Commercial kitchens aren’t for the faint of heart, especially when you’re the one who’s in charge.
Add being at the helm of a popular Downtown restaurant that serves as many as 300 people on a Saturday night, and the job’s even tougher.
Ten Penny’s new executive chef, Jamie Tavelaris, is up to the challenge. Not only can she stand the heat like a pro, she said, but the Rochester, N.Y., native actually thrives on the pressure.
Female chefs turn up the heat
Although Pittsburgh has more female head chefs than many cities, the field is still dominated by men.
Only 19.6 percent percent of chefs and head cooks are women, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the smallest percentage of women in any food industry job next to dishwasher.
They also earn $18,000 less a year than their male counterparts, according to the American Culinary Federation.
Still, women chefs in Pittsburgh are making their mark. In addition to the two featured here, the region boasts two-time semifinalist for the James Beard Foundation’s “Rising Star Chef of the Year” — Sonja Finn at Dinette in East Liberty — as well as Kristin Butterworth, the chef de cuisine at Lautrec at the Nemacolin Woodlands Resort in Farmington, Fayette County, which has southwestern Pennsylvania’s only Five Diamond AAA rating and a Five Star rating from Forbes.
“I get into my mood amid the chaotic,” says Ms. Tavelaris, 37, of Lawrenceville, who on May 1 took the reins at the busy restaurant near the David L. Lawrence Convention Center. “I get off on the stress.”
She’s preparing one of her menu’s best-sellers as she speaks, homemade ravioli filled with a savory mix of porcini mushrooms and buttery mascarpone cheese. Handmade pasta is her specialty, she noted, and watching her stretch, fill, fold, seal and then cut long, stuffed swaths of dough into delicate, ruffled squares proves it. Her fingers fly across the stainless-steel worktable, effortlessly. The results are perfect.
Cooked and tossed a few minutes later in a creamy porcini wine cream sauce perfumed with garlic, the ravioli speak to her love of upscale Italian food and the joy she finds in being creative.
“Even in gourmet restaurants, it can be hard to find handmade pasta,” she says, smiling proudly; in high-volume establishments such as Ten Penny, it’s almost unheard of.
Duck confit, which she warms to a crisp in a screeching hot pan as a topping for goat cheese-and-sage waffles, is another rare Pittsburgh offering. The French dish is time-consuming, and the way she serves it — slathered with house-made orange/pear marmalade and crowned with a sunny-side-up egg — requires so much prep (although it can be pulled together fairly quickly on the line).
All those flavors in one bite may sound funky. But the disparate ingredients somehow work in harmony and customers, she says, “are really digging it.” Just look at the way the spicy honey-maple syrup soaks so deliciously into the waffle’s nooks and crannies.
“People love comfort food,” she says. “It appeals to such a wide demographic.”
The pace at Ten Penny is demanding, and Ms. Tavelaris knows as a woman, she has to compete at the highest level — to be taken seriously as chefs, women have to work longer, she says, sustain pain better and generally out-perform their male counterparts in every area of the kitchen.
Bring it on. If people tell her she can’t do something, she says, “I’m like, ‘Oh, yeah?’ ”
Ms. Tavelaris’ style is a bit more traditional than that of predecessor Anthony Hruska, whose cooking had a distinct Asian flair. (He left to become executive chef of Social House Seven, an Izakaya-style restaurant opening later this year on Seventh Street in what used to be Bossa Nova.) Along with Italian, she tends toward regional American dishes that deliver an unexpected twist. She also loves Mediterranean food, the result of marrying a Greek man whose family was in the restaurant biz.
She never set out to be a chef, but dreamed instead of becoming a lawyer as a political science major at SUNY Brockport. Halfway through her junior year, however, she dropped out to open a 200-seat casual restaurant with her future husband. It didn’t take long until she was hooked.
“I just loved being in hospitality,” she says.
Front of house at first, Ms. Tavelaris soon developed a passion for the restaurant’s command center: the kitchen. Once she started cooking, she discovered that prepping, preparing and plating food not only was where the action was, but was fun — as she put it, “a great artistic experience.”
So while the marriage didn’t last, her love of restaurant work did.
“It’s a source of expression,” she says.
It also was incredibly draining. So much so, that after 10 years of running the restaurant, she checked out for a while to bartend and work as a certified personal trainer. It was, she said, her year of soul searching.
She considered resuming her legal studies, but decided that at age 30, with two small children to care for, it would take too long. Instead, she decided to move to Pittsburgh and enroll in the Art Institute’s dual culinary arts/management degree program. She did so well in her culinary lab classes that in 2014 she ended up a top-three finalist in an internship competition sponsored by the Food Network, losing, she says with a laugh, “to a lawyer from Costa Rica.”
To help make ends meet while she was in school, Ms. Tavelaris worked as executive chef at Industry Public House in Lawrenceville, an “insane” job she got quite by chance — she happened to be wearing her chef’s whites from school when she applied for a part-time bartending position.
In a field that breeds workaholics, Ms. Tavelaris displays a punishing work ethic. Fifteen-hour days aren’t uncommon, and unlike some executive chefs, she actually cooks alongside sous chef Art Shelton and line cooks Liz Long and Lawanda Cutler. A lot.
“I’m in the war zone with the boys,” she says. “You earn more respect that way.”
All the while she never steps out of her role as teacher, continually instructing her staff on how to properly do this or, more important, how not to do that.
She knows she’s tough. But she has to maintain high standards and besides, at the end of the day, her mothering instincts always kick in.
“It can’t always be pansies and posies, and I hold people accountable. But if I yell,” she says, “the next day I’ll build you back up.”
Ten Penny’s menu has changed pretty dramatically under her guard, but she said that’s part of the reason she was hired — they wanted to revamp and jazz up their offerings, and Ms. Tavelaris had great ideas to make that happen.
“I’ve been working on my menus since I was three years old,” she says. Even while she’s sleeping, her subconscious dreams about food.
One of the best aspects of her job, she says, besides the constant adrenaline rush, is the bond she has with her staff and the fact she loves being around them.
“They’re my family.”
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.