To Melissa McKay Vautier, cookies are as integral to the holidays as choosing the perfect Christmas tree or wishing for snow on Christmas Eve.
The Venetia mother of three grew up baking with her grandmother, Margaret Pellegrino, and mother, Josephine. Every wedding mandated dozens of homemade treats for the cookie table, and the women were even more prolific during the holiday season when they’d churn out sheet after cookie sheet of sprinkle sugar cookies, tassies and Aunt Helen’s molasses cookies.
“We’d make tons and tons and box them up as gifts,” she remembers.
So when she moved back to Pittsburgh in 2007 after living out of town for several years, she decided to start her own sweet tradition to celebrate the holidays: a cookie exchange.
“I just thought it would be a fun way to get my kids involved,” she says of the culinary event in which invitees make a dozen or more of their favorites cookies and take them to a party where they’re swapped along with recipes and holiday cheer.
The exchange was an immediate hit. So much so that it’s grown from about nine participants making a few dozen cookies to one that draws upwards of 40 guests who bake and exchange at least 200 cookies each.
“Everyone is just so happy when they leave,” Ms. Vautier says of the annual get-together, which this year will be held on Dec. 14.
Lori Krzeminski-Miller can attest to that sentiment. She had such a blast at her inaugural cookie exchange last December with 11 friends that this year she’s going big — really big. On Dec. 15, she’ll host a first-ever community exchange at Hilltop Hose Company No. 3 in her hometown of Natrona Heights. In all, 79 invitees will make and swap some 13,000 cookies along with more than 1,500 puppy treats for their furry friends.
After participants have taste-tested and exchanged their favorites, nearly 1,000 of the sweet treats will be gifted to local charities that include Highland Area Meals on Wheels, Allegheny Association of Churches, Alle-Kiski Hope Center in Tarentum and Applewood Personal Care Home in Brackenridge. The firefighters — who will deliver the donated cookies via firetruck wearing Santa hats — also will get multiple trays. The many dogs waiting to be adopted at Animal Protectors of Allegheny County will get some goodies, too.
Mrs. Miller says they’d love to make, exchange and donate even more cookies. They just can’t squeeze any more tables into the volunteer fire hall on Cambridge Street — where she’s been an auxiliary member for 15 years — leaving a host of would-be bakers on a waiting list.
Many of the cookie makers are members of The Wedding Cookie Table Community on Facebook, which in August set the Guinness World Record for the largest wedding cookie table.
But there’s some newbies, too. Mrs. Miller’s 24-year-old niece, Holly Penn, and daughter, Gabby, for instance, are part of a 7-member group of “Next Gen” bakers who will make more than 700 cookies, including one of the holiday’s most popular varieties — snowballs, also known as Russian tea cakes or Mexican wedding balls.
“They always look so cute on a cookie tray,” she says.
It’s poised to be a festive affair. Bakers — broken into six groups of 12 — chose names and are dressing up in matching shirts and aprons. As a “Grinchette,” Mrs. Miller will don a Grinch costume, while her older sister, Phyllis, a Rockin’ Reindeer, will wear antlers.
“Everyone is going crazy,” she says, laughing.
While Dutch and German immigrants brought the custom of Christmas cookies with them to the U.S in the 1700s, no one knows for sure when, or where, the first official cookie exchange was hosted. Yet the tradition dates at least to 1936, when an article about a cookie swap between members of the Syracuse Home Bureau exchange was reported in a New York newspaper.
Given how busy many people are today, a cookie exchange can save bakers’ time and energy by spreading the holiday work load. It’s also a fun way for family and friends to get into a festive mood. Still, it takes some planning if you want everyone to go home full of Christmas spirit.
Here’s how to make it a success, along with some can’t-miss recipes to get you started.
SET GROUND RULES: Are store-bought cookies or candy OK? What about boxed brownies or everyday varieties like chocolate chip? Some hosts are super-strict about everything being homemade, while others accept that not every baker is Martha Stewart. Either way, be sure to specify in your invitation what the parameters are and try not to micromanage. To avoid duplication, as well as ensure a nice variety, Ms. Vautier asks her guests to specify what they’ll be bringing when they RSVP. “And I say what I’m making last to run interference,” she says. She also keeps a few cookies aside in case guests don’t count properly
STURDY IS BETTER: The best cookies to bring to an exchange are firm ones that travel well. Think drop cookies, unfrosted bars, cutout or icebox cookies, and varieties with hard chocolate coatings like buckeyes. Ms. Vautier freezes her cookies ahead of time so they are hard and don’t stick together during transport.
DETERMINE THE SCOPE: In addition to sampling them, each guest will be taking cookies to enjoy later. A general rule of thumb is at least one or two dozen cookies per participant, and as many as six if you have the space and people are expecting to bring a lot of goodies home.
TIMING: The closer you get to Christmas, the busier everyone will be. Yet seeing many people’s freezers are stuffed in December, you don’t want to plan an exchange too far in advance. Ms. Vautier suggests 10 days to two weeks ahead of Christmas.
MAKE IT A TRUE PARTY: Offer some coffee, cocoa or a holiday cocktail to wash down all the taste-testing cookies, along with a few easy appetizers or a vegetable tray to keep everyone from going into sugar overload. Mrs. Miller also suggests having a few awards, such as most “Christmassy,” hardest to make or best overall cookies. “And let everyone cast a vote,” she says. It’s also fun to play a game or two or organize a Secret Santa gift exchange with Christmas socks stuffed with everything from chocolate to lip balm.
DISPLAY: Be sure to offer ample space for laying out the cookies and make tasting them easy. Some hosts like to provide platters, but it’s also OK to ask attendees to bring their own. If guests aren’t providing recipes, you may also want to provide place-setting cards and a marker so bakers can note if their cookie includes nuts or some other allergen. Also, provide enough tongs so that party guests can make their selections without actually touching the cookies.
TAKE AWAY: You’ll want your guests to get their cookies home in once piece. It’s perfectly acceptable to ask everyone to bring their own plastic containers to pack up their loot. But just in case, make sure you have a variety of to-go containers or inexpensive paper bakery boxes in different sizes on hand, along with parchment paper and/or plastic baggies for separating the treats.
SPREAD THE WEALTH: Consider ending your evening by making up some cookie trays to donate to a local organization or family that would use some extra Christmas cheer. The holidays are a time of giving and sharing. “Everyone will be so excited to receive some of your sweet treats,” says Mrs. Miller.
Chocolate Peppermint Cookies
PG tested
These crispy, candy cane-topped cookies are about as close to a Girl Scout Thin Mint as a cookie can be. The original recipe calls for dipping the chocolate cookie in melted white chocolate, but I found it easier to ice the cookies. I used a beer taster glass to instead of a cookie cutter.
1 cup all-purpose flour, plus more for surface
½ cup unsweetened Dutch-process cocoa powder
½ teaspoon baking soda
½ teaspoon baking powder
½ teaspoon salt
5 tablespoons unsalted butter, softened
¾ cup sugar
1 large egg
1 large egg yolk
¾ teaspoon pure peppermint extract
8 large candy canes or 30 peppermint candies, crushed
2 pounds white chocolate, coarsely chopped
Preheat oven to 325 degrees. Sift flour, cocoa powder, baking soda, baking powder and salt into a bowl. In another bowl, beat butter and sugar with mixer on medium-high speed for 1 minute. Reduce speed to medium-low, and add egg then yolk — beating well after each addition. Beat in peppermint extract.
Slowly add flour mixture and beat until just incorporated. Shape dough into 2 disks, wrap each in plastic and refrigerate until firm, 1 hour to 2 days.
Roll out 1 disk of dough on lightly floured surface to ⅛-inch thickness. Freeze until firm, about 15 minutes. Using a 2-inch round cutter, cut out circles and place 1 inch apart on parchment-lined baking sheets. Roll and cut scraps once. Freeze until firm, about 15 minutes. Repeat with remaining disk.
Bake until cookies are dry to the touch, about 12 minutes. Transfer parchment, with cookies, to wire racks to cool.
Sift crushed candy, separating larger pieces from dust, reserving both. Melt chocolate in heatproof bowl set over pot of gently simmering water. Remove from heat. Dunk cookies into melted chocolate. Using a fork, turn to coat, let excess drip off. Place on parchment-lined baking sheets and sprinkle ¼ teaspoon of candy or dust on top. Refrigerate until set, up to 3 hours.
Makes 6 dozen.
— marthastewart.com
Toffee Mandelscotti
PG tested
Wonderfully crunchy, these biscotti-like cookies just might be the best cookie on your table this holiday season. For an extra-festive touch, sprinkle cookies with raw sugar or dip the ends in melted chocolate. If you’re a cookie dunker, they’re terrific with milk or coffee.
3 eggs
1 cup vegetable oil
1 cup sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla
3½ cups flour
1 teaspoon baking powder
1 teaspoon salt
12-ounce bag semi-sweet chocolate chips
8 ounces almond toffee bits
Place eggs, oil, sugar and vanilla in bowl of an electric mixer. Beat until light in color, 5 minutes. Sift together flour, baking powder and salt. Mix in egg mixture just until incorporated. Do not overmix. Stir in chocolate chips and toffee bits. Wrap dough in plastic wrap, and refrigerate for 3 hours.
Heat oven to 350 degrees. Divide dough into 4 pieces; shape each piece into 8-by-3-inch logs on an ungreased cookie sheet. Bake until lightly browned, 25 minutes.
Reduce oven to 300 degrees. Remove cookie logs from baking sheet; cut diagonally into ¾-inch sliced. Place sliced cookies back on baking sheet. Bake until golden brown, 20 minutes.
Makes 3 dozen cookies.
— “Holiday Cookies” by the Chicago Tribune staff (Agate Surry, 2014)
Gluten-Free Kitchen Sink Blondies
PG tested
Just because you have a gluten sensitivity doesn’t mean you can’t be part of the fun. This recipe is made with 1-to-1 gluten-free flour. It can be doubled to fill a 9-by-13-inch pan, but the batter will have to be baked an additional 10 to 15 minutes or until an inserted toothpick has moist crumbs.
½ cup butter, melted
1 cup light brown sugar
1 egg
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
1 cup all-purpose gluten-free flour
¼ teaspoon salt
½ cup milk chocolate chunks
½ cup dark chocolate chips
½ cup chopped pecans
1 cup ridged potato chips, crushed
½ cup caramel bits
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Line an 8-inch square pan with parchment paper or grease well with butter.
Combine butter and sugar in large bowl and stir until smooth. Add egg and vanilla and stir to combine. Stir in flour and salt until just combined.
Add chocolate chunks, chocolate chips, pecans and potato chips. Stir to mix throughout. Scoop the batter into prepared pan and spread to the sides with a spatula. Scatter caramel bits on top.
Bake 25-28 minutes, or until slightly browned around the edges and an inserted toothpick has moist crumbs. The top of the blondies should be slightly cracked on top. Cook completely before slicing into bars.
Makes 1 dozen.
— “The Weeknight Dessert Cookbook” by Mary Younkin (Page Street, October 2019, $22)
Snowball Cookies
PG tested
The snowball, also known as a Russian tea cake, is one of the most popular holiday cookies. Super easy to make with just a handful of ingredients, they’re melt-in-your mouth good.
1 cup butter, softened
½ cup sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2½ cups flour
¾ cup nuts, finely chopped
Powdered sugar, for dusting
Preheat oven to 375 degrees.
Cream butter and sugar in medium bowl until creamy. Add vanilla; beat until well mixed.
Add flour and nuts; beat at low speed, scraping bowl occasionally, until well mixed.
Shape dough into 1-inch balls. Place 1 inch apart onto ungreased cookie sheets. Bake 16-18 minutes or until very lightly browned. Cool 5 minutes; roll in powdered sugar while still warm and again when cool.
Makes 48 cookies.
— Holly McGregor, Natrona Heights
Cranberry-Orange Shortbread Cookies
PG tested
Buttery and light, shortbread cookies are easy to make and can be embellished with your favorite ingredients. These are perfumed with orange zest, with toasted almonds and dried cranberries adding crunch.
1 cup unsalted butter, room temperature
1 cup powdered sugar
¾ teaspoon almond extract
¼ teaspoon coarse sea salt
½ teaspoon table salt
1 tablespoon orange zest
2 cups flour, sifted
⅖ cup toasted sliced almonds
⅔ cup dried cranberries, chopped
Coarse turbinado or raw sugar, optional
Preheat oven to 325 degrees. Line 2 or 3 baking sheets with parchment paper.
Place butter, powdered sugar, almond extract, coarse salt and table salt in the bowl of a stand mixer. Beat 3 minutes on medium-high speed. Add orange zest and beat for an additional minute.
Add sifted flour, turn mixer to low and mix just until flour is incorporated. Fold in almonds and dried cranberries. Pat dough into a 1½ -inch diameter log and wrap in plastic wrap. Freeze dough until firm, at least 1 hour.
When ready to bake, remove dough from freezer and slice into ¼-inch thick slices. Place dough on parchment-covered baking sheet 1 inch apart. Sprinkle with coarse, decorator sugar, if desired
Bake cookies in a 325-degree oven for 20-25 minutes, or until edges turn golden. Remove cookies from oven and, after 2 minutes, transfer cookies to cooling rack.
Makes about 40 cookies.
— simplysated.com
Chocolate Thumbprints with Caramel
PG tested
Thumbprint cookies are usually filled with jam or preserves. Rolled in pecans, these chocolate cookies are drenched in thick caramel and drizzled with chocolate. So decadent!
1 egg
½ cup butter, softened
⅔ cup sugar
2 tablespoons milk
1 teaspoon vanilla
1 cup all-purpose flour
⅓ cup unsweetened cocoa powder
¼ teaspoon salt
16 vanilla baking caramels, unwrapped
3 tablespoons whipping cream
1¼ cups finely chopped pecans
½ cup (3 ounces) semisweet chocolate pieces
1 teaspoon shortening
Separate egg; place yolk and white in separate bowls. Cover and chill egg white until needed. In a large mixing bowl, beat butter with an electric mixer for 30 seconds. Add sugar and beat well. Beat in egg yolk, milk, and vanilla.
In another bowl, stir together the flour, cocoa powder, and salt. Add flour mixture to butter mixture and beat until well mixed.
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Lightly grease a cookie sheet. In a small saucepan, heat and stir caramels and whipping cream over low heat until mixture is smooth. Set aside.
Slightly beat reserved egg white. Shape the dough into 1-inch balls. Roll the balls in egg white, then in pecans to coat. Place balls 1 inch apart on prepared cookie sheet. Using your thumb, make an indentation in the center of each cookie.
Bake for 10 minutes or until edges are firm. If cookie centers puff during baking, re-press with your thumb. Spoon melted caramel mixture into indentations of cookies. Transfer cookies to wire racks; cool. (If necessary, reheat caramel mixture to keep it spoonable.)
In another saucepan, heat and stir chocolate pieces and shortening over low heat until chocolate is melted and mixture is smooth. Let cool slightly. Drizzle chocolate mixture over tops of cookies.** Let stand until chocolate is set.
Makes 36 cookies.
—bhg.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.