What’s underfoot matters, especially because an area rug often anchors the room. Many designers work from the floor up, using the rug as a starting point, an inspiration for the colors and style of the space.

“Sometimes we start with the rug first,” said Paige McNaul of LSM Interior Design. “But we look at the overall design scheme and make our decision based on what upholstery and casegood finishes are in the space. Every project is different.”

Stark, Feizy, Jaipur Living, Safavieh, Colonial Mills and Loloi are just a few of the top rug manufacturers today, each weaving a multitude of materials, patterns and sizes. To help navigate the seemingly infinite choices, we asked three experts to give us some tips on finding the right rug for a room.

Joanna Gaines of HGTV’s “FIxer Upper” fame just introduced a new line of area rugs for her Magnolia Home collection by Loloi.

Advertise with us

“It’s not about design rules or creating perfect spaces,” Mrs. Gaines said. “That’s why I’ve designed a collection that is equal parts beautiful and livable for you and your family.”

Weisshouse was called Modern Curtain and Rugs when it opened more than 60 years ago in Squirrel Hill. Today, the family owned business is known for iconic furniture and interior design, but it’s stayed true to those roots.

“Our origins are actually in wool carpet and rugs,” said Stacy Weiss, president and owner.

The company has a carpet library featuring over 5,000 samples of the best wool on the market.

“Wool by far is the preferred fiber for rugs here at Weisshouse. It is the most stain-resistant and resilient (won't crush) and it is 100 percent sustainable and environmentally friendly,” she said, noting that synthetic rugs don’t break down in landfills.

Advertise with us

Wool also takes dye well, giving a saturated color, and it’s naturally flame-resistant, Ms. Weiss said. Interior designer Becky Jarold of B Jarold & Company agreed. “Wool carpet is good because it’s a natural fiber, durable and cleans easily,” she said.

Natural vs. synthetic

While wool is a great choice, especially in colder climates, there are other materials that are appropriate in high-traffic areas or places that receive lots of sunlight.

Ms. McNaul led the design team working on a beach house in The Hamptons of Long Island last spring.

“Knowing that the family room had a ton of natural light pouring in and that the client was going to rent the property out for the summers, I opted for a wide-scale, blue- and white-striped woven Sunbrella rug,” she said.

Advertise with us

“The whole room is actually [done in] Sunbrella, including the sofa, chairs and pillows, because Sunbrella and other performance materials are great options for their light fastness and cleanability, as are a lot of nylon rugs,” Ms. McNaul added.

Performance materials are available in a variety of styles, colors and patterns and are much softer than the first generation of fabrics. Natural fibers remain a popular option for any climate.

“Sisal carpet and area rugs can be great, depending on their placement and usage,” Ms. Weiss said. “These natural fiber rugs are durable and can last for years, although they do stain easily and are difficult to clean.”

Weisshouse offers a variety of natural fiber rugs and lookalikes. “We have sourced some beautiful synthetic sisal rugs that clean well and look like the real thing — ideal for outdoor or basement areas.

“If you are committed to using the real thing, we suggest a weave with a heavy texture, pattern or color variation to disguise stains,” she advised.

Advertise with us

Ms. McNaul said she and LSM designers are also fans of sisal and other natural materials.

“Sisal rugs, often with unique linen or leather borders, are definitely LSM go-to’s when it comes to adding style without increasing the budget,” she said. “Natural fiber rugs such as sisal can really ground the space and add a lot of texture.”

Size matters

When choosing the size of an area rug, Ms. Weiss offers this advice:

“In a dining room, the rule of thumb is at least 2 feet beyond all sides of the table. In living rooms we usually like the rug to go under the feet of the sofa.”

Advertise with us

Ms. McNaul explained the extra 2 feet around a dining table: “You want enough to pull a dining chair out from the table and still be on the rug.”

At LSM Interior Design, the aesthetic preference is to always have the legs of all furniture on the rug. “However, that is not always possible. For example in a bedroom, we may choose to pull the rug down a bit so that it lays in front of the nightstands,” Ms. McNaul said.

When in doubt, always choose the larger size, Ms. Weiss said. “You won’t be sorry.”

Pick a pattern

A rug’s texture, color scheme, motif and design can transform the ambiance of a room. Animal patterns such as zebra stripes or leopard spots give a room an exotic and sophisticated look. Stripes are great for easy, casual, contemporary or traditional spaces. Southwestern designs offer a more rustic feel, and the Moroccan quatrefoil pattern is very popular, especially for indoor/outdoor rugs. Sometimes custom is the way to go.

Advertise with us

“We had a room where we needed to use a custom design mimicking a drapery in an adjacent room so the the two rooms tied together,” Ms. Jarold said. “The rug was chosen because of the flexibility of design options and and luxurious feel with the cowhide, not to mention excellent wear properties of this natural product.”

Weisshouse has exclusive designs that are hand-woven in Morocco.

“It comes is several color combinations including a cream background and a black background,” Ms. Weiss said. “When you purchase any hand-woven rug, each one will be unique due to the nature of hand weaving.”

“We are fortunate to have some clients that let style be the No. 1 factor in choosing a rug,” said Ms. McNaul. “Those are the clients that are willing to wait 9 to 12 months for the custom hand-knotted silk and wool Stark rugs made overseas — truly works of art!”

Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com.