When I first was learning to cook, I followed recipes to the letter, slavishly attentive to every ingredient, step and description. Fifteen or so years later, after culinary school, five years of professional food writing and many more hours in the kitchen, I sometimes wonder exactly what I was so determined to avoid. Did I think that every recipe I tried was the best possible version of itself? That if I made a single change, I risked winding up with an inedible mess?

Fear of failure hampers many cooks and even more would-be cooks. But the truth is, if you are an adventurous, frequent cook, no matter how experienced, you will make mistakes.

Most will be mundane: underseasoned meat, too-spicy chili, overcooked broccoli. Occasionally, there may be more memorable disasters.

My personal favorite was an olive oil cake I decided to bake for a Hanukkah party in 2006. The recipe [see below] came from a respected cookbook, but I'd never made it, and I doubt I read it closely before throwing the batter together at the last minute. About 20 minutes later, the cake exploded in our oven. The recipe called for a combined 3/4 cup of baking soda and powder. In hindsight, I can't believe I went ahead with the recipe, but I was making too many new dishes in too little time, and common sense had clearly deserted me.

Advertise with us

Several years later, I was making ricotta gnocchi from a favorite chef's cookbook for a dinner party. I noted that it called for a surprisingly large quantity of salt. As I measured it out, I thought again, "Wow, that is a lot of salt." But did I add less, then taste it to check? No, I did not. I dumped it in, stirred up the mixture, and only then took a bite, which I promptly spit out.

I may have wanted to splatter that gnocchi mixture against a wall, but instead I took a deep breath, raced to the grocery store and bought another pound of ricotta so I could double the recipe, minus the salt. As I recall, dinner was a little late that night.

I'm far from the only food writer guilty of making a new recipe for guests. Bob Batz Jr. will never forget trying to impress his friends by making, from Anne Willan's "The Country Cooking of France," several recipes at once, including one for Baeckeoffe, an Alsatian meat and potato casserole. Hurrying, he dumped the entree's marinade down the sink before realizing he should have reserved the liquid. And the casserole took so long to bake that guests literally were falling asleep.

But it turned out delicious, as did the vegetables (sans mushrooms that he'd forgotten to buy) and dessert (lemon tart that he left in the oven too long).

Just a few weeks ago, Post-Gazette food writer Gretchen McKay went to the grocery store to pick up gluten-free flour for a recipe she was testing. The batter didn't look right, but she put that off to her inexperience with gluten-free baking. When the muffins came out of the oven, they were sunken, heavy and totally unappetizing. She looked at the bag and realized that she'd accidentally bought a bag of gluten.

Advertise with us

Those moments of discovery may be full of frustration, but they inevitably become favorite stories over time, especially for innocent bystanders.

Marlene Parrish, former Post-Gazette staffer and frequent contributor, acknowledges many tempestuous cakes over the years, as well as a troubled history with sugar syrups, but her favorite kitchen mishap involved a relative cooking her first Thanksgiving turkey.

"I was keeping her company in the kitchen while she prepped the bird," she recalled. "She made bread stuffing. That's it. Just cubes of stale bread. She started to push the stuffing into the neck cavity. When the space got full, she loosened some breast skin and packed the bread under the skin. I mentioned that maybe some of the stuffing could go in that, you know, very large space in the cavity of the turkey. 'Oh, no,' she said firmly. 'This is my mother's stuffing recipe, and this is the way she always did it.' And into the oven it went. When the turkey was done, it resembled either a winged, double-hump dromedary or a turkey afflicted with a goiter. Funniest thing you ever saw. And her mother laughed until she had tears in her eyes."

Virginia Phillips, co-president of Slow Food Pittsburgh and a frequent contributor to the PG food section, has had more trouble protecting her desserts until they actually make it to the table. Her most memorable mistakes included "Baked Alaska's meringue sliding floorward over the counter edge (caught by my mother-in-law)" and "a prune cake heaved into the hedge."

Her favorite culinary disaster story, however, involved a boned turkey breast that she was preparing for an important Slow Food Pittsburgh meeting. She happened to be out of the kitchen as it was finished up by "trusted lieutenants." The recipe instructed that the turkey rolls be dusted with baking soda, but instead the helpers enthusiastically covered them in a thick layer of the white powder. Fortunately, "cooler heads prevailed," and they rinsed off the rolls and brushed them with olive oil. They were returned to the oven and "emerged bronzed and fabulous," Ms. Phillips said, saved from certain disaster.

Advertise with us

Cook frequently and errors are bound to ensue, but who cares? Cooking is about getting your hands dirty, and if things never went wrong, we would never learn. Let fear rule your kitchen and you're doomed to a lot of boring dinners. So dive in, and remember that olive oil cake is delicious, and it makes a much better story when it explodes.

Extra-Virgin Olive Oil Cake

PG tested

This simple, delicious cake is a great summer staple. Hardy enough to transport to pot-lucks and picnics, it goes great with all kinds of summer fruit. -- China Millman

  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 1 tablespoon baking powder
  • Pinch of salt
  • 1 1/2 cups sugar
  • 4 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup orange juice
  • 3/4 cup extra-virgin olive oil
  • 3/4 teaspoon vanilla extract

Heat the oven to 350 degrees. Spray a 9- or 10-inch cake pan with vegetable oil spray or lightly oil it. Cut a piece of parchment to fit the bottom of the pan and lightly spray or oil it.

Advertise with us

In a small bowl, whisk together the flour, baking powder and salt. In a large bowl, whisk the sugar and eggs until the color lightens somewhat. Add the orange juice, olive oil and vanilla extract and whisk to combine.

Add the flour mixture in three additions, mixing well between each one. Pour the batter into the prepared pan and bake until a toothpick inserted toward the middle of the cake comes out clean, 45 to 50 minutes. Let cool on a rack for 10 minutes and then invert the cake onto a cooling rack. Wrap in plastic wrap when completely cool. The cake will keep for about 2 days. It also freezes really well wrapped in plastic wrap.

Serves 10.

-- From "New Italian Cooking" by Scott Conant (Broadway Books, 2005, $35)