On a recent icy Sunday evening, all of the businesses in the little alcove-like Manor Oak shopping center in Scott are dark, save one with warm, inviting light radiating from the windows of the dining room. Inside of Arpino Trattoria dozens of customers are laughing, eating, drinking, listening to holiday music and celebrating the season.

And, just a few steps back from that in a hot, cramped kitchen, chef Steve Goda is cursing like a sailor — appropriate as he’s an ex-Navy man — while his Popeye forearms toss and stir 40 covers worth of fresh pasta, bay scallops, shrimp and calamari into a light lobster sauce in a saute pan the size of a hubcap.

This is the very definition of a labor of love: Mr. Goda’s annual presentation of the Feast of the Seven Fishes, a traditional Italian-American Christmas celebration meal that has had a revival of sorts in Pittsburgh-area kitchens in recent years.

While nothing short of a bear to prepare quickly, this course of Taglioni Pescatore is well worth the trouble to share with his customers, who cherish it as part of their own family traditions.

Advertise with us

“My family does it, my wife’s family does it and we put together her seven and my seven, and we’d kind of split it,” he said of the meal they’ll prepare at home on Christmas.

At his restaurant, however, the idea is to kick off the holiday, as much as punctuate it.

“Here, a lot of these folks are regulars and a lot of them, they know each other. So tonight’s kind of a night to all get together at one time and hang out and relax. They’re here for three hours, and it’s kind of like they’re in their own living room or dining room,” he said, adding, “Wine doesn’t hurt.”

Here are six other local restaurants that have done, or are doing a Feast of the Seven Fishes and the chef’s pick for their favorite dish during the multi-course dinner.

Bar Marco

Advertise with us

Dish: Squid ink pasta with sea urchin and crab.

With no Italian background to speak of, chef Justin Steel was introduced to the fish tradition by his establishment’s namesake, Marco Enrico, who was his mentor at DeNunzio’s in Greensburg.

Monday will mark the fourth year of Bar Marco’s feast and Mr. Steel is excited to make a squid ink pasta — which could be spaghetti or bucatini — with a sea urchin sauce and crab meat.

“It’s going to be super rich, but delicious,” he said. “Sea urchin to me is like if you close your eyes and imagine what the ocean tastes like.”

Details: 6:30 p.m. Monday, 2216 Penn Ave., Strip District. $70, includes gratuity, wine pairing, 412-471-1900; http://​www.barmarcopgh.com/.

Advertise with us

Della Terra

Dish: Pesce al Cartoccio.

Chef Fiore Moletz isn’t yet sure which fish he’ll use for the main course of his holiday feast on Monday. It could be wild Lake Erie walleye (depending on availability), or a premium farm-raised branzino.

But he knows the preparation: cook in a paper bag with lemon, herbs and garlic.

“It’s a really good way to preserve the fish flavor and keep it moist, and permeate it with every aspect of the dish,” he explained.

Advertise with us

“With this prep you can really be able to control 50 dishes at one time, so you get perfectly cooked fish,” and added that the presentation is the fun part.

“It’s like sitting at table and opening a Christmas present, and with the beautiful aroma, it gets all the senses firing,” he said. “That’s how we like to cook here.”

Details: 6:30 p.m. Monday, 100 Perry Highway., Harmony. $70 plus $20 optional wine pairing, reservations required; 724-473-0630; http://​www.dellaterrapgh.com/.

La Tavola

Dish: Giuseppe’s Anchovy Sfinci.

Advertise with us

At La Tavola, among the first area restaurants to revive this traditional dinner seven years ago, chef Jolina Giamarita looks forward to this annual melding of tradition and technique.

“My parents are from Sicily, and this is definitely a southern Italian tradition,” she said. “But I like to challenge myself. We have a pretty traditional Italian menu at the restaurant, so for this I like to pull out the big guns a little bit. It’s a chance to shine and we get to have a really good time planning it.”

Her favorite is the anchovy sfinci.

“This is a really old-school dish. You put anchovy in the batter, and then it’s a deep fried dough, almost like a doughnut. My dad made them the first year, but he didn’t make a whole lot of them because he didn’t know how it would go over,” she said.

They were a huge hit.

Advertise with us

“Some people hadn’t had them in 40 or 50 years. They get super excited about them because their grandparents used to make them.”

Details: 6:30 tonight, 1 Boggs Ave., Mount Washington. BYOB; $75, reservations required; 412-215-4468; http://​latavolaitalianarestaurant.com.

Senti

Dish: Arancino Nero di Sepia

Despite growing up in Abruzzo, for the only Italian-born chef on this list it wasn’t until Franco Braccia came to the States that he was properly introduced to this Italian-American banquet.

Advertise with us

He now has one under his belt as a chef at Senti, the Lawrenceville restaurant he co-owns with his wife, Annette. This year, he’s looking to do some novel takes on fish dishes, including Arancino Nero di Sepia, or risotto balls made with sepia (or cuttlefish) ink.

“Usually in these dinners, it’s just fish. What I’m doing is incorporating the fish and the meat together,” he said. “[This] is made with risotto, the black ink of the sepia, and we add pork sausage. Between that and the vegetable sauce — and it will be served with fried calamari — this one, for me, is the best.”

Details: 5-10 p.m. Dec. 24, 3473 Butler St., Lawrenceville. $95, reservations suggested; 412-586-4347; http://​sentirestaurant.com/

Stagioni

Dish: Salted cod and cauliflower fritter.

Advertise with us

Though chef Stephen Felder is not at all averse to creative cooking, his favorite dish for this feast is straight nostalgia: a recipe that came from his wife Cara’s grandmother.

Mr. Felder calls his father-in-law, Ron DelSignore, a Green Tree native-turned-South Florida restaurateur who bears a resemblance to Michael Keaton, to go over the recipe specs and get his chops busted a little, as only an in-law can.

“We always make these, and every year I call him to get the exact ratio, and then he calls me afterward because he wants to know, ‘How’d the fritters turn out?’ And I’ll say, ‘They were good,’ and then he always says, ‘Yeah, but you’ll have the real ones on Christmas Eve.”

Details: 6 p.m., Sunday, 2104 E. Carson St., South Side. $40, full bar but corkage waived, reservations required; 412-586-4738; http://​stagionipgh.com/.

Vivo Kitchen

Advertise with us

Dish: Fried smelts.

This is the fourth year that Vivo will host this dinner, but for chef Sam DiBattista it’s been a lifelong tradition.

“We did it at home all the time when we were growing up, ever since I can remember, and we still do it with the family on Christmas Day,” he said.

“I’m not even necessarily sure what traditional really is — there’s a million ways to do this if you read up on it. Some will do 13 fish, some will do 20. We stick to seven.

“The fried smelts are, for me, something that just makes sense. I don’t even eat them the rest of year, but man, are they good this time of year with this meal.”

Advertise with us

Details: 3 and 6 p.m., Sunday, 432 Beaver St. Sewickley. $75, reservations required; 412-259-8945; http://​vivokitchen.com/.

Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412