Fourth in an occasional series on the birth of notion. (Read Part 1 and Part 2 and Part 3 .)
David Racicot knew he was in for an uphill battle when he opened his 38-seat restaurant notion in Oakmont a year ago this Saturday.
In a region that prides itself on its sandwiches topped with french fries, "fine dining" can be a hard if not an out-and-out deal-breaker. All the more so if you have to cross a river to experience it.
Not that the 32-year-old chef didn't have the culinary chops, or self-confidence, to pull it off.
Recognized by the prestigious James Beard Foundation as a "rising star" in 2009, Mr. Racicot has never met a raw ingredient he couldn't transform into something as delicious as it is original and exciting. (Who knew cauliflower could be reduced to an intricate foam, or chocolate to a melt-in-your-mouth powder?)
Yet traveling to Nemacolin Woodlands for dinner at the five-star Lautrec, where he started perfecting the complex flavor combinations and eclectic presentations that define his modernist cuisine, was one thing; believing it's worth one's while to drive 15 miles from Downtown to the "suburbs" is quite another.
"The location has been a struggle," Mr. Racicot said late last month over a cup of coffee at Starbucks in East Liberty. "But we went into it knowing we'd eventually have to move."
That's "move," mind you, and not the dreaded c-word that the vast majority of restaurants have to confront within three years of opening: "Close."
On Dec. 17, the chef and his staff served their last 32 dinners at the tiny Allegheny River Boulevard eatery. And while that sounds like very bad news, it's actually making the Indiana, Pa., native pretty happy, because it helps to accomplish two goals: the opening of a second, more casual restaurant in the same space next month, and relocating notion to the heart of Pittsburgh's emerging food scene in East Liberty.
Mum's the word on the specific space he'll inhabit later this spring -- he's still negotiating a lease -- but it will be in the "center of everything" in the food world.
"This has always been part of a very specific plan," he insisted, bristling at the suggestion that the retreat from Oakmont was something akin to failure.
OK, so his first attempt at restaurateuring wasn't the runaway success he'd initially dreamed. Some nights, just a handful of hungry guests turned out, despite consistently great reviews. (The PG's China Millman rated its food and service as "outstanding.")
Still, enough people ate there with enough regularity that he turned a small profit, which in turn convinced him that Pittsburghers not only "got" what he was doing but would follow him when he relocated to the city.
"Actually, we're a whole year ahead of our original plan," he said, noting that when he first put pen to paper, he thought the move wouldn't happen at least until 2013.
The first inkling Mr. Racicot was up to something came on Nov. 21, when in announcing notion would be closed for a few days over the Thanksgiving holiday, he also tweeted the following: "Big changes on the horizon. Updates this week." Less than 24 hours, he'd spilled the beans on his blog, and by Nov. 30, it was full steam ahead.
"Really exciting times for us. New projects. New risks. New leap of faith," he posted on Facebook.
The young chef is a lot of things to a lot of people -- brash, outspoken, brilliant -- but dummy isn't one of them, he insists. He knew going in he wouldn't get huge crowds in such a small and sedate location, especially given his shoestring budget; his main goal in opening in Oakmont, he said, was to "introduce myself" and the innovative, almost obsessively crafted dishes he loves to create.
The menu will be a little more conventional at the new 314 Pasta and Prime, which if everything goes according to plan -- Mr. Racicot is doing all the renovations himself -- will open for business Jan. 16. As the name suggests, the menu will feature homemade pasta and steaks sold by the ounce, along with various chicken entrees.
Geared toward families, it'll also boast a giant chalkboard for kids to draw on while they're waiting, plus all the salad and bread one can eat. Nothing will cost more than $20.
He said, "It's going to be much more community oriented," the kind of food he and his own family -- who recently moved to Oakmont from Uniontown -- love to eat. "Think Olive Garden, but with really good food."
He expects it will take about five months to get 314 running like a clock with his current staff. At the same time he'll also be designing, building, decorating and creating menus for the new notion. So don't expect to be noshing on his signature tartare until May or June at the earliest.
At least one part of the plan is comfortably in place: whereas last year he had to empty his retirement account to cover his start-up costs, this time he has a handful of investors. A few regular customers also have bought $1,000 gift certificates that will be good toward future service, a sign that just as his biggest fans followed him from the Laurel Highlands to Oakmont, so too they'll be calling for reservations in East Liberty.
Interior designer Nachum Golan, who was among notion's last diners on Dec. 17, already is counting the days, and not just because the new location will be more convenient to his home in Shadyside.
"He is such an incredible talent," he said.
Mr. Racicot has learned plenty over the past year as an owner-chef, chief among them how to achieve more with less. Two years ago at this time, for instance, he would have had white truffles and turbot on the menu. He also was constrained by the physical space, which was cramped and badly lit and not nearly as welcoming as he would have liked.
"It's been a challenge to order and prep," he said.
Just as tough was learning to that you can't make everyone happy all the time -- bloggers were especially unkind -- himself included.
"It's so easy to beat yourself up over even small stuff, and that's not a healthy thing," he said. "I've had to develop a thicker skin."
The silver lining is that having fewer resources -- be they space, staff or ingredients -- teaches one to be a better chef. A good example is his signature tartare starter. Made with meat trimmed from the ribeye, it would have been unthinkable at Lautrec. Yet at notion, where it was paired with basil and sesame seed, kiwi and pickled vegetables, it was an immediate hit.
Some may question his decision not to stay open through New Year's Eve, which for many restaurants is one of the busiest (and most profitable) nights of the year. But that, says Mr. Racicot, is one of the benefits of being your own boss: you get to bend the rules. Besides, after a solid year of 16-hour-plus workdays, he and general manager Jennifer Jin needed a break.
"Instead of trying to work in [much-needed] vacations, we just closed a few days early," he said with a sigh. "Some local chefs just don't get what I do."
There was a certain wistfulness to the chef's posts on the night of his last service. "Final sweet," he tweeted at 9:53 p.m., along with a picture. But they also reflected his optimism. "For now of course," he added.
"Sad? We're not sad!" said Ms. Jin. "It's the right thing to do."
"It's been an awesome year for us, and we've accomplished a lot," Mr. Racicot agreed. "So many people have eaten here and seen our vision and want us to continue."
So going to East Liberty, he said, "will be a happy move for us."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.