Cucumber sandwiches were from a bygone day, often served at ladies’ teas. On buttered white bread, with crusts removed, they were sliced into dainty triangles. Sandwiches were stacked on tiered trays lined with doilies. And the ladies wore hats.
High tea at Omni William Penn
Since the mid-1980s, High Tea has been served in the Palm Court at this stately historic hotel in Downtown. Cucumber sandwiches are always available on request: (otherwise they contain smoked salmon). Chef Michael Fischetti described this classic and simple sandwich. Cream cheese flavored with lemon juice and chives is spread on pumpernickel, topped with thinly sliced cucumber that’s tossed with fresh dill and then another slice of pumpernickel. Crusts are cut off.
A traditional English-style cucumber sandwich is in the works, said food and beverage director Brian Annapolen, and is expected when the menu changes in mid-September. Slices of buttered (on the outside) Pullman loaf will be spread with mixed cream cheese and mayo and topped with sliced cucumbers. Tea is served 2:30 to 4 p.m. Monday through Saturday, and reservations are suggested. Call 412-281-7100.
“The Afternoon Tea Book” by Michael Smith presents a recipe for a “Nonsoggy” Victorian cucumber sandwich. First, sweet butter is mixed with heavy cream, a “tip of a teaspoon mild French mustard” and lemon juice. He says the cucumber must be cut as thin as possible, lightly salted and drained, then mixed with olive oil, lemon juice, a pinch of sugar and ground white pepper.
The butter mixture is spread over thin slices of white or brown bread which are “decrusted,” and then topped with cucumbers, another slice of buttered bread and cut into triangles.
That’s all lovely and tasty, yet a little fussy.
Instead, how about this rustic bolder sandwich built on bread you have to really chew. I’ve had a terrific cucumber year in my garden, thanks to all the rain. Crisp and sweet, cucumbers add moisture and snap to a simple sandwich; no salting or draining necessary.
At the supermarket, select small Persian cucumbers, not those seedy, waxed ones. If buying cukes at the farmers market or planning next year’s garden, choose thin-skinned, slender slicers or Kirby’s or the super-crispy white pickling cucumbers with little black spines that I just love.
I planted two types of these that I started to see a couple of years ago. One is called ‘Salt and Pepper’ and the other is a family heirloom from Kentucky called ‘Edmonson.’ If you’re used to green cukes in your garden they can be a bit startling, but much easier to find. I’m glad they’ve been reintroduced.
Just like cucumber sandwiches, everything old is new again. And sometimes, even better.
Miriam Rubin: mmmrubin@gmail.com or on Twitter @mmmrubin.
■

Cucumber Sandwiches With Feta Spread
PG tested
4 ounces (3/4 cup) good-quality feta cheese, finely crumbled
1/2 cup plain Greek yogurt
2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil
2 to 3 tablespoons snipped fresh chives
1 to 2 tablespoons snipped fresh dill
4 to 6 large slices rustic, sturdy bread
3 to 5 small pickling or slender, unwaxed slicing cucumbers, thinly sliced
Thin slices sweet red or white onion
Thin slices tomato, optional
Kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
In a medium bowl, mash feta with a fork. Mix in yogurt and oil and beat with fork until fairly smooth. Stir in chives and dill. Spread thickly on bread.
Top bread with overlapping cucumber slices, a few onion slices and tomatoes, if using. Season with salt and pepper. Serve immediately or refrigerate up to 1 hour.
— Miriam Rubin





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.