Mr. Mansch went in to work at 11 p.m. and was at the shop until 9 the following morning, prepping for the holidays. He’s no longer taking orders because he doesn’t want to promise something he might not be able to deliver. Ever since word got out, “it’s been a madhouse over here,” he says.
As expected, loyal customers are devastated. Some have even taken to social media to try to find him the much-needed help.
“We have relied on them forever,” Ms. Phillips says.
She’s particularly upset that she’ll no longer be able to buy Mr. Mantsch’s famed cherry-nut bread, a zillion of which she has purchased over the years.
Jamie Elizabeth, who lives right down the street from the bakery in West Homestead, also can’t imagine life without the bakery. She’s been a devoted customer for some 15 years and her husband’s family has been going even longer.
“His grandparents are in their 90s and they still go every Saturday to get their rye bread,” she says. A Blue Bonnet birthday cake decorated in blue and gold roses is another treasured family tradition and you cannot get a better doughnut anywhere, she adds.
“Our kids have grown up on them.”
Andrea Jackson will miss its authenticity as much as its baked goods. There’s only room for about three people in the shop. But once inside, “you feel like you’re part of the neighborhood and family,” she says. “Then you’re surrounded by all this goodness and you just get hungry.”
The Crafton resident, whose mother grew up in Homestead, was raised overseas and has lived in six or seven other states. But there is no where else in the world, she feels, that bakes like Pittsburgh.
“I’m heartbroken, and so sad to think of all the years we got baked goods there,” she says. “It’s like, ‘Oh my gosh. Who can help them out’?”
Mr. Mansch concedes he might feel differently about trying to find a new owner after the holidays. He has no children to pass the bakery onto, and his sister doesn’t want to take it over either.
“I want to enjoy my retirement,” he says.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.