With this year’s biggest holidays in the rearview mirror, it’s time to start using up leftovers. Got cheese?
I had a fridge drawer full of cheddar cheese chunks and bits, left over from an appetizer cheese board, and I converted them into a rich cheese sauce. It also could be a good candidate for part of a weeknight supper.
When cheddar sauce is ladled over toasted bread it becomes Welsh Rabbit. Pour it into that fondue pot you bought in the ’70s for a cheese fondue. Take it a step or two further to make a turkey Devonshire sandwich, which many restaurants offer on their menu, but it’s easy to make your own. The Devonshire also is a good way to use leftover turkey.
How Welsh Rabbit got its name is an old tale, and a good one. Seems that long ago when Welsh wives spied their husbands or sons across the field, returning from a hunt empty-handed, they quickly set some cheese before the fire to melt, as a substitute for a dinner of game. Welsh Rabbit is sometimes called Welsh Rarebit. Story there is that there was a time when appetizers were known as “forebits,” because they were served in advance, and the foods served at a meal’s end were called “rearbits,” which, when slurred, sounded like “rarebit.” Then there’s the Golden Buck, a rarebit served with a poached egg on top, and when porter, a dark style of beer, is mixed with Stilton or Cheshire cheese, you have a Scotch Rabbit. If you add tomato soup to the rarebit, it’s called a Blushing Bunny. The Brits and their semantics.
Whatever you call it, melted cheese is key, but the next key ingredient should be a common local beer — ale, porter, stout, lager. And beer will be the beverage of choice at the table.
Aside to nitpickers: The very first rarebit recipes go back to about 1750. And most of them include an endearing cooking “secret” that covers all the rarebit variations: “in heating whatever liquid is used, add cheese gradually and stir constantly with a wooden spoon in a single direction.” I have no idea why directional rotation is critical.
Fondue is usually made with a lighter cheese and wine. But Welsh Rabbit is equally delicious, and is great fun when a gang of folks set to dunking chunks of bread.
Aside to millennials: The Devonshire sandwich is an open-face, meal-on-a-plate created in Pittsburgh by the late Jim Blandi, long time owner of The Park Schenley restaurant in Oakland. It is a ’Burgh food icon up right up there with Isaly’s chipped ham and Primanti's fries on your sandwich. The Devonshire is built by stacking a generous slice (about one-third inch) of turkey breast draped over a toasted, thick slice of bread. A couple of tomato slices are next, then a hot, rich cheese sauce is poured over all. A sprinkling of chopped parsley is optional. Finally, top the dish with two crisp pieces of bacon. A restaurant would run the sandwich under the salamander just before serving, but at home, place the dish on a tray for easy handling, and set under the broiler just until the dish is hot and the cheese sauce is patched with scorchy brown spots.
To round out suppers, add a salad and maybe a baked apple and leftover Christmas cookies.
Marlene Parrish can be reached at marleneparrish@icloud.com or 412-481-1620.
■
Welsh Rabbit
PG tested
Use a good country-style bread, thickly sliced, to stand up to the flavor and creamy texture of the cheese sauce. Artisan cheeses can be inconsistent in their meltability, so use Kraft’s extra sharp Cracker Barrel cheddar for all or part of the amount of cheese, and I might throw in bits and bobs of other cheeses to make up the full amount. Veering from tradition, I always add a few ounces of Philadelphia brand cream cheese to insure a creamy sauce.
4 tablespoons butter, melted
4 egg yolks
1 cup beer
1 teaspoon dry English mustard
2 teaspoons Worcestershire
Cayenne to taste
1 pound sharp cheddar cheese, grated
2 ounces cream cheese, cut into small cubes
8 slices toasted sturdy bread
Have all ingredients ready at hand. Use a double boiler (if you don’t have one, put a bowl over a pot of simmering water, although this is the “hard way”). Place the top of the double boiler over barely boiling water (in the bottom part) and add melted butter.
In a small bowl, whisk together egg yolks, beer, mustard, Worcestershire and cayenne, and add that mixture to the butter. Let it get hot, but not boiling.
Then start adding grated cheese in handfuls, stirring constantly in one direction with a wooden spoon, until all the cheese has been added and mixture is creamy and smooth. Stir in the cream cheese and stir until combined.
Correct seasoning, if necessary. Place warm toasted bread in soup plates and ladle the cheese sauce on top. Serve right away.
Makes 4 servings.
— “The World of Cheese” by Evan Jones (Alfred A. Knopf; 1977)
■
Cheddar Cheese Fondue
Pour the Welsh Rabbit into a fondue dish set over a Sterno heat source to keep it warm. Cut a baguette into thick slices and then into quarters so that each piece has crust on one side. Surround the fondue with the bread and vegetables such as cauliflower and red pepper chunks. Everyone loves to dunk into the warm cheese sauce.
— Marlene Parrish
■
The Devonshire Sandwich
PG tested
The Devonshire is one of Pittsburgh’s finest inventions, a knife and fork open-face sandwich. With your mies en place at the ready, you can assemble the dish at the last minute. Have all the essentials ready to go including oven-safe, deep casserole-oval-shape dishes.
Welsh Rabbit cheese sauce, see above
Slices of good bread, toasted and kept warm
Slices of turkey, cut from the carcass (about ⅓ inch), never from the deli case
Slices of tomato, on the thin side
Slices of crisp bacon, 2 for each serving
Pour hot cheese sauce over top of toasted bread, sliced turkey and a couple of tomato slices. Garnish with slices of crisp bacon.
Makes 4 servings.
— Marlene Parrish





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.