Laura Magone has been baking cookies with her mother, Wanda, and sister, Maria, for as long as she can remember. Being a Pittsburgher with Italian-American roots — all four of her grandparents were born in Italy — many of those homemade treats end up on a wedding reception cookie table when a loved one gets married.

It wasn’t until she started photographing cookies at weddings in her 20s and 30s, and got to view the custom from the other side of the table as a spectator, that she realized how much time, effort and planning went into the custom.

She remembers studying one especially pretty table in 1996 at a reception at the Valley Inn Fire Hall  in her hometown of Monongahela and thinking, “Wow, this is really a creation, a work of love that reflects the efforts that people pour into them.”

As a documentary filmmaker and historian, she realized there was a story to be told. It would take her until three years ago to figure out the best way to do it.

Advertise with us

That’s when she created a Facebook page, The Wedding Cookie Table Community. An open forum for lovers of all things cookie-related, it encourage its members to give and get advice on baking, assembling and sharing wedding cookie tables.

Any time she heard of a wedding, she’d go and take gratis pictures of the table, post them and wait for any responses. It took off like a rocket.

“You know how it goes,” she says. “Somebody tells somebody who tells somebody else.”

The group that started with just a few hundred members now has more than 10,000. And they’re not just from Western Pennsylvania or neighboring West Virginia and Ohio, but across the country, and even the world.

In bringing cookie lovers together online, Ms. Magone hopes to make everyone’s baking that much better. Members share recipes and photos, and they also ask and answer questions — often in real time. “They’ll  post in the middle of a cookie crisis, and others will come right back with a solution,” she says.

Advertise with us

Not that it’s all sunshine and butterflies: members can be very persnickety about ingredients and methods, and sometimes have to agree to disagree.

At its heart, the site is about creating fellowship, and preserving the family stories and ethnic traditions behind all those gorgeous peach cookies, lady locks and jam-filled thumbprints.

“Remember all those wonderful smells and feelings when you were little and baked with grandma?” Ms. Magone asked at the group’s first ever “cookie college” last month at the DoubleTree by Hilton, Meadowlands. “Those are the things we cherish,” she told them, and important to hand down to future generations.

She organized the event with help from the Monongahela Area Historical Society and Washington County Tourism Promotion Agency because people were clamoring to meet after so many virtual exchanges. She expected only a few dozen people to show up.  More than 300 crowded into the ballroom.

“We actually had to rush out and buy more cookies because we ran out,” Ms. Magone says, adding, “that’s humiliating.”

Advertise with us

Attendees got to learn a little cookie table history, listen to a panel discussion on how to prepare a cookie table, and watched demonstrations on cookie decorating from pros like Peg Lydic of Bethel Park, who’s famous in these parts for baking 21,000 cookies for her daughter’s 2010 wedding. They also got to see Julie Gustafson, Fox Chapel Golf Club’s banquet and catering manager, build a tray-free “cookie wave” table out of hundreds of cookies. They’re planning another event in the spring.

The group is such a success, Ms. Magone says, because there is something about the heart and spirit of  bakers. “They like to make other people happy.”

And cookie tables, she says, aren’t so much about the cookies  as the love behind it.

Ms. Magone points to October’s Tree of Life shooting in Squirrel Hill as an example. With two days’ notice, members showed up on a Saturday morning at Pittsburgh Police Bureau's Zone 4 station with trays bearing more than 2,000 cookies. They were distributed to various fire and EMS departments. And one tray went to the hospital room of the wounded officer.

“This is an amazing group,” she says.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.