We don't all scream for ice cream.

Some of us scream for custard. Or sherbet. Or gelato. Or fro' yo'.

But what do all those terms really mean? Here's how to tell the difference between different frozen desserts.

Ice cream

Advertise with us

One important ice cream ingredient you might not guess is air, without which you wouldn't recognize it -- or much want to eat it. Ice cream can be 50 percent or more air. The rest is dairy solids (about 20 percent by weight) and milk fat (at least 10 percent by weight, although some "premium" ice creams have much more fat) from milk and cream, plus sweeteners, thickeners, emulsifiers and other ingredients.

By federal law, a gallon of ice cream must weigh at least 4.5 pounds. But there still is a lot of variation. According to the International Dairy Foods Association, Food and Drug Administration rules allow ice cream to be described as:

• "Reduced fat," meaning it contains at least 25 percent less total fat than the referenced product (either the company's brand or an average of leading brands)

• "Light," meaning it contains half the total fat or one-third fewer calories than the referenced product (the average of leading brands)

• "Lowfat," meaning it contains a maximum of 3 grams of total fat per serving, and

Advertise with us

• "Nonfat," meaning it contains less than .5 grams of total fat per serving.

And a serving is defined as a half cup.

Yeah, right.

Further, as the IDFA explains, ice cream can be marketed as:

• "Superpremium," which tends to have relatively little air and lots of fat, and best-quality ingredients

Advertise with us

• "Premium," which tends to have less air, more fat and higher-quality ingredients than

• "Regular," which meets federal standards, and

• "Economy," which meets standards but sells for less.

Bottom line: If you gain weight from eating too much ice cream, you can tell people, "I'm not higher fat; I'm superpremium!"

Frozen custard

Advertise with us

Like ice cream, it needs to be at least 10 percent fat, but it also contains egg -- at least 1.4 percent egg yolk solids by weight, according to the FDA. It can be served soft or hard, when it's sometimes called "French ice cream."

Soft serve

This type of ice cream is no longer officially designated as "ice milk," but rather it's one of the lighter versions described above. Dairy Queen, for instance, says its soft serve "now fits into the 'reduced-fat' ice cream category [containing 5 percent butterfat], and our shake mix qualifies as 'low-fat' ice cream."

Gelato

Gelato -- the Italian word for "frozen" -- is Italian-style ice cream. It's not a specifically federally regulated "standardized frozen dessert," but it typically is made from more milk than cream or all milk and has less fat, roughly 6 to 8 percent. As Mulberry Street Creamery's Rick Mercurio told me a decade ago, when gelato was just coming on in the States, it has a creamy texture because it is frozen with smaller ice crystals than ice cream and far less added air -- about 10 percent.

Advertise with us

Gelato is where you find some of the craziest flavor experimentation. I've tasted wasabi gelato at La Casa Gelato in Vancouver, British Columbia, where they always have 218 flavors available, from more than 500 that they make.

Sherbet

Like an ice cream, but with less milkfat -- only 1 to 2 percent -- and flavored with fruit or fruit juice. The FDA says sherbet must weigh in at least 6 pounds to the gallon. And the word contains only one R.

Sorbet

Unlike sherbet, sorbet contains no dairy or egg and little or no fat; often it's mostly real fruit or juice, but it can be other flavorings and sweeteners. Giant Eagle Market District among other places calls it the Italian sorbetto.

Advertise with us

Ices (or water ices)

Frozen water with fruit flavoring of some sort -- and too frequently, really brilliant coloring. Runs the gamut from slushies to shaved ice and "ice balls" at Gus Kalaris' cart on the North Side. Sometimes the frozen mixture -- of coffee, or lemonade -- is granular and crunchy and called granita. My almost 4-year-old son looks forward all week to his regular two scoops of what he still calls "ice cweam" -- LaScola's smooth fruit-flavored Italian Ice at the Mt. Lebanon Lions Farmers Market.

Semifreddo

This varied group of "half frozen" Italian confections aren't as dense as gelato, because their bases, which can be ice creams or custards, are mixed with whipped cream and/or otherwise lightened with egg whites. Unlike traditional ice cream, you can make these at home without any kind of special churning equipment.

Frozen yogurt

Advertise with us

The IDFA says it "consists of a mixture of dairy ingredients such as milk and nonfat milk, which have been cultured, as well as ingredients for sweetening and flavoring." The now-trendy kind is tart, at places such as Razzy Fresh, in Squirrel Hill and in Oakland, twice. Part of the appeal is the big selection of fruit and dry toppings.

Non-dairy frozen desserts

You can now get a wide range of non-dairy frozen desserts, made with everything from coconut milk to hemp milk. Now you can scream for Tofutti, too.