A wedding on New Year’s Eve seems like a complicated calculus. Venues are often committed to hosting NYE parties and the stress and cost of planning a wedding on the heels of a holiday can be brutal.

But that has not deterred dozens of couples from getting married on Tuesday in and around Pittsburgh. The pros — protracted time off from work, biggest party night of the year, twinkling lights and other seasonal decor, a free firework show, easy-to-remember anniversary date — far outweigh the cons for them.

Kate Walker, 31, works on a wedding cake at Bethel Bakery. She piped an intricate lacework on her own wedding cake at the bakery in 2018. It was a lot of pressure, she says, because in addition to planning for her wedding she spent hours on end decorating her cake. (Christian Snyder / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Hannah Janecek of the North Hills is one those NYE brides. She and her fiance, Stephen Strayer, are ringing in 2020 with a roaring ‘20s Gatsby-inspired wedding at the Embassy Suites, Downtown, and many of their out-of-town guests, who were already visiting their families for Christmas, are staying back for it.

“I worked on a bride’s hair and makeup last New Year’s Eve and that’s what set the ball rolling. It seemed like a fun idea to have one big party,” says the owner of Wanderlust Beauty Studio in West Deer. “Plus, everybody is already in town and New Year’s Eve is one of my favorite holidays.”

Advertise with us

Glam and glitter is her mantra, and everything from her gown to a festive nontraditional four-tier cake by Bethel Bakery, reflects it.

“Hannah wanted a touch of drama to the cake, and so I call the cake Drama La Ma,” says Katlyn Doolin, the bakery’s wedding department manager.

The 22-inch-tall cake made with white batter, vanilla bean and milk chocolate mousse has a bottom tier covered with black fondant decorated with hand-piped gold filigree. It is topped with a tier of round sugar discs airbrushed with gold. The next tier up is taller and has gold-colored quilting and the top tier is white with gold drapings.

Typically, September and October are the busiest wedding cake months for the bakery, and they are followed by May and June. When it comes to weekends, the busiest ones are Memorial Day, Labor Day and New Year’s Eve weekends. Based on the cake orders, Ms. Doolin found more couples picked NYE to having their wedding this year.

Bethel Bakery is making nine NYE wedding cakes and most of them are for unions being held in Downtown venues.

Advertise with us
Bethel Bakery’s lead decorator, Stefanie Saccomani, 31, of Murrysville, sprinkles decorative sugar on a wedding cake. (Christian Snyder / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“Downtown is the place to be in Pittsburgh at this time of the year,” Ms. Doolin says. “There are the fireworks and there’s a party atmosphere. You can count down to the New Year with your whole family.”

And that’s what Ms. Janecek plans on doing after her wedding, which begins at 5:30 p.m. It will be followed by a four-course dinner and pizza at 11 p.m. She and her fiance got pizza on their first date and so they thought it would be a fitting way to celebrate their wedding before the countdown to 2020 begins.

When she chose the colors for the cake, she says she was trying to make a statement, especially with the black, gold and white accents.

And she’s not the only one. More and more couples these days are less fearful of adding color to their wedding cake, Ms. Doolin says, and they want it to be an artistic showpiece.

Another four-tier NYE cake that the bakery is making is a pink ombre cake with gold drips. “It looks like liquid gold dripping down the cake and is made with royal icing,” she says. A third cake blends traditional with the whimsical by featuring white French butter cream rosettes on the bottom tier and glittering crystallized sugar on the above three tiers.

Advertise with us

NYE cakes generally feature crystallized sugar and crystal banding to add texture and sparkle, making them more Instagram worthy. The hues tend to be metallic gold and silver or champagne, which is pale gold with a touch of pale pink. Sometimes they are decorated with hand-sculpted bubbles made with fondant to look like beads of Champagne. Buttercream rosettes are added to give more texture and volume.

The wedding cake team members at Bethel Bakery, from left, are: Marsha Gediohn, Vicki Kruszka, Kate Walker, Stefanie Saccomani, Charlene Yakich and Jenna Marweg. (Christian Snyder / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Ms. Doolin says she and her team of 10, who bake, stack, ice and decorate, have only one shot at the cake. So they take efforts to get the smallest of details down correctly right from the day the consultants first meet with the couples. They meet in the bakery’s parlor room, which has faux wedding cakes dolled up with beaded borders and rosettes on display, to ask and answer questions and later follow up on the orders.

“We know the cake photographs are going to be looked at forever,” she says.

For this year’s weddings, her team started baking the cakes on Sunday and finished decorating them on Monday or by Tuesday morning at the latest.

By the time the cake is finished, the bakers, stackers, frosters and decorators form a bond with it. So much so, when it’s time to send the cake to its destination, “we wave them goodbye,” Ms. Doolin says. “The cakes are like our children. We remember each of the cakes and couples we work with.”

Advertise with us

Will NYE be a popular date for weddings in 2020, too?

Ms. Doolin thinks the date is here to stay for tying the knot. Couples also have already started requesting cake orders for Feb. 29 (2020 is a leap year after all and the date falls on a Saturday) and 10-10-2020.

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.