How to carve a turkey

The Turkey Day hotline is going to be exceptionally busy this year.

With many people unable to get together with their family to celebrate Thanksgiving, novice and seasoned cooks will not get their usual support in the kitchen. Mom won’t be around to help make a picture-perfect pie, and Dad won’t be on the scene to stuff and carve the bird.

But there is no need to hit the panic button. We have sought out experts to answer questions about thawing, trussing and cooking the turkey, reheating potatoes, serving wine at the proper temperatures and baking pie without a cracked top.

They are Bill Nolan, Butterball turkey talk line supervisor and professional chef; Dan Souza, editor-in-chief for Cook’s Illustrated magazine; Josh Hull, wine buyer for the Chairman’s Selection and Chairman’s Advantage programs at Fine Wine & Good Spirits stores; and Nancy Fiorani, customer service agent for Libby’s.

Advertise with us

Here’s their advice to help whip up a winning Thanksgiving feast.

Turkey

Q: Where does a first-time cook begin when it comes to making the turkey?

Bill Nolan: The person should first determine what size turkey to buy. A small Butterball is 10 pounds, a medium is 16 to 17 pounds, and a large is 18 to 24 pounds. The rule of thumb is to estimate 2 pounds per person; this allows for leftovers, too. So a 10-pound bird will feed five.

The next step is to decide if it should be a fresh or frozen turkey. If you have room in the freezer, buy frozen. That way, the job is done. As long as you remember to thaw the bird, you don’t have to worry about it anymore. A fresh turkey, on the other hand, is more expensive, but it just needs to be removed from the fridge and cooked.

Advertise with us

Q: What is the best way to thaw a bird, and how long does it take?

BN: It’s best to move the turkey from the freezer to the fridge to thaw it. A 10- to 18-pound bird takes three to four days, and a 22- to 24-pound bird can take five to six days. The National Thaw Day this year was on Nov. 19.

Dan Souza: If you are short on time, transfer the frozen bird into a plastic bag and thaw it in a big stockpot filled with cool water. You want cool water so that the turkey does not get hot on the outside while you wait for the inside to thaw. Then change the water every hour or so. It takes about 30 minutes for every pound to thaw. So for a 12-pound frozen bird, you are talking about 6 hours. The best bet is to do it ahead of time in the fridge.

Don’t thaw the bird, even if it is a small one, in the microwave. It won’t heat the bird evenly, even on the defrost setting.

Q: What are the basic tools required for cooking the turkey?

Advertise with us

BN: You need a reliable meat thermometer to tell you if the meat is done. When the turkey is cooked in a 325-degree oven, it is done when the breast registers 170 degrees and the thigh is 180 degrees. If you are stuffing the bird, it should read 165 degrees.

You also need a roasting pan that is large enough to hold the turkey and the juices that come out when cooked. But it should be a shallow pan that is about 2 inches in depth. It should not be too high as that will affect how the sides of the bird are cooked.

The bird needs to rest on a flat rack in the pan. This allows for air to circulate under the bird for even cooking. If you don’t have a rack, make a coil using 3 feet of heavy-duty foil and rest the bird on it.

Make sure to have good oven mitts — the roasting pan will be very hot. Also, be sure to clear the space on the countertop or stovetop.

A good sharp knife to carve the turkey and a carving fork to hold the bird are essential. The longer the knife, the better it is.

Advertise with us

Q: Why is the turkey cooked at 325 degrees and not a higher temperature?

BN: If the temperature is higher, it is easier to overcook the surface before the inside of the turkey is cooked. Also, there will be less splatter in the oven and you’ll have less cleanup.

Q: How often should you check the oven to see if the bird is cooked?

BN: It takes about 3 hours to cook a small bird in a 325-degree oven. Check on it 2 hours in and then every 20 minutes closer to the time when it is almost done. Don’t open the oven door too often as you will be letting out the heat and extending the cooking time. A 22-pound bird will take 4 to 4½ hours to cook, and so let it cook for at least 2½ to 3 hours before you first open the door.

Q: How does the resting time differ from a small and big turkey?

Advertise with us

BN: It’s important to let the turkey rest, otherwise it will fall apart when sliced. The average resting time for a small turkey is 20 minutes. The resting will allow the juices to redistribute and the meat to firm up, making it easier to carve. For a 20-pound turkey, the carryover cooking is greater as it absorbs and holds more heat. As a result it takes more time to cool and will need to rest for at least 30 minutes.

Q: Is it better to stuff or not stuff the bird?

BN: If you are a first-time cook, don’t stuff. It adds another level of complexity. But if you are up to the challenge, stuff the turkey just before it goes into the oven. Don’t stuff it the night before. And if you are adding meat like ground pork to the stuffing, make sure it is cooked.

Q: What is the proper way to truss the bird?

DS: Trussing is good for appearances for a Norman Rockwell kind of Thanksgiving. It also makes the bird a little more compact and helps to slow down the cooking, especially the inner parts of the breast where it touches the drumstick. But if you don’t truss, it is not the end of the world.

Advertise with us

There are complicated old-school ways to truss a bird, but all you need is about 6 inches of twine that you cross over right at the drumstick joint. If the twine is longer it will burn in the oven.

Potatoes

Q: Is there a proper way to reheat mashed and scalloped potatoes?

DS: Generally, when mashed potatoes are reheated, they get a whole lot drier. A good way would be to add the potatoes into a pot over low heat along with a small amount of the desired dairy like milk or cream. Then gently stir them together. You don’t want to overwork the potatoes as it will become gluey.

It is a little harder to get scalloped potatoes back to their original form when reheating them. Your best bet is to add a little dairy on top, and reheat the potatoes, covered, in a 250- to 275-degree oven. The low temp will heat the potatoes evenly and gently. It takes about 25 minutes to reheat fridge-cold scalloped potatoes. If I were eating it, I will add some cheese, too, to get a nice browning and make it more cheesy.

Advertise with us

Pies

Q: What is the secret behind making a perfect pie?

Nancy Fiorani: Bake the pie for 15 minutes at 425 degrees and then turn the temperature down. Without the high temperature, the crust will turn doughy and soggy. For best results, always bake the pie in the lower third section of the oven where the temperature is most even.

If using a metal or foil pan, place the pie on a preheated heavy-duty baking sheet for the entire baking time. It will bake more evenly. Glass pie plates conduct heat evenly and so don’t need to be placed on a baking sheet.

On removing the pie from the oven, place it on a wire rack in a draft-free spot. The rack allows for air flow under the pie and from steam remaining in the pie. This will prevent the crust from becoming soggy.

Advertise with us

DS: For a better textured pie, it is best to bake it closer to the time it is served. For a nice clean slice, custard pies like pumpkin pie need 2 to 3 hours to cool. They cannot be rushed. So assemble the pie ahead of time and bake it on Thanksgiving Day. This way you can get the desired crisp effect.

Q: How do you avoid the pie from cracking on top?

NF: If the oven rack is too close to the top heating element in the oven, the filling will get a thin layer of skin and crack as the pie bakes.

Another reason for the cracking is that the pie may be overbaked. So try reducing the cooking time by 5 to 10 minutes.

Q: How long can you keep an opened can of pumpkin puree?

Advertise with us

NF: After opening the can, transfer the filling to a nicely sealed container, and it will keep for a week in the fridge and up to 3 months in the freezer.

Wines

Q: How soon should a bottle of white and red wine be consumed once it is opened?

Josh Hull: A young white wine will hold up for several days if it is kept cold. A young red would hold up for several days, too, if the bottle is kept in a cool place and is sealed.

The notable exception might be an older wine, which may need to be consumed within a day or so after opening, depending on where the wine is at in its evolution. This will vary based on acidity levels, tannin structure, age and storage conditions.

Advertise with us

Q: What is the ideal temperature to serve whites and reds?

JH: A lot of people consume white wines too cold and red wines too warm. Sure, white wines belong in the refrigerator, but that doesn’t mean that they should be served really cold. Similarly, serving a red wine at room temperature when it is 72 degrees is wrong, too.

Get the white out of the refrigerator and let it sit on the counter for 30 to 40 minutes so its temperature gets up to 50 degrees. This way the aromas and flavors will come out better than when it is 38 degrees.

Reds on the other hand should be served a little cooler, around 60 degrees. They present their best version of fruits and aromatics at that temperature. So place the bottle in the refrigerator for 30 to 40 minutes before serving.

Q: How important is to decant wine?

Advertise with us

JH: Not all wines need to be decanted. A super young tight red wine or an older wine will benefit from a decanter. The young wine needs a decanter because it needs some air to breathe. The older wine needs to be decanted to get the sediment out. But be careful when decanting an older wine because as more air hits, the wine will quickly fall apart. A young wine benefits from breathing but an old wine will suffer from too much breathing.

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.