Pittsburgh has a long history of craftsmanship. Steelworkers built the city — and country — with their hands.

The skyline was forged in steel and built to last a lifetime.

While Pittsburgh’s steel industry has waned, the tradition of craftsmanship is as quintessential to the city as its bridges.

Like diamonds in the rough, several multigenerational Pittsburgh-area jewelers have survived amid a rise of online shopping, rising inflation and ever-changing trend cycles.

Advertise with us

Nearly half of all couples — about 47%, according to The Knot — get engaged between November and February. The magic of the holidays, combined with the convenience of time to celebrate with family and friends, drives a lot of what’s unofficially known as “proposal season.”

For those planning to propose, Pittsburgh’s locally owned jewelers offer a wide range of price points and gemstones — and a legacy of craftsmanship that’s built to last.

To find these stores, I reached out to the Pittsburgh Brides Facebook group. Here’s a roundup of jewelers Pittsburghers recommended, listed in alphabetical order.

Brooks Diamonds

Stacey Brooks is a testament to the old saying “when you know, you know.”

The North Hills native got her start in the world of jewelry at 19 years old, working for a wholesale jeweler in the Clark Building. When the company went out of business, Brooks decided to get a bank loan and start her own jewelry wholesale business, Brooks Metals, in 1996.

Advertise with us

She transitioned into retail in 2006, opening what’s now Brooks Diamonds in the Clark Building, Downtown.

“I love it. It’s my passion,” Brooks said. “I love making people happy.”

The store specializes in high-quality diamonds, custom designs and high-fashion jewelry. What makes the business stand out is a commitment to customer service and competitive prices, Brooks said.

“We want to make sure people have their purchase, that we listen to what they want, and we don't try to oversell them or upsell them,” she said.

Before popping the question, Brooks recommends having a clear sense of what your partner will like.

Advertise with us

“You want to make sure she likes the ring without blowing the surprise.”

717 Liberty Ave. No. 303, Downtown. Open 9:30 a.m.-4 p.m. Monday-Friday, and 10 a.m.-3 p.m. Saturday.  brooksdiamonds.net

Chapel Hills Jewelry

Chapel Hills Jewelry came together almost by accident in 1989.

Prior to opening the Aspinwall store, Jack and Tina Tesauro were both working health care when they saw a business opportunity. The Tesauros began selling jewelry to doctors who needed last-minute gifts, and from there, it grew.

“It wasn't a huge part of their life,” said their son, Jonathan Tesauro. “They just saw an opportunity, and then it became their life.”

Advertise with us

Now, the family business is in its second generation. Jonathan and his twin sister, Lauren, are partners in the company.

“It’s the best,” he said about working with family. “You get to work with your best friends every day.”

Family values are part of the experience of shopping at Chapel Hills Jewelry.

“Come into the store and let us know your story. We'll tell you ours,” Jonathan said.

“Come in, have a drink, have a cup of coffee, whichever you like. We just want you to feel at home, and we'll make sure that everything's perfect for not just the person you're buying for, but that for yourself as well, so that you're leaving happy.”

Advertise with us

Chapel Hills Jewelry is best known for its custom design and luxury goods.

503 Freeport Road, Aspinwall. Open 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Tuesday, Thursday and Friday, 10 a.m.-7 p.m. Wednesday from 10 a.m.-3 p.m. Saturday. chapelhillsjewelry.com

Jewelry by Alicia and Scott

Alicia Blair, 43, of Pine, grew up in a family-owned jewelry business.

At just 13 years old, an age when many young girls were making friendship bracelets, she got her diamond grading certification.

“It's like the business just sort of picked me, rather than me picking the business,” Blair said, “I kind of grew up in it, and then attempted to, you know, do some different things in my life, but always ended back here.”

Advertise with us

She spent years working for her parents’ jewelry business before they retired. Now, she owns her own jewelry destination in Pine with her husband, Scott.

“We love working together,” Blair said. “It's great to be able to be a team in life, but to know that, like everything we build, we build together.”

For Pittsburghers looking to propose, Blair said the city and surrounding areas make the perfect backdrop for such a milestone.

“The city has so much to offer as far as history, cultural events, restaurants, gorgeous outdoor locations,” she said. “If you can't find something cool and creative to do in this city, it is literally because you haven't left your house.”

Jewelry by Alicia and Scott specializes in natural diamonds, natural exotic colored gemstones, lab-grown gemstones and custom design.

Advertise with us

306 Warrendale Road, Pine. Open 11 a.m.-6 p.m. Tuesday to Friday and 10 a.m.-3 p.m. Saturday. jewelrybyaliciaandscott.com

Mathews Jewelers

Mathews Jewelers is now on its fourth generation.

The family-run business began in 1947 in Zelienople. As the family grew, so did the store’s footprint. In 2007, a second store opened in Cranberry.

Michelle Mathew, whose grandfather opened the jewelry business, now co-owns the store with her brother, Phil. The family plans to pass down the business to Michele’s two nephews and niece.

Through the decades, generations of the family cultivated lifelong, multigenerational customers as well.

Advertise with us

“We work with people that have been with us through the generations,” Michelle said.

“I have people coming in and they're like, ‘Your grandfather sold me our engagement ring,’ or ‘You sold my grandparents their engagement ring.’”

122 N. Main St, Zelienople; 20430 Route 19 Suite 170, Cranberry. Open 9 a.m.-5:30 p.m. Monday-Wednesday and Friday, 9 a.m.-8 p.m. Thursday and 9 a.m.-4 p.m. Saturday. mathewjewelers.com

Noah Gabriel and Co.

For Christopher Sarich, the founder of Noah Gabriel & Co. Jewelers, a love of jewelry began with a part-time job in college.

Years later, he founded his own store in 2016, motivated by the joy in helping others celebrate big moments.

Advertise with us

“In very few businesses, you get to interact with people in maybe the happiest moments of their life,” Sarich said. “What we like to say is, ‘We sell pretty things to happy people’ and there's really not much of a better way to spend your day.”

Sarich has made a lot of unique and interesting custom rings in his years.

For one couple who got married in a church, the store incorporated the woodwork from the church into the design of the ring.

For a custom anniversary ring for a couple moving from Pittsburgh to a mountainous area of Utah, Noah Gabriel & Co. Jewelers incorporated a profile of a mountain range into the design.

271 Market Lane, Pine. Open 10 a.m.-8 p.m. Monday-Thursday, 10 a.m.-9 p.m. Friday and Saturday and 11 a.m.-6 p.m. Sunday. noahgabrielco.com

Advertise with us

South Hills Jewelers

South Hills jewelers has been in business for over 40 years.

Tiffany Taylor’s grandfather, Robert Taylor Sr., opened the store in 1982, and it was later purchased by her father, Robert Taylor Jr. Now, the 23-year-old is the digital marketing manager and a jewelry consultant.

“I like following my dad's footsteps, and he's very generous to everyone,” Tiffany said. “I like being generous to people and seeing their reaction.”

She said her grandfather was a people person and a businessman, traits that seem to have been passed down through generations.

“I feel like we stand out because [we are] family-owned and also we do all our repairs on site, so nothing leaves the store, which people really like,” Tiffany said.

Advertise with us

5247 Library Road, Bethel Park. Open 10 a.m.-6 p.m. Monday-Friday and 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Saturday. southhillsjewelers.com

Truvers

At Truvers, every piece of jewelry is personal.

Robert Truver, the owner, is a goldsmith and diamond setter. The Upper St. Clair native founded his business over 30 years ago.

Truver does all the work in house himself, said Barbara Muse, a Truvers employee of 25 years.

“He's all about quality,” she said.

Advertise with us

Since every piece of jewelry is personal, Truvers employees recommend customers bring their rings in every three months for a free cleaning.

“That's always free, so we keep an eye on them,” Muse said. “Keep you sparkling in good shape.”

3287 W. Liberty Ave., Dormont. Open 10 a.m.-5 p.m. Tuesday and Friday, 11 a.m.-7 p.m. Thursday and 10 a.m.-3 p.m. Saturday.  truvers.com