A new pickle company owes not only its name to Pittsburgh but also its soul.

When chefs Mark Mammone and Joe Bardakos launched Bridge City Brinery last month, they were hoping for the best. The COVID-19 pandemic still had a stranglehold on businesses and they had 10-hour-a-day jobs at Piccolo Forno. The pickles, made in Piccolo’s kitchen, were being sold only on Mondays and could be picked up only during a two-hour window at the Lawrenceville restaurant.

But when the picklers started getting flooded with preorders, the launch date had to be pushed back and they went from making 5 pounds at a time to 300 pounds. Now they are selling their pickles online from coast to coast and across the region at 52nd Street Market in Lawrenceville, Wagner’s Market in Hampton and a tavern and supermarket in Beaver County.

The 16-ounce jars, filled with fermented Kirby cucumbers, couldn’t be more Pittsburgh-centric. The keystone-shaped label with a black-and-gold edge has line illustrations of bridges. Bridge City Brinery’s name is a throwback to Pittsburgh’s nickname and a riff on the many craft breweries in the area.

Advertise with us

“Pittsburgh Pickles was already taken and Pittsburgh Brinery just didn’t have a ring to it,” says Mr. Mammone, the company’s founder. “When we combined Bridge City and brinery, it just flowed together.”

The label is catchy but not big, to keep the focus on the pickles. “We want to show this is who we are and this is what we have and you are looking at it,” he says.

BCB launched with a dill pickle, Smithfield Sour, which is named after the Smithfield Street Bridge and sits in a brine that the picklers call river water because “it looks like something you would scoop out of the Allegheny.”

The brine consists of the usual suspects — water, salt, dill, spices, onion and garlic — but it is the old-fashioned process that adds the oomph.The cukes are not preserved the quick and easy way, in vinegar for a few hours. Instead they are fermented in the aromatic salty solution for eight to 11 days.

The picklers let air and good bacteria do the work but monitor the cucumbers closely every day by spinning them around in the buckets and burping them to release the gases. And they taste the brine every day.

Advertise with us

“When we taste it on the first day, it is so different from what it tastes like on the second, third or fourth day,” says Mr. Bardakos, co-creator of the company and head chef at Piccolo.

On day one, they get a lot of spice heat in the brine, a little salt and some flavor from the water leeching out of the cucumbers. By day three, there is a sour taste, the punch from the spices diminishes somewhat and the brine has a better salt profile. On day five, there is almost no hint of spice and the punch from the onion and garlic builds, giving the brine a fuller flavor. The cukes also go through a color change, turning from a bright green to a more army green. A well-rounded flavor arrives around day 11.

“When we open the buckets on that final day, a really good aroma fills the room. We know by the smell that it is ready,” says Mr. Mammone. “It’s like walking into a steakhouse — you know where you are.”

The Beaver native first started making pickles when he lived in Los Angeles. He had spent much of his seven years there working as a body double for Seth MacFarlane, David Schwimmer and other 6-foot-tall actors.

When that part of his life came to a close, he went to culinary school. He also embarked on a new hobby — pickling, first with vinegar-based pickles and later with kimchi. He followed concepts that his grandmother, who emigrated from Croatia, used when making sauerkraut. Inspired by friends who told him to sell his pickles, he hoped to open a pickle company when he moved back to Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

It became a reality when he got the job at Piccolo in January and shared the idea with Mr. Bardakos. The Shaler native, who was not a big pickle fan, agreed to give it a shot and brings a new perspective with his culinary knowledge. He was on the dean’s list at Pittsburgh’s Le Cordon Bleu Institute of Culinary Arts and worked at the Omni William Penn Hotel and restaurants in Louisiana and Philadelphia suburbs before joining Piccolo last November.

It has taken a lot of tweaking — from the correct room temperature to the proportion in ingredients — to get the pickles to where they are now. Even with constant daily tastings, the chefs say it is hard to get pickled out because they taste something different every day.

“There are a lot of intricacies to it and the profile can change in 12 to 24 hours. So it is like tasting something new every single day,” Mr. Bardakos says. “I think that speaks to how cool the entire process is.”

It also means incredibly long hours in the kitchen. They start chopping cucumbers and making the brine after their shift at Piccolo and sometimes work until 5 in the morning.

“Once we are done with our shift, Mark and I are just starting on our day off. We really enjoy doing this in our free time and it doesn’t feel like a long day,” Mr. Bardakos says.

Advertise with us

Has it ever crossed their minds that they are against a big player in town who goes by the name of Heinz?

“We are happy for the path they have paved for people to be so excited about pickles. We just want to be part of that culture and maybe do something that Heinz started,” Mr. Mammone says, referring to the company’s “57 varieties” slogan. “They don’t anymore and we hope to fill that gap a little bit.”

BCB’s next pickle, which comes out in January, is a hot one. Called Smoky Hot Metal, it is a nod to the Hot Metal Bridge.

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.