Arline Polinsky’s cream cheese pound cake is legendary. It’s the type of no-frills cake that remains true to itself, keeps coming up in conversations and has a life of its own.
When it first aired on WQED’s “QED Cooks” on the “M is for Mom” show in May 1995, the recipe became a favorite with the viewers. “It was the most popular one of all time,” said Chris Fennimore, co-host and producer of “QED Cooks.”
Ms. Polinsky appeared on the show with her daughter, Nancy Polinsky Johnson, who is the other host, publisher of Shady Ave magazine and wife of WPXI-TV news anchor, David Johnson. It was her first and only time on “QED Cooks” where she showed how to make the cake and stuffed cabbage with ground chuck. [The recipes aired on different half-hour shows at different times.]

The cake’s popularity took off almost instantly. “Strangers would come to me at grocery stores, the movie theater, anywhere and say, ‘I made your mother’s cake. It is so easy. It is so great. I love it’,” Ms. Johnson recalled.
The segment also appeared on “Best of QED Cooks,” “Best of All QED Cooks” and aired twice a year for three years. So the odes to the pound cake kept coming.
One was by a letter 10 years ago from a woman who alluded to the cake’s buttery goodness when explaining why her family renamed Arline Polinsky’s Pound Cake to Heart Attack Pound Cake. “We loved your mother’s pound cake. My husband can never get enough of it, and one night he had two pieces. That same night he had a heart attack.”
Read More
When she went to see “Miss Saigon” at the Benedum Center in February, the people sitting in front of her turned around to say how much they enjoy the pound cake recipe. “It is a thing that doesn’t stop,” Ms. Johnson said.
Reference to the cake came up again last month at a grocery store. “After introducing herself, the person said, ‘I have been watching you and Chris [Fennimore] for years. I got to have to tell you about your mother’s pound cake. I absolutely love it. It has become a staple in our house,” Ms. Johnson said.
The timing of the compliment reverberates in her because it happened only days before her parents died hours apart from each other of complications from COVID-19. Her father, Gerald “Jerry” Polinsky, passed away late at night on April 13 and her mother the following morning at the same hospital in Hollywood, Fla. Their beds were next to each other. A nurse told the family that Ms. Polinsky mouthed “together” and “Jerry” when her husband was wheeled out of the room.

After Ms. Johnson’s husband posted the news on his Facebook page, which got more than half a million views, she started hearing about the pound cake from his fans and people who wrote in condolence messages to her.
“I was sorry to hear of the passing of your parents. I remember like it was yesterday, your Mom’s pound cake.”
“My thoughts and prayers go out to Nancy and your entire family. I will think of her Mom every time I make her pound cake [which is often!].”
“I’ll always remember Nancy’s mother through her pound cake. After all these years, I finally made one in February. So worth the wait!”
At the WQED taping, her mother was anxious, Ms. Johnson said, conscious of the time limit and where the cameras were. But what people at home didn’t see on the TV screen was a woman with an incredible force.
“She knew how to get things done. Had tremendously high standards. Wanted everything to be done as properly, beautifully and deliciously as possible,” Ms. Johnson said.
Her mother was an interior decorator and later became a real estate agent. When the Polinskys moved to Columbia, S.C., she chaired the town’s first Symphony Designer Showhouse, founded the Columbia Jewish Film Festival and was a charter member of the EdVenture Children’s Museum.
Ms. Polinsky had no formal culinary training or special techniques but loved to cook for her family, especially baked goods. Apple pies, blintz loaves, lemon mousse cakes, brownies and Hello Dollies were all part of her repertoire.
“Mummy learned from her mother and mother-in-law and was very committed to family and traditions,” Ms. Johnson said. “So she would cook my Gagi’s [paternal grandmother] strudel for major Jewish holidays and holiday gatherings like Thanksgiving and of course, the cream cheese pound cake.”
The cake was a regular feature during Ms. Johnson’s early life. In addition to the holidays, her mother would make it when she came home from college and even after she moved away and had her own family.
“There are many things you can do to a pound cake — add powdered sugar, fruits or syrups. But I never wanted anything except the plain pound cake, crusty and cracked on top. It was just too delicious the way it was,” Ms. Johnson said.
The recipe was featured in the ‘Best of QED Cooks’ cookbook. As part of the headnote, Mr. Fennimore wrote: “It is tempting to say we save the best for last, but there is no doubt that desserts, cookies and cakes are among the most requested from our cookbooks, and the most popular of them all is Arline Polinsky’s cream cheese pound cake.”

It wasn’t just her pound cake that got all the glory. There also was Arline Polinsky’s apricot chicken made with three ingredients — apricot preserves, Wishbone Russian dressing and dry onion soup mix. It was the second most favorite recipe with the viewers of “QED Cooks.” After Ms. Johnson’s demonstration aired on WQED, Russian dressing bottles were flying off shelves.
“When I went to my grocery store, an employee said: ‘I don’t know what is going on with the Russian dressing. Something aired on TV, and we cannot seem to keep it in stock,” she recalled. “That was my first glimpse of the power of her recipes.”
One of her mother’s words of wisdom was: “Part of cooking is cleaning up.” And Ms. Johnson took it to heart. As she was not into complicated recipes or involved cooking, she used to be the busser and dishwasher, while her younger sister, Joanna (Berens), would be the sous chef in their growing up years.
When Ms. Johnson got married, her mother typed up simple recipes with short and easy directions and placed them in a plastic sleeve for protection and gave them as one of her wedding gifts.
So what are her best memories of her mother in the kitchen?
“How do you sum up a feeling?” Ms. Johnson asked, choking up. “Mummy would always be there in her apron standing by the counter, always so organized. A breeze would blow in through the kitchen window and there would be a wonderful smell of whatever is cooking. And there would be a feeling of love.”
For the past six years, she and her family have been going to Florida to spend Mother’s Day with her parents at her sister’s home. But this year Ms. Johnson is not sure whether she will be heading south to clean out her parents’ apartment or spending the day with her two sons in Squirrel Hill.
“Besides crying, I don’t know what else I will be doing,” she said.
Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.

Arline Polinsky’s Cream Cheese Pound Cake
PG tested
The butter or oleo and cream cheese need to be brought to room temperature before they are creamed together with the sugar. Also, after taking the cake out of the oven, cool the cake in the pan for about 15 to 20 minutes before plopping it out on a plate.
As Nancy Polinsky Johnson says, this cake does not need any sort of embellishment — it is wonderful as is.
3 sticks butter or oleo, at room temperature
8 ounces cream cheese, at room temperature
3 cups sugar
1½ teaspoons vanilla
6 large eggs
3 cups sifted cake flour
Preheat oven to 325 degrees.
Cream butter, or oleo, cream cheese and sugar until light and fluffy.
Add vanilla. Add eggs one at a time, beating well after each addition.
Stir in sifted flour, and combine. Spoon into a 10-inch tube or bundt pan.
Bake at 325 degrees for 1 to 1½ hours, until a tester comes out clean.
— Arline Polinsky

Mummy’s Apricot Chicken
PG tested
Nancy Polinsky Johnson says chicken breast, thighs, legs or a combination of all of them can be used in this recipe.
For 2 pounds of chicken drumsticks, I used ¼ cup of apricot preserves, ¾ cup Russian dressing and one envelope of dry onion soup mix. At the end of 1 hour, 25 minutes, the chicken drumsticks were incredibly tender and crunchy outside.
Apricot preserves
Wishbone Russian dressing
1 package dry onion soup mix
Chicken
Preheat oven to 325 degrees.
Smear apricot preserves all over the chicken pieces in the baking dish.
Pour Russian dressing over the meat. Sprinkle with dry onion soup mix.
Bake for 1 to 1½ hours.
— Nancy Polinsky Johnson





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.