Don Kaminski remembers the heavy smell of garlic as it spilled onto the pinched street in front of Mission Street Market, a sure sign that Christmas — and fresh Polish kielbasa — was near.

Fresh kielbasa is a holiday staple for many Polish-Americans, and Mission Street Market’s recipe, native to the South Side Slopes, has been the go-to for many Pittsburghers since 1921. Mission Street Market closed its doors in 2003, but its fresh kielbasa recipe (among others) are still produced and distributed to local retailers, triggering a flock of devotees seeking it for their Christmas and Easter spreads.

The South Side institution, first known as The White Eagle, was the brain child of Peter Wojtowicz who opened the store just three years after he emigrated from Poland. Located on Leticoe Street, the Polish heart of the South Side, it lasted until 1969 when a larger store front was available one street over on Mission, and the Mission Street Market name was born, although the traditional recipes persisted.

Michele Pitaro, manager of the Silver Star Deli, wraps up some Mission Street Market kielbasa after weighing it. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Just down from the Wojtowicz market was Mr. Kaminski’s childhood home.

Advertise with us

Like others from the South Side in the 1940s, Mr. Kaminski grew up assisting his mother to make fresh kielbasa by hand. Wielding a sharp knife at the family’s round wooden table, large enough to accommodate all six kids, he and his sister were tasked with cutting the pork butt into chunks while their mother, Cecilia, a Polish immigrant, handled the artistry of seasoning, adding the proper amount of fat and the stuffing of casings, until she lost her sight.

“Once she quit making it, I couldn’t eat it for a couple years,” Mr. Kaminski said.

His kielbasa fast ended when word circulated that a school mate, Don, aka Donny, was making kielbasa at his father’s shop. Don eventually became the market’s owner in 1990.

“It was pretty similar to mom’s. It had the Polish taste to it,” Mr. Kaminski said.

The threat of losing that hard-to-capture Polish taste sent the Mission Market fan base into a frenzy in 2003 when the Market closed its doors, and thus began the odyssey that this flock of Pittsburgh Polish-Americans has taken, following the recipe that most closely approximates the kielbasa that mom would make.

Advertise with us
“We like to try to keep traditions alive,” says Robert Germony, president and CEO of Silver Star Meats, about selling the Mission Street Market's kielbasa at his Silver Star Deli in Kennedy. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

While still in business on Mission Street, the market had agreements with Silver Star Meats, based in Kennedy, to help meet the store’s incredible demand. By that time, Don Wojtowicz’s son, Tom, had become the owner of the family’s most treasured recipes, and he, along with Silver Star Meats’ president and CEO, Robert Germony, found a way to perpetuate the most emblematic of Wojtowicz recipes.

“We like to try to keep traditions alive,” Mr. Germony said. “Whenever we see an opportunity, when someone has been in business for a long time, and we can come in and help preserve that name and that legacy, we gotta do it.”

Since 2003, Silver Star Meats has exclusively produced and distributed Mission Street Market’s kielbasa a few weeks before the Christmas and Easter holidays, but it’s the retailers who have changed over the years, turning the Mission Street Market following into a roving band of kielbasa-hunters.

Mr. Kaminski, who resides in Baldwin Township, has followed the recipe from the now-defunct Shop ’n Save on Joseph Street in Baldwin, to the bygone McGinnis Sisters in Brentwood and finally to Party Line Catering on Custer Street in Baldwin.

And he is not the only one.

Advertise with us

According to Party Line’s owner, Brian Meador, Christmas preorders for the kielbasa easily top 250, and that says nothing for what is sold directly from the case.

“People will walk in, and they’ll buy five, 10, 15 pounds,” Mr. Meador said. “Because they’re buying it for families or they’re sending it away, out of the area, because people still remember it, and they want to get it for the holidays.”

Listen: You say kielbasa, I say kolbassi ...

Those who frequented the Mission Street Market store will likely smile at that comment, remembering the five-by-three-foot map on the deli counter wall with red stick pins to show everywhere the family’s products had traveled.

The map still sits in Mr. Wojtowicz’s shed, an ironic reminder of when such far-reaching fandom seemed rare.

Advertise with us

The popularity of Mission Street Market’s kielbasa now commands an audience at eight retailers throughout the Pittsburgh area, equaling thousands of pounds of pork.

“The neighborhoods and the ethnic followings that you have down here are pretty unique throughout the country,” said Mr. Germony, a native of Buffalo, N.Y. “It’s because of the following, because of the people in Pittsburgh: They just love a certain niche product, and that’s all they want.”

No one knows this devotion to tradition better than Tom Wojtowicz, who, along with his siblings, has gotten to see this entire story unfold.

“I think part of it is there’s a strong family tradition, and a lot of times it’s centered on food,” said Mr. Wojtowicz. “There’s a certain comfort there. When we all get together, there are certain foods you’re looking for, and everyone can focus on that.”

The focus on kielbasa for many Polish-Americans isn’t just its presence but also its presentation.

Advertise with us

With the entire link kept intact to secure the juices inside, the kielbasa is boiled. Forty five minutes later, the link turns grayish-white when it is cooked through, earning its namesake, biala, which means white in Polish.

The meat can be sliced and pan fried from there, if desired, to crisp the natural casing and lend a slight crunch. Fried or not, grated horseradish accompanies the dish, setting off the garlic, pepper and sometimes marjoram with its flavorful heat.

Fresh Mission Street Market kielbasa at the Silver Star Deli in Kennedy. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The warmth is interrupted by the other traditional dressing: chilled red beets. The beets are boiled (or sometimes pickled), and then are grated into the horseradish or sliced and eaten as a side to the biala-horseradish combination.

Never ones to waste, people in Poland even have a way to use any leftover kielbasa in a soup called zurek or zur. Like an episode of “Chopped,” this hearty soup is full of seemingly-unrelated foods — root vegetables, hard-boiled eggs and leftover marjoram, horseradish and kielbasa from the preceding meal — which speaks to how special fresh kielbasa is regarded, never to let a bite go uneaten.

Over 4,000 miles and several generations away, fresh, Polish kielbasa is treated no less reverently in the hills of Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

As Christmas draws near, four generations of Kaminskis will be united by the practice of slathering Mission Street Market fresh kielbasa with horseradish and finishing it with a bite of pickled beets.

It’s that kind of story that still humbles the Wojtowicz family.

“When you grow up and become an adult, you realize that you were actually able to participate in a piece of Americana,” said Mr. Wojtowicz of his family’s accidental role in Pittsburgh’s history.

“It’s something we take pride in. How we think about it is, ‘Maybe we did a little something good.’”

Abby Mackey: Abbyrose.mackey@gmail.com and Twitter @AnthroAbbyRN.