What does it take to make 2,000-plus finikias and koulourakias in 7 hours?

Plenty of willingness, time and effort, ability to get along and a good sense of humor — if you are the ladies of the Presentation of Christ (Ypapanti) Greek Orthodox Church in East Pittsburgh.

Since April, the group has been meeting in the church’s kitchen at Olympia Banquet Hall to make cookies, spanakopita and other treats for the four-day Ypapanti Greek Food Festival. The freezer is already half full with baklava, kourambiethes (butter cookies) and pastitsio (macaroni with beef and bechamel sauce).

The church is celebrating its centennial this year, and it’s the 32nd year for the festival, which will be held 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Thursday-Saturday and 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Sunday at the hall on 1575 Electric Ave. in East Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

“It’s the oldest church in Pittsburgh that has been on the same site all these years,” says Mary Doreza, co-chairman of the Ypapanti Greek Festival.

There’s a chairwoman for every type of cookie made for the festival, and on a warm day in June 10 women have gathered to take direction from Mary Papazis. The 82-year-old Murrysville native is an affable drillmaster when it comes to baking finikias (honey-spice cookies) and koulourakias (braided butter cookies).

A first batch of 380 finikias and 1,400 koulourakias were made earlier in the month but it was felt more were needed.

Mrs. Papazis has been in the kitchen since 8:30 in the morning, and the sugar-and-butter-Crisco-oil batter for the finikias is already well underway. Her helper is Tootie Pranis, whose job is to measure the flour, spices and sugar and add it to the mixer’s ginormous bowl.

Eggs are added next. Then goes in the orange juice with baking soda, and finally the flour — 63 cups of it, along with the baking powder, cinnamon and nutmeg. “Tootie is very good at this, and she does not miss count,” Mrs. Papazis says.

Advertise with us

Once Mrs. Papazis certifies that the dough is well blended, her granddaughters Paulina Neuschwander, 17, and Vanessa Kachulis, 24, help her to empty the mixture into a big bowl. She then quickly shapes a few finikias. “I know the dough is good when I can twist it and form it into shapes. If it’s too dry, it will crack. If it doesn’t have too much butter, you cannot shape it,” she says.

She then places them on a tray to be baked. Soon, an aromatic smell wafts through the kitchen and the cookies are taken out about 8 to 10 minutes later. Mrs. Papazis samples the first one and says, “It’s very tasty but I think it is undercooked.”

Lucy Koutsavlis, who is in charge of the oven, says the cookies are fine. “When warm, they will taste undercooked, so you have to let them cool down, and they will taste cooked,” she says.

Once they come to an agreement, a big bowl of dough is divided into smaller bowls and the other ladies are summoned to shape the finikias into oval shapes and press them against vases and plates with distinctive designs on them.

As the ladies shape the cookies and neatly place them on trays to be baked, conversations are all over the map from their pets to the Pirates’ games to the U.S. women’s soccer team’s performance.

Advertise with us

The baked finikias are dunked in hot honey syrup, made with water, honey, sugar, cinnamon sticks and lemon juice, and then sprinkled with ground walnuts and cinnamon.

“If you don’t add the lemon juice, the sugar will crystalize. And if you put too much honey, the syrup will get too thick and you cannot cut it,” Mrs. Koutsavlis says. ”I learned it the hard way when I made baklava.”

Mrs. Koutsavlis is of Irish origin and says she grew up on very plain food. “I never have had Greek food until I married my husband,” she adds. She is certified by the Allegheny County Health Department and so makes sure everything is done by health department regulations.

Meanwhile, Mrs. Papazis has already started preparing the batter for the koulourakias but checks in on the group to see how the finikias are coming along. “Beautiful,” she says to Tula Bargas. “That’s a big compliment, coming from Mary,” says Mrs. Bargas, laughing. The 79-year-old, who was born in Salonika, Greece, says, “My mother never made me cook. I learned it with time. But even if you never learned from your mother, you learn to do it like your mother.”

Nancy Russon has been quietly dunking the baked finikias into the honey syrup all this while. The decorative patterns on the finikias are not visible after the cookies are dipped in the honey syrup but that doesn’t bother Mrs. Russon. The cookies need those patterns so that they can absorb the syrup better, she says.

Advertise with us

At 88, she is the oldest in the group. “I plan to do this for a long time as I feel very strongly about the church,” she says.

When the last tray of finikias is taken out at 12:15 p.m., there is a call for a short potluck lunch. It’s the first time the ladies have sat down all morning. At 12:30 p.m., Mrs. Papazis ushers everyone back into the kitchen to twist the dough to make koulourakias.

The ladies roll out the dough like a cigarette, about 6 inches long, and make a horseshoe shape with it. It is then crossed over left to right and then right to left to make a twist.

Mrs. Papazis has made three huge bowls of dough for koulourakias, and there’s some grumbling about it. But that doesn’t stop the volunteers from doing the work at a clockwork pace. Before going into the oven, the koulourakias get brushed with egg wash and topped with sesame seeds.

Mrs. Koutsavlis takes her place in front of the oven again, and says she takes a lot of pride in doing the job. “I rotate the cookies, and see that the bottoms don’t burn and the top cooks as well as the bottom,” she says. “I don’t use a timer; it’s all by sight.”

Advertise with us

By 2 p.m. the ladies are getting tired. Mrs. Russon is still dunking the finikias in the honey syrup, when she suddenly turns around and tells the group: “Guess what I am making when I go home. Finikias!”

It sends the ladies into peals of laughter, and they get re-energized to finish what they started. But Mrs. Papazis is worn out and sits down, saying that her back is hurting. “I slept for only 15 minutes last night. I went to sleep at 6:30 a.m. and my alarm went off at 6:45 a.m.”

Even as she says that, she starts twisting more koulourakias. Her friend Josephine Markamtone joins to help her, and so does Mrs. Bargas. “I am tired but I am grateful for all the help I have,” Mrs. Papazis says.

The rubbing, twisting, rolling and baking of koulourakias finally come to end at 3:25 p.m. The cookies are counted and the group finds out it made 550 finikias and 1,600 koulourakias for the day.

“I am happy we are done,” Mrs. Papazis says. “It was a success, and I got the yield I anticipated.”

Advertise with us

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1494 or on Twitter @asub

■

Finikia

1⅓ cups oil

3/4 cup butter

Advertise with us

3/4 cup Crisco

3/4 cup sugar

2 eggs

1/2 teaspoon baking soda

5/8 cup orange juice

Advertise with us

7¾ cups flour

2½ teaspoon baking powder

1/2 teaspoon cinnamon

1/8 teaspoon nutmeg

In mixer, blend oil, butter and Crisco together well.

Advertise with us

Add sugar slowly, beating until blended. Then add eggs.

In a small bowl, add baking soda to orange juice and stir. Be careful, as the juice will rise and may overflow.

Add juice to sugar-butter mix, and blend well.

Sift flour, baking powder, cinnamon and nutmeg in separate bowl, and add slowly to mixer. You might have to remove dough from the mixer and knead it on the counter until blended.

Roll cookies into small football shapes, about 2 ½ to 3 inches long. Then press them against a designed dish or vase or cheese grater. Place on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper.

Advertise with us

Bake at 365 degrees for about 25 minutes, or until lightly browned.

For syrup:

2½ cups water

2 cups sugar

3 squeezes of lemon

Advertise with us

1 cinnamon stick

1/2 cup honey

Ground walnuts

Cinnamon powder

Bring to boil the first 4 ingredients and then simmer for 15 minutes.

Advertise with us

Add honey and simmer for another 8 minutes.

Dip cooled cookies into simmering syrup for about 1 minute.

Remove cookies and place them on a rack to cool. Finally, sprinkle cookies with a little cinnamon and ground walnuts.

— Mary Papazis

■

Advertise with us

Koulourakia

Makes approximately 160 cookies.

1 pound unsalted butter

2 cups sugar

12 egg yolks

Advertise with us

2 teaspoons vanilla

1 teaspoon baking soda

1 cup orange juice

5 teaspoons baking powder

9 cups flour

2 eggs, beaten

Sesame seeds for topping

In mixer, beat butter until light and fluffy. Add sugar, and beat until blended.

Add egg yolks and vanilla; mix well.

In a cup, stir baking soda into orange juice; then add to mixer.

Add baking powder and add flour by the cup. Mix dough until it is in a consistency where it can be shaped. You may have to remove dough onto a floured counter and knead it.

Twist dough into a braid. Then brush cookie with egg wash. Top it with sesame seeds.

Place on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper and bake at 350 degrees for about 20 to 25 minutes or until lightly browned.

— Mary Papazis