How much should we eat? This seems like a simple question with a simple answer. But in a nation where two-thirds of adults are either overweight or obese better guidance is clearly needed.

One of the most common suggestions for losing weight or maintaining a healthful weight is to eat smaller portions. There are few nutritional concepts as vague, however, as "portion." How much a person should eat depends on so many factors -- how is anyone supposed to know whether three slices of pizza or a large bowl of salad is too small, too big or just right?

Knowing more about the nutritional content of different foods can help and many people use nutritional labels to make those purchasing decisions. In 2008, when the Food and Drug Administration conducted its most recent Health and Diet survey, 77 percent of consumers said that they consult a label the first time they buy a product. Unfortunately, FDA rules for determining and listing the serving size of products often lead to confusing and misleading information.

Last year, the Center for Science in the Public Interest, a nonprofit consumer watchdog agency, issued a report highlighting the worst serving-size offenders. Foods with the most misleading serving sizes included canned soups, ice cream and nonfat cooking sprays, many of which exploit legal loopholes to make their products appear more healthful than they are. One of the center's biggest concerns, said senior nutritionist Jayne Hurley, is that "the portion sizes we see on all food labels in the grocery store are mainly based on data of what people ate in the '70s."

Advertise with us

Americans were slimmer then, and the amounts they reported eating in one sitting -- the definition of a serving -- seem unrealistically small today. How often does someone eat just 15 potato chips?

When serving sizes are unrealistic, foods may benefit from a kind of halo effect, Ms. Hurley said. After all, a "serving" of potato chips has just 160 calories, and that's not so bad. But what if the average consumer today eats 45 chips, for 480 calories? Confronted with that calorie count, more people might skip the potato chips.

Using the smallest allowable serving size also permits food manufacturers to round certain ingredients down to zero, even when the item contains a measurable amount of the substance. For a cookie that contains less than 1/2 gram of trans fat per serving, for example, a company could round that down to zero. If a consumer eats 10 cookies he ends up consuming several grams of trans fats.

"Chances are with a larger serving size it won't be zero anymore," Ms. Hurley said. For now, she recommends that people read labels carefully, check the ingredient list and always consider the serving size when evaluating food's nutritional information.

The grocery store is just one place where portion size matters. People also need to consider portions when they cook or eat in a restaurant. Cookbooks typically use a more heuristic notion of portion size, suggesting that a specific recipe will feed a certain number of people.

Advertise with us

Cookbook authors do think carefully about portion size. Whether that recipe is light and healthful or rich and indulgent will depend on the style of the cookbook.

Prolific author Diane Morgan always considers the audience of the cookbook she's writing. One of her recent books, "Skinny Dips" (Chronicle Books, $19), included detailed nutritional information, and Ms. Morgan created recipes that would have big flavors and relatively few calories. But even when she doesn't think her reader is counting calories, she still considers how many people a given recipe should feed.

"For a home cook who likes to play in the kitchen and try some different things, you just come at it from such a different perspective," she said. "You have a portion size in mind, but you might also have a leftover expectation." For a cookbook that isn't supposed to be particularly healthy, she'll use portions that are larger than for a "dietetic" cookbook, but she knows that her portions are still smaller than what some people might expect to get in a restaurant.

Sarah Billingsley, a former Post-Gazette staffer, is now a cookbook editor at Chronicle Books and has co-authored several cookbooks. "I look at the yield as a very important part of the recipe," she said, "It's literally as important as looking at the grammar and making sure all the [ingredients] are there."

She knows that many of Chronicle's cookbook buyers are interested in and knowledgeable about food, but they don't have the culinary proficiency that allows them to look at a recipe and know how much it will make. They rely on the yield being accurate.

Advertise with us

Or at least, close. "We err on the side of generous," said Ms. Billingsley. It's better for a cook to have leftovers, than for someone to invite people over and be one plate short.

Most cookbook authors have a good sense of portion size, she said, with one exception.

"When they fall into the chef camp," she said, "they give almost no thought to yield. They'll put for an entire cake, 'serves four.' " Fortunately, cookbook editors can recommend adjustments.

Chefs are frequently blamed for portion inflation, and there's a lot of evidence that portions have become larger, particularly at restaurants that emphasize value. Restaurants want portions to be perceived as generous, and in some cases "generous" borders on "obscene."

Even when people are faced with a portion that's too big, they don't know how much to eat.

Advertise with us

"Research repeatedly confirms that larger food servings not only provide more calories but also have two other effects. They encourage people to eat more and to underestimate how much they are eating," New York University nutrition professor Marion Nestle wrote in a recent column for Washington Square News.

In situations where it's difficult to get clear nutritional information, develop some shortcuts for minimizing portions. Ms. Nestle suggests using smaller plates, bowls and cups; ordering appetizers instead of entrees when going out to eat or sharing entrees with friends.

"The system is stacked against you, and it's up to you to figure out how to cope with it."