In lieu of an Ash Wednesday fish fry, St. Joan of Arc Parish in South Park is throwing a Fat Tuesday Fabulous Feast that would make New Orleans and Pittsburgh proud, and anyone with a hearty appetite happy.
It is the first time ever that the church is holding a feast on Fat Tuesday with Mardis Gras beads et al, and it all stemmed from a decision that the Rev. Joseph Sioli made. He didn’t think it was appropriate to continue the church’s tradition of holding a fish fry on Ash Wednesday because of the proximity between the church and its social hall.
“We just have a hallway that separates the church and the social hall, and Father Joe felt that the noise from the hall would be a little disruptive on the day of fasting,” explained Audrey Wurst of South Park, who had worked at the church for 20 years and now volunteers there during Lent for fish fry Friday.
So a group of longtime church members, including Ms. Wurst, decided to hold a feast instead like no other on Fat Tuesday. The discussion started out as a salute to a New Orleans Mardi Gras celebration featuring classic foods such as jambalaya, gumbo and red beans and rice.
Then someone suggested kielbasa and potato-cheese pierogies. Soon stuffed shells, stuffed cabbage, potato pancakes and hot sausage with peppers and onions made it on the menu, too.
At that point it wasn’t Mardis Gras food anymore, Ms. Wurst recalled, and she suggested calling the meal for what it really was — a Fat Tuesday Fabulous Feast.
The menu was expanded to include fried chicken, cornbread and beef brisket, and German-accented foods like potato salad and knockwurst. Initially, bratwurst also was on the list but then was pulled out because the committee felt that there was a sausage overload. Green beans almondine (French-style with almonds) were added to the menu so that there was some sort of a vegetable.
For desserts, there will be assorted pies from Signature Desserts and vanilla sheet cakes decorated with green, gold and purple icing. A Fat Tuesday feast is incomplete without fried doughnuts, and the members opted for the Pittsburgh paczki over the New Orleans beignet. Dave Terrace Bakery in Baldwin will supply doughnuts with chocolate cream, buttercream, jelly, apricot, lemon and custard.
Children can feast on mac and cheese and chicken tenders in addition to the regular menu. There also will be face-painting for them.
The buffet-style feast is open from 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. and the cost is $20 per person, $15 for seniors, $10 for students and free for children ages 5 and under. Beverages such as two kinds of beer, red and white wine, coffee, tea and soft drinks are included in the cost. While volunteer “waitresses” will serve the coffee, tea and water, those who are 21-plus would need to go to the bar to pick up their alcoholic drink.
Around 40 to 45 people are volunteering to help in the kitchen and social hall. Prep work like cleaning, chopping and grating the vegetables is scheduled for this weekend while cooking at the church’s big commercial kitchen, which has a 10-burner gas stove and convection oven, will begin on Monday. Sausage with onions and peppers will be cooked on Fat Tuesday.
“We have never done this before and so we don’t know if it will be a gangbusters [feast] or a flop,” Ms. Wurst said. She is hoping it will be the former.
Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.