There was a time, not so long ago, when John Jamison had the worst time getting customers to buy anything but the “best” parts of a lamb.
Back when he and his wife, Sukey, decided to become sheep farmers in the mid 1970s, the animal’s prized middle meats were favored. On restaurant menus, you’d just find a fancy rack or roasted loin chops. And, boy, was it going to be expensive.
Perhaps not surprisingly, John says, people decided they were never going to cook for themselves a cut of meat that rivaled the cost of filet or New York strip steak. Lamb’s reputation as being much more gamy than beef didn’t help matters.
The “leftover meats” or peasant cuts, as they sometimes were called, only made it into someone’s kitchen tucked into one of Sukey’s soups, stews or pies the couple sold by mail order and at Jamison Farm in Pleasant Unity, Westmoreland County. The lower meats also were dolled up with spices in breakfast sausage.
“We wanted to open people’s eyes to how good it was,” she says.
Then the Food Channel came along, and more people became interested in unfamiliar food, stretching their concept of what constituted a good meal.
What they discovered was something the Jamisons have been preaching forever. Not only is this part of the lamb less expensive. Shanks — the meaty cut from the lower leg — and shoulder, cut from the top front leg of the lamb, can be extremely flavorful, too. You just have to cook it low and very slow as you would barbecue to make it tender.
“They can be braised, which is very easy cooking,” John says.
The couple also are apostles for ground lamb, which is made from scraps from the shoulder and leg. It can be rolled into meatballs for pita sandwiches, browned with Italian spices and vegetables to make pasta sauce, and be the star of the mashed potato-topped casserole known as shepherd’s pie.
As demonstrated in the Jamisons’ recently published cookbook, “Coyotes in the Pasture & Wolves at the Door,” it makes for a terrific burger, too.
The couple started offering cooking classes at their farm on 65 rolling acres 10 years ago.
Sukey gathered up her recipes and John was writing, too, committing to paper all of his favorite (and often funny) stories about the farm and the famous chefs and others they’d met over the years. (He met Jodie Foster when she was photographed, in a room at what is now the Omni William Penn, holding one of his baby lambs in the promo for the 1991 movie “Silence of the Lambs.”) Because if you don’t write them down, he says, “You forget them.”
Yet they wouldn’t start pulling the stories and recipes together into a cookbook until about two years ago. It was published last November.
The two dozen or so recipes are split between family favorites like a mushroom lamb stroganoff and meaty lamb pasta sauce their three kids grew up on, along with newer ones like lamb paprika. A riff on the chicken paprikash Sukey made when they were in college, they cooked the dish at the Pennsylvania Farm Show a couple of years ago, drawing lines of samplers.
There’s recipes for classics like boneless lamb loin roast, rack of lamb and roast leg of lamb, too.
Whatever you cook, choose lamb that’s a rosy pink color, says John; it’s a sign it’s not old. Jamison lamb is available at the East End Co-op in North Point Breeze or on their website, Prices range from $68 for six 1-pound packages of ground lamb to $78 for two shoulders to $88 for eight shanks.
“Or come to the farm,” he says. Their next Cooking Class 101 ($95) is on Aug. 17, and includes a multicourse dinner along with an evening of conversation.
The Jamisons will meet up with some old friends Aug. 8 when they serve their baby lamb with locally foraged chanterelles and local herbs a dinner celebrating the legacy of Jean-Louis Palladin at The Watergate Hotel in Washington, D.C. Jacques Pepin and Kingbird executive chef Sebastien Giannini will be doing the cooking, along with Palladin’s former executive sous chefs Jimmy Sneed and Larbi Dahrouch.
You can find the Jamisons’ cookbook at Mystery Lovers Book Shop in Oakmont, Riverstone Books in McCandless, and G Squared Gallery in Ligonier. It is also available online at amazon.com, jamisonfarm.com and wordassociation.com.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.
Best-Ever Lamb Burgers

PG tested
Ground lamb makes a terrific burger so long as you gently form the meat into patties. They pair especially well with blue cheese, and the Jamisons’ “secret sauce” adds even more appeal. But you can top the burgers with any of your favorite condiments.
2 pounds ground lamb
1 teaspoon salt
1 teaspoon coarsely ground pepper
¼ cup blue cheese
6 mixed-grain hamburger buns, sliced in half
Horseradish sauce (recipe follows)
Gently form ground lamb into 6 hamburger patties. Salt and pepper both sides of patties.
Preheat grill or grill pan on the stove top (if indoors). Cook burgers on hot grill, turning once, until burgers reach desired doneness, 4 to 6 minutes per side for medium rare.
Add cheese the last 2 minutes of cooking time. Toast the buns, cut side down, until golden, about 30 seconds. Assemble the hamburgers, garnishing them as you like them.
Makes 6 burgers.
— “Coyotes in the Pasture & Wolves at the Door” by John and Sukey Jamison (Word Association, Nov. 2018, $35)
Horseradish Sauce
PG tested
Sukey Jamison calls this peppery and mildly spicy white sauce her “secret sauce.” It’s great on a lamb burger. It makes a lot so I halved the recipe.
2 cups sour cream
1 cup mayonnaise
½ cup plain yogurt
5 ounces prepared horseradish
1 teaspoon salt, or to taste
1 teaspoon pepper, or to taste
Fresh parsley and basil chopped, to taste
Combine ingredients in food processor. Process until smooth. Check seasonings to taste. Chill in the fridge, for use on burgers or grilled leg of lamb.
Makes 3 cups.
Lamb Paprika

PG tested
This one-pot dish comes together quickly and is quite satisfying. You can serve the stew over rice or pasta.
2 slices Spanish onion
2 tablespoons olive oil
1 teaspoon sugar
½ teaspoon salt
½ teaspoon coarsely ground black pepper
½ teaspoon minced fresh basil
1 tablespoon sweet paprika
1 pound cubed lamb stew meat
2 bay leaves
¾ cup sour cream
Cooked pasta or rice, for serving.
Saute onions in olive oil in a large heavy pot over medium-high heat until onions are soft but not browned, about 10 to 15 minutes.
Add sugar, salt, pepper, basil and paprika, stirring until dissolved, about 5 minutes. Add lamb and bay leaves. Cover pan, bring to a simmer then reduce heat to low, and cook until the lamb is tender, 30 to 45 minutes. This may be prepared ahead to this point.
When ready to serve, add sour cream and reheat over low heat. Season with salt and pepper to taste.
Serve over pasta or rice.
Makes 4 servings.
— “Coyotes in the Pasture & Wolves at the Door” by John and Sukey Jamison (Word Association, Nov. 2018, $35)






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.