Tony Carbonara and his younger brother, John, know Italian food. They were born in a small town east of Naples, Italy, after all, and with seven sisters and a mother who loved to cook, some of the family’s culinary know-how was bound to rub off.

Many of the recipes they serve at Carbonara’s Ristorante, which Tony opened in 1991 on Mt. Lebanon Boulevard in Castle Shannon, are family favorites that have been handed down over the generations. In addition to house specialties such as veal piccata and chicken parmigiano, Carbonara’s menu includes pasta topped with homemade sauces that always begin with peeled tomatoes and other fresh ingredients and are never flavored with sugar, cornstarch or preservatives.

The all-natural spaghetti sauces have proved so popular that for years the restaurant has kept ready-to-go quarts in a cooler by the front door so that patrons could enjoy them at home. The restaurant’s soups also have been good sellers.

It’s Carbonara’s ruby-colored sauces, though, that added the title “entrepreneur” to the brothers’ list of accomplishments.

Advertise with us

They’ve sold so much of it over the years that 3½ years ago, after toying with the idea for two decades, they decided to branch out and commercially jar their most popular flavors and sell them in local groceries and specialty markets. Spurring them along was Janet Gralka of Bethel Park’s Uncommon Market. Her family had great success with jarring Labriola’s Italian Homestyle Pasta Sauce, and she felt the Carbonaras also had a product they could sell. She kept pestering: Why are you waiting? It’s not that hard!

Next thing the brothers knew, they were jarring.

First offered two years ago at Rollier’s Hardware in Mt. Lebanon, the sauces are now available in Giant Eagle and Shop ’n Save locations as well as other locations such as Bethel Park’s Uncommon Market, Trax Farms in Finleyville, Sunny Bridge Natural Foods in McMurray and Pennsylvania Macaroni in the Strip District.

The sauces, which come in 32-ounce jars, are available in three varieties: chunky tomato, marinara (each $8.95) and meat made with 100 percent ground chuck ($9.50). All the sauces wear a label created by Tony’s daughter Adrianna that depicts a picturesque street in the family’s rural hometown of Nusco in the Campania region, where the 11 Carbonara siblings and their parents lived on a small farm without running water or electricity. (John took the original picture.)

“People were always telling us, you should jar this stuff,” says Tony. “Everyone likes it.”

Advertise with us

This week, the brothers are expanding their offerings. Twelve-ounce bottles of Carbonara’s Italian salad dressing will join their sauces on store shelves at Giant Eagle. It will retail for $3.99 and bear the same charming family label.

Used to dress the restaurant’s house salads and sauce up many of its oven-baked hoagies, the gluten-free dressing also can be used as a marinade.

Converting a stove-top restaurant recipe into a FDA-compliant, commercial manufacturer’s formula is not the easiest process. Tony Carbonara said it took more than a year of tweaking, and a lot of sampling, to replicate the sauces in large-scale production.

“They had to have the same integrity,” says Tony, while at the same time not end up so expensive as to price themselves out of the gourmet market — a process that ultimately came down to cooking time. “We didn’t want to fill the jars with water.”

Persuading grocers to actually place the sauces, and now the dressing, on shelves where consumers could easily find it was another challenge. It’s up to each grocery manager to decide what goes where in the dog-eat-dog world of shelf placement.

Advertise with us

“Sometimes it’s in the bakery, or in front of meats, or in the sauce aisle,” he says. But no problem: If you can’t find it, “Ask for it,” he says.

When the brothers introduced the sauces in 2014, they made all the sales calls, deliveries and set up themselves, and John also did a lot of sampling; last year, they took on a distributor who’s now responsible for the heavy lifting.

At two to three times the cost of mass-produced national brands, Carbonara’s sauces aren’t cheap. What sets them and the new dressing apart from its competitors, says John, is that they include quality ingredients (“read the label,” he urges) and are ready to use. No cooking, mixing or fuss required.

“We believe in making food fresh and serving it fast,” he says.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.