Looking to gift ’90s-style clothing this holiday season? Local stores can help you reclaim the decade that was.
With the era now back in fashion 26 years removed from 1999, a variety of stores across Pittsburgh have something to offer for anyone who’s in search of the perfect ’90s gift for their nostalgic or stylish loved one.
So pick up your big, boxy plastic flip phone: The decade is calling.
From Garfield to West Elizabeth, boutiques and vintage shops are filling their racks with graphic tees, flannels, CDs and other throwback items.
Fifty One Ten Vintage
Didn’t grow up in the ’90s? Not sure where to start?
Meghan McTavish isn’t shy when it comes to styling customers who walk into Fifty One Ten Vintage in Bloomfield.
“It’s common — someone comes in not knowing what to get, I style them and they walk out with a new outfit,” said McTavish, the store manager. “I had this group of guys come in and say, ‘Yeah, we’re going to a Y2K party,’ and it was so fun getting all four of them a new outfit for it.”
Fifty One Ten — which celebrated its fifth year of business in October — carries clothing, accessories and records, with items ranging from the 1970s through today and sourced from private collections, estate sales and other thrifts.
McTavish has noticed certain ’90s items in the store becoming more popular, including Liquid Blue and Grateful Dead shirts, Harley Davidson apparel, BCBG, Victoria’s Secret, graphic tees and anything with Pittsburgh teams.
For ’90s-centric gifts, McTavish said the shop offers something for everyone at a low price.
“Shoes, anything outerwear, leather jackets and crew necks — those are all really good,” she said.
“I personally believe that, in the ’90s and prior, all the clothes were made so much better than the 2000s to now, because they were made with cotton, not polyester, and the people that were making them were focusing on quality rather than quantity.”
5110 Penn Ave., Bloomfield; 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Sunday-Thursday, 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Friday-Saturday; fiftyonetenvintage.com
Steal City Vintage
When Rob Schwoegl and DJ Lander opened Steal City Vintage on Murray Avenue three years ago, they wanted to create a shop that wasn’t restricted by gender norms.
“We started with the idea that both of us wear whatever,” said Schwoegl. “Some people will ask us, ‘Is this the men’s section?’ But the jeans don't have a gender, and it lets [shoppers] have so much more freedom to choose.”
Before opening the Squirrel Hill store, the pair were wholesalers, building collections from thrifting. Now, much of their inventory comes from community sales and donations, with the goal of giving clothes a second — or even a third — life.
Lander said another goal is to be a one-stop shop. With clothing, posters and old-school formats (records, CDs, VCR tapes), Steal City offers a mix influenced by horror movies, hip-hop culture, pop music and more and including plenty of ’90s staples.
Gift shopping can be tricky, but Schwoegl and Lander said their wide variety helps.
Shoppers often find jewelry, vintage tees, $1 CDs and of course, gift cards. Members of Gen Z in particular tend to want physical items from the generation before them and “romanticize” the ’90s, the pair said.
“They want CDs, tape cassettes and Walkmans,” said Schwoegl. “They see a Playboy, and their minds are blown because they have never even comprehended that. I think it has a lot to do with just what people didn’t get to grow up with.”
1918 Murray Ave., Squirrel Hill; 3 to 7 p.m. Monday, noon to 7 p.m. Tuesday, noon to 6 p.m.; tinyurl.com/stealcityvintage
Cheetah Lounge Vintage
For locals, the Main Street brick-and-mortar in New Eagle, Washington County, may be remembered as The Twist.
In March, the former ice cream shop was decked out with cheetah-print wallpaper and transformed into Cheetah Lounge Vintage, now run by 23-year-old Olivia Vizzuett.
Vizzuett never imagined owning a store, but, after family-owned The Twist shut down, her mom suggested the idea, and she ran with it.
“Most of my store, you are going to find a lot of ’90s and Y2K, but I do have pieces from before then,” Vizzuett said. “I have ’80s, ’70s, some ’60s and even ’50s items. But the older you go back, the harder they are to find. I also have modern pieces mixed in too.”
Vizzuett doesn’t seek donations, as is common at many thrift stores. Instead, she does all the “hunting.” Everything in the shop — clothing, bags, shoes and accessories — she curated. And no matter when you stop in, there are ’90s staples.
“Grunge is a style category that has never died,” she said. “Whether it’s baggy vintage Carhartt, rugged jeans or flannels. I also think of '90s supermodels — the tailored looks, minis, tiny tops, very structured and sleek. Right now, I have a lot of that in my store.”
Vizzuett said Cheetah Lounge is an easy spot to purchase gifts.
“Cheetah Lounge would be the right place if you're looking for nostalgic gift ideas. You would definitely score here.”
207 Main St., New Eagle; noon to 5 p.m. Wednesday-Thursday, 11a.m. to 5 p.m. Friday-Saturday; tinyurl.com/cheetahloungevintage
Haven Boutique
From the outside, it still looks like a school.
Now housing various businesses, the former Lincoln Elementary in West Elizabeth is part of a larger effort to bring the river town back to life. Haven Boutique owner Ashley Delgado wanted to be part of the revitalization that’s starting with the school.
Delgado describes her store, which opened in May 2024, as having a “boutique feel, but with thrift prices.” The clothing and home decor are always thrifted or donated, while the rest of the shop features items — from bath bombs and candles to plants — handmade either by her or local makers, perfect for unique holiday gifts.
With clothing racks full of color and filled with jeans, T-shirts and jean jackets, Delgado said many donated items are from or reminiscent of the ’90s. She also keeps prices capped at $9.99 — whether the item is a Michael Kors jean jacket or Christian Louboutin heels.
While her main demographic is young moms, Delgado said she has noticed more teenagers, so the store features a wide range of styles.
“I just feel like it's more of a treasure hunt here than it would be if a group of girls went to Marshalls,” she said. “They just get excited, and it feels like a store for young-at-heart people, but then also, grandmas feel comfortable here. It's just a really cool space.”
800 5th St. (Rt. 837), West Elizabeth; 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. Tuesday-Wednesday, 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. Friday, 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. Saturday, 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. Sunday; havenboutiquepgh.com
Ava Dzurenda (ava.dzurenda@gmail.com) is a science writer and exercise physiologist based in White Oak.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.