This week, olive oil distributor and importer Domenic Mantella and Luke Wholey, chef and owner of Luke Wholey’s Wild Alaskan Grille, answer queries on what to look for when buying olive oil and the best way to peel and devein shrimp.

If you have a question for Kitchen Talk, email kitchentalk@post-gazette.com.

Q: When I go to buy olive oil and see a dizzying variety of names on the store shelf, I never know which one to buy. What do I need to look for if I want to buy one that is of good quality?

A: Choose a bottle or tin of olive oil that is made in the same country as where the olives are grown. When a label says that the oil is the product of a certain country, it does not mean that the olives are grown there. Instead the oil might be a blend that has imported olives. It is important that the olives are grown, pressed and bottled in the same country, When olives travel a long distance, they are not fresh when they get to their destination and the oil ends up tasting rancid.

Advertise with us

Also, look for the words cold pressed. It means that the olives are pressed at room temperature (around 81 degrees Fahrenheit) during the entire pressing process and no artificial heat is used to extract the oil, When heat is applied more oil can be extracted but at the same time it will kill the delicate flavors.

If you are going for the extra-virgin olive oil, buy the nonflavored ones. When peppers or lemon are added to the oil, the flavor is being embellished and it is not extra virgin any longer.

What kills olive oil is light and oxygen and so buy oils in a dark or tinted glass. Aluminium tins are fine, too. Avoid light-colored bottles and stay away from plastic ones as plastic interferes with the flavor.

Price does not always dictate if the olive oil is of good quality or not. But generally use lower-priced ones for sauteing and frying and expensive ones for finishing salads or topping vegetables. You definitely want a high-end oil for dips as you want to taste the butter and smoothness.

It is best to use a bottle of olive oil within four to six weeks after it is opened because the fresh taste will be lost after that. Usually the expiration date for the oil is two years after it is pressed.

Advertise with us

— Domenic Mantella, Tavolo Pazzo olive oil importer and distributor

Q: What is the easiest way to peel and devein shrimp?

A: Place the shrimp in your left hand and then with your right hand pull its legs off first. This way the back shell will pop off easily. Then use a small serrated knife and run it through from the head to three-fourths of the way toward the tail. The serrated edge of the knife will catch the thin dark string, which is the “vein” or digestive tract, and pull it out. Make sure you pierce shrimp only 1 centimeter deep, though.

The digestive tract in larger shrimp have to be deveined as it can be sandy or grainy. But smaller shrimp don’t have to be deveined, unless the vein looks dirty, because it won’t affect the taste or how you enjoy the product.

Once the shrimp are peeled, and if you are not cooking them immediately, avoid exposing them to moisture or water because they will spoil faster. You don’t want the shrimp to be sitting in water if they are consumed right away.

Advertise with us

The best way to defrost frozen shrimp is to leave them in the refrigerator overnight.

Shrimp are not a huge carrier of bacteria and so they don’t have to be cooked for very long or until they are well done. When the translucent pink shrimp start turning white, it means that they are adequately cooked. They get smaller when cooked. When they curl up and the head touches the tail, it means that the shrimp is overcooked.

— Luke Wholey, owner and chef at Luke Wholey’s Wild Alaskan Grille