Scary. That's definitely what it was when Sherri Panza and I pulled up at our favorite diner in Kutztown -- Letterman's -- and spotted the "For Sale" sign.
We'd made the dash to Eastern Pennsylvania to celebrate our daughter's birthday before she graduates from college and heads to New York. And even though my daughter was moving on, Letterman's is only about 15 minutes off the road to New York for future trips.
Letterman's is one of the best down-and-dirty breakfast places I have found, and I have recommended to many. There one can enjoy watching the Paganini of the griddle dish up remarkable platters of breakfast items.
As I tucked into the last few bites of an improbable meat and cheese omelet featuring a tangy barbecue sauce, I broached the subject when the master turned from the mountains of hashed brown potatoes. He laughed and explained that he'd put the sign up only to spark conversation, riling more than a few dedicated diners at the 1920s relic.
"Ahhhhhhhh," I sighed.
Joe Bastianich's new book "Restaurant Man" claims that in New York, the appearance of an "under renovation" can mean it's over. And yours truly recently saw it happen at another Eastern Pennsylvania diner, which I keep hoping will somehow renovate itself and reopen.
How many of our favorite restaurants just disappear? One day they exist and the next time you visit, the sign is gone.
That happened to Dine and Sherri on a trip up to the Windy City, on which we planned on barbecue at a restaurant north of Indy of Interstate 65. It's no longer there. The building appeared to have turned into a discount store.
There was another choice up the road -- South Street Smokehouse at Lafayette -- but then the worrying started. What if it is gone, too? No piles of rib tips with choice of six sauces. No fried wedges of pecan pie with dipping sauce. No rich and bracing greens and no gooey mac and cheese.
But it was there. We had a new appreciation for the idea that you don't know what you've got until it's gone. It has happened many times.
Someone always asks, "Did you go to the fried fish place?" "What about those Chinese dumplings?"
And after living for a number of years in Israel and having had to answer the question, "Doesn't Abu Shukri have the best hummus in the world?" I finally made the trek to the place on a recent holiday just to be able to say yes or no. (I thought it was good.)
It was this bothersome type of question that hit me again recently, just before a trip to pick up a new puppy in Chicago:
"Had I ever eaten a burger at Thurman Cafe, the Columbus joint that's been on all the food TV shows?"
Sherri Panza and I lived in Ohio's capital city in the early 1980s, when she worked for the state health department and I taught photojournalism at Ohio State University.
I also held down at kitchen job at Lindey's, a quasi-French-New Orleans bistro in my German Village neighborhood, but I had never had a burger at the Thurman, which was only a couple of blocks from our house. Drank beer there, yes, after covering football, but I never took notice of the burgers, not my thing in those days.
So, here we were heading to Chicago to pick up our new puppy -- a rescued black spitz who, with his brothers and sisters, was moved from Alabama by the American Eskimo Dog Rescue Association.
Pulling off Interstate 70 in Columbus, we rolled past our old house (thanks for the memories) and turned the corner onto Thurman Avenue. It seemed less dicey than in our day. We found that the eatery's newfound popularity came with a 45-minute wait. But that went by in the blink of an eye and we were seated at a small table, from which we could see improbable amounts of food make their way from kitchen to wide-eyed customers.
My target was the Thurman Burger: Three-quarters of a pound of really good beef, topped with a stack of sauteed ham, three kinds of cheese and sauteed onions and mushrooms. It was filled with a beefy good taste that made me question why I didn't order the double patty version, which the next table was enjoying.
It made me wish I'd had a burger fetish 30 years ago. But in those days I was all about Chinese food.
The Thurman Cafe does more than just burgers. A 1-pound chili dog, topped with onions became the challenge facing Sherri, who after offering me a couple of inches, wolfed down the terrific tube steak and gave it a thumbs-up for good smoky flavor and an excellent chili.
So, we finally got to fill our bellies at the Thurman Cafe before that improbable time that it leaves the decades-old control of its owners and becomes modern and spiffy and loses that certain something that makes a neighborhood joint something to be treasured.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.