My favorite ice cream memory is from Youngstown, Ohio, home of the original Handel's Ice Cream on the South Side. Adults were smitten with the chocolate laden with whole pecans or pistachios. A kid's standard order was chocolate marshmallow, with its stripe of sugary white. Even a pup would wait in anticipation for a vanilla doggie cone.
Ice cream is one of the ephemeral treats of summer, literally so, as ice cream melts down a cone on a hot summer night. Falling within the comfort-food genre, ice cream is associated with an American childhood.
And it's having a renaissance, especially artisan ice cream made of the purest ingredients. Without fillers or corn starch, the base is just milk, cream, eggs and sugar.
In some circles, ice cream of memories is melting away, as bucolic imagery and classic flavors are set aside for quirky ingredients and incendiary marketing, filled with culture-vulture references, sexual innuendo and a glorification of the underbelly.
Take The Icecreamists, founded by United Kingdom resident Matt O'Connor and partner Frank Frederick. In the cookbook of the same name, Mr. O'Connor declares in bombastic fashion how ice cream offers no better medium "to celebrate the culture of addiction."
The book is ablaze with punk-rock imagery and seductive pics as well as the story of how the shop gained infamy with The Sex Pistol ice cream cocktail, made with a "natural stimulant" ice cream and a shot of absinthe served by a sexy nurse with an intravenous drip. The stimulant, it turns out, is ginkgo biloba, arginine and guarana.
The crew staged their second incident in 2011, with the introduction of breast-milk ice cream dubbed "Baby Gaga," which ended up making international headlines when more than 300 women donated their breast milk and Lady Gaga protested the name.
The kerfuffle threatened to bankrupt the Icecreamists, who have since dialed back, though they remain "a theatrically minded troupe of provocateurs and cold warriors, hopelessly foul-mouthed, anti-Establishment, and politically incorrect."
Past recipes for standard vanilla and chocolate -- renamed Vanilla Monologues and Choc and Awe -- lie Carameltdown (dulce de leche); Smack, Crack and Pop (popcorn); Black Ice (licorice); and Cold Sweat (chile, ginger, and lemongrass) with instructions that include plenty of outrageous and sophomoric asides. Sections on sorbetto, cocktails, sundaes and desserts follow, named for references both witty and absurd.
Aside from its aesthetic, the book is among the best how-to's I've used for making ice cream.
In a section called "The Alchemy of Ice Cream," Mr. O'Connor emphasizes process. In the tempering, don't allow the mixture to heat over 185 degrees or until you see bubbles. Let it cool at room temperature for 30 minutes, or 20 with the pan cooled in an ice bath.
Once the mixture has chilled overnight, he suggests whipping ice cream for 20 to 60 minutes. This makes sense, as ice cream is comprised of milk fat, dairy solids and, yes, air. This differs from gelato, which has a lower fat content, few to no eggs and less air.
A 45- to 60-minute whip creates a luxurious ice cream. But the real work is in the freezing. In the "beat me" section -- among subheads such as "choose me," "chill me" and "whip me" -- Mr. Connor suggests removing ice cream from the freezer after 50 minutes, beating it with the mixer or immersion blender to remove ice crystals, then doing so every 30 minutes for two to three hours.
Perhaps it's no surprise this method transforms ice cream from nostalgia to lust. If you're at all curious, buy the book (or make the accompanying recipes).
Compare "The Icecreamists" to San Francisco's "Humphry Slocombe Ice Cream Book," the 2012 cookbook from founder Jake Godby, Sean Vahey and Paolo Lucchesi. Having opened his first shop in the Mission District in 2008, Mr. Godby assembled the name from Mr. Humphries and Mrs. Slocombe, characters on the British sitcom, "Are You Being Served?"
"Loosely following the 'how to come up with your drag queen name' formula of taking references from your past and putting them together to come up with a name," they wrote, "we combined the names of two of our favorite characters on a show."
Since the shop opened, Mr. Godby -- a pastry chef at Zuni, Fifth Floor and Coi until 2006 -- has enthralled and offended ice cream aficionados. Let's face it: flavors named Government Cheese, Hot Mess, Tranny Smackdown and Fetal Kitten sound like the tasting menu for a death-metal band.
But Mr. Godby's droll irreverence has built quite a following. "We can't promise you your money back," reads the first paragraph, "and in fact have probably already spent it on pills and liquor, but if you don't like the ice cream, we will eat a bug."
Such a menu was designed to puncture menu boredom and "irritation with the orthodoxy governing how we're all supposed to eat (local, sustainable, organic, etc.)" reported The New York Times Magazine in an article on the shop in 2010.
Not all flavors are designed for disgust. Though Mr. Godby won't pair strawberries with rhubarb, he will make Harvey Milk and Honey, named for the gay California icon; Strawberry Candied jalapeno, Cinnamon Brittle and Peanut Butter Curry (think of this one akin to Thai massaman sauce). For posterity, Mr. Godby includes classics such as "Here's Your Damn Chocolate Ice Cream."
Unlike in "The Icecreamists," in this book, adding air to ice cream is a bigger variable. Regarding "How to make ice cream without a machine," where Mr. Godby instructs readers to find a blunt instrument from the kitchen and vigorously mix the contents of a pan every 15 minutes for about an hour.
I quite like the idea of the beat down, but I'm guessing it makes for a less luxurious product.
Elsewhere in the book the process instructions are more lax, too. Cover the bowl and refrigerate for at least an hour or preferably overnight, reads the Harvey Milk recipe. And "transfer it to an ice-cream maker and spin according to manufacturer's instructions."
In short: I love the flavor profiles of Humphry Slocombe, but prefer the instruction of The Icecreamists.
These books have lent fun to ice-cream making, though I look forward to buying it in Pittsburgh shops with attitude.
In the meantime, whether it's strawberry or sausage ice cream you crave, "Make a base, go crazy," writes Mr. Godby.
"There are really only a few ingredients and as with all cooking -- and life? -- the quality of what you start with is reflected in the finished product."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.