MODENA, Italy -- “This is not just vinegar. This is balsamic. They are not the same,” Daniele Barbieri said when I visited his family’s Acetaia del Cristo in this Northern Italian city last fall. I heard him, but I was also engaged, engrossed in the parade of flavors in my mouth.
Mr. Barbieri had suggested that I stick my pinkie inside a 165-year-old juniper-wood barrel. I did, coating my finger with thick, mahogany-black fluid. I tasted it: sweet, lush, acidic, alpine.
“You will taste that for a long time,” he said.
Turns out, everything about real balsamic vinegar is long, from its history to its flavor. But it didn’t take me long during my visit here to learn something about the different categories of balsamic and to appreciate the best of it.
Traces of the importance of vinegar to the Emilia-Romagna province date back through at least 1046 AD when villagers in nearby Reggio Emilia presented a bottle of their prized product to the future Holy Roman Emperor Henry (Enrico) III.
Today, nearly 4,000 families in the region produce bottles of balsamic vinegar for home use. “This product is so special, and it has a peculiar quality and taste to each house. Every family thinks their balsamic is the best in the world,” says Giuseppe Pedroni III. He runs Acetaia Pedroni with his father, Italio. The Pedroni family opened their roadside tavern in Modena in 1862.
Balsamic vinegar in the United States was a hyper-niche product until Chuck Williams (he of Williams-Sonoma) imported the first commercial shipment to the United States in 1977. It’s now become a ubiquitous product on store shelves and as a go-to, must-have vinaigrette mixer, but what many of us think is balsamic vinegar and what is the “real” balsamic are two very different products.
“Between A and Z there is everything,” says Mr. Pedroni, who has a particular disdain for marketing firms that make flavored balsamic vinegar. “But just because you can have everything, that doesn’t mean you should do it. Fruits and vegetables should be in your salad, not your vinegar.”
At the low end, there is commercial vinegar, which is nearly always produced on an industrial scale. It’s labeled as “condiment vinegar,” “Balsamic Vinegar of Modena” or simply “balsamic vinegar,” and it could be made anywhere, not necessarily in Italy. It’s mostly wine vinegar, with grape must, sugar and colorants thrown in the mix. Mr. Pedroni calls it “a borderline product.”
At the high end, however, there are rules — geographical indications — for how balsamic vinegars may be labeled, now codified by both Italy and the European Union. The rarest can be labeled Denominazione Origine Protetta (DOP), and Mr. Barbieri and Mr. Pedroni produce products that meet the standards of that designation.
The DOP way
The production of DOP balsamic vinegar is a deceptively simple one: It’s simply grape juice that is reduced, inoculated with bacteria and left to age in wood barrels. That simplicity belies its complexity, however. The finest balsamic vinegars are the product of a tightly regulated process.
In 1979, the Consortium of Producers of Traditional Balsamic Vinegar of Modena was established to, as Mr. Pedroni says, “protect the integrity of what we do.”
“We have always maintained the tradition of family and culture. Now it’s our generation’s turn to preserve and share it with the rest of the world. This is my mission,” Mr. Barbieri says.
Mr. Barbieri’s family began producing balsamic vinegar in 1848 — the barrel I tasted was one of the earliest in the family’s production line — but he and his cousins are the first generation to make it a commercial operation.
“We start with only one ingredient: grape must,” says Mr. Barbieri.
Only grapes traditionally grown in Reggio Emilia — primarily Trebbiano and Lambrusco — are allowed to age into DOP balsamic vinegar.
The grapes are harvested in the autumn, pressed and filtered. The pressed liquids are then reduced by nearly 50 percent over a slow-burning fire.
“We only have a few options [from] here. You can decide how long it will age, provided it is at least 12 years. You can decide where it will age. And can decide the type of raw material — which wood you choose for the barrel — to age it in,” says Mr. Pedroni.
The choice of building materials — using concrete or using wood flooring, for example — gives the product of each acetaia unique characteristics. A sunny location will produce a warmer room than a shady location, and that will speed up the process of acidification and evaporation. The room at Acetaia Pedroni where vinegar is aged 25 years and longer was noticeably cooler than the room where those destined for a bottle after 12 years are aged.
Unlike bourbon, though, the specific location of a barrel within the acetaia has only a limited effect on the final product. “The difference here is not that great,” says Mr. Pedroni.
What does makes all the difference — and what separates DOP balsamic vinegar from any other vinegar in the world — is the batterie of barrels.
There are seven accepted woods: chestnut, oak, cherry, mulberry, juniper, ash and acacia (the last two are less aromatic and less common). The cooked, bacteria-rich liquid must age for a minimum of 12 years in a batterie of five to seven barrels of decreasing size.
“The choice of barrel, the blend of barrels, is of utmost importance,” says Mr. Pedroni.
After 12 years the bacteria die and the acidification process ends. However, the vinegar will continue to reduce, oxidize and mellow after that.
Mr. Barbieri says that at 25 years (the other standardized age for bottling), “the acidic part and the sweet part are now dialed together. The sugar is more concentrated and the molecules are bound together.”
Barrels all have rectangles cut from the top — covered with a cloth to keep the flies out — to allow for oxygenation. While most other vinegars ferment in tightly controlled environments, it’s the oxygenated airflow and seasonal temperature changes that give the balsamic its characteristic, almost rust-like, bass notes. In process and flavor, balsamic has more in common with sherry or Madeira wines than to rice-wine or apple-cider vinegar.
Every winter — that’s when the bacteria are the least active — 1 liter of balsamic is bottled from the smallest barrel in each batterie. That barrel is refilled with a liter from the next-smallest barrel, that one refilled from the one before it, and on and on.
Barrels can come from anywhere in the world as long as they are made of one of the seven accepted woods. At Mr. Barbieri’s acetaia, there was even a barrel of Pennsylvania oak from Keystone Cooperage in Jefferson.
Some barrels in both the del Cristo and Pedroni batteries are more than 100 years old. These antique barrels are so precious that if one starts to leak, rather than replace it, another barrel is placed around it. Traces of vinegar more than 150 years old were swirling around in that juniper barrel that I stuck my pinkie in. “When you refill a barrel for 100 years there is just so much concentration. What’s inside those barrels is so special. The character of the barrel is priceless,” says Mr. Barbieri.
Oak contributes to flavors that will resonate with whiskey drinkers, cherry is tart and sweet, juniper pungent and herbaceous. “It’s very resinous,” says Mr. Pedroni after sharing a sample of a 12-year juniper.
“This wood produces a taste that is most peculiar. Some people think this is very nice, other people don’t enjoy it at all.”
How to buy it
Mr. Pedroni and Mr. Barbieri say that with all the poor imitations on the market, it’s important to make sure that, if you’re going to spend a lot of money on something special, you’re buying the DOP balsamic.
“People see a nice storefront with nice-looking bottles, and they buy these products. They get used to the flavor [of the cheaper stuff] and think, ‘This is balsamic vinegar.’ But that isn’t true,” says Mr. Pedroni.
For example, Indicazione Geografica Tipica, or IGT, balsamic vinegars are produced under a standardized set of criteria that are less rigorous than DOP. They are a mix of wine vinegar and grape must, and the contents of the whole barrel (which need not be one of the seven woods) are filtered and used for bottling.
“It can be anything. Sometimes they are very good, and sometimes they are not,” says Mr. Pedroni.
“Never use something that’s not at least IGP,” says Mr. Barbieri. But, he cautions, you should still be a smart shopper because, “even with the IGP a lot of them are trash.”
Mr. Pedroni does think that a well-made IGP balsamic has a place in the cupboard and that, for marinades and salad dressings, it is a better product to use than the DOP balsamic. “When you are mixing it with the fat of a good olive oil, you want something with bright, sour acidity.”
But there’s one thing that IGP can’t do. “It is impossible for an IGP product to become a DOP product. They are totally different. It is impossible,” he says.
There also is condimento-grade balsamic, which is sometimes a well-produced or family reserve balsamic that didn’t pass through the consortium for a DOP label, but sometimes is a commercial-grade balsamic with a fancy label on it.
Here in Pittsburgh, Rick Sunseri of Pennsylvania Macaroni Co. in the Strip District says that the balsamic market can sometimes be tricky to navigate. “Yes, DOP is the good stuff. But in my opinion, is there other good stuff? Yes. Definitely.”
In fact, he sells a condimento bottle of balsamic from the Reggio Emilia Acetaia F.lli. Gorrieri that’s nearly as complex and nuanced as the red-label DOP (made under basically the same rules as in neighboring Modena) from the same producer, but it sells for just one-fifth the price ($29.95 for 200-milliliter bottle vs. $73 for a 100-milliter bottle). He also stocks an IGP from Fattoria Estense (Invecchiato, $26.95 for 250-milliliter bottle) that is intensely sweet and sour, with resonant notes of prune.
Mr. Sunseri says that finding the right balsamic vinegar can be confusing, and that the best thing to do until you find your favorite bottles is to do exactly what I did: ask. One of the best things about having a store like Penn Mac is the opportunity for guidance from a top-notch staff that can point you in the right direction.
If you’re looking for something memorable, seek out bottles with the DOP label and the Modena consortium standardized 100-millilter Giorgetto Giugiaro sphere design (or the Reggio Emilia tulip design) to keep for special occasions. It’s a pricey but worthwhile addition to your kitchen pantry.
How to use the good stuff
How best to enjoy DOP balsamic is another divergence from run-of-the-mill vinegar.
“Balsamic is for the dish, not for the fire,” says Mr. Pedroni. That is, for finishing dishes, not for cooking them.
A few drops of balsamic aged in cherry turns vanilla ice cream into a jubilee of flavors. Chestnut-aged on strawberries will make the months between strawberry seasons haunt your dreams. Juniper-drizzled grilled beef and lamb are transcendent. Mulberry would add a fruity shine to a cocktail.
Or simply enjoy it pure, dropped onto a ceramic spoon. The pure, cool nature of the ceramic allows the essence of the vinegar to shine. According to Mr. Barbieri, Michael Douglas, who, along with Queen Elizabeth II of England, has a private batterie at Acetaia del Cristo, “drinks it every day like a digestive. Always he wants it on the table.
“This product, this tradition of our region that has lasted in families for hundreds of years, this is so special,” says Mr. Barbieri as he savors a spoonful of the 50-year-old mix of oak and chestnut aged. “This is not vinegar. This,” he swallows, he smiles, and his eyes go bright, “this is balsamic!”
Hal B. Klein: thismanskitchen@gmail.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.