Long before southwestern Pennsylvania was famous for coal or steel, we were known for our whiskey — specifically Monongahela rye.

The spicy, dark-hued liquor made by farmers in Washington, Fayette, Westmoreland and Allegheny counties was the most popular whiskey in this part of the young United States (take that, bourbon!).

Local farmers who refused to pay Alexander Hamilton’s federal excise tax started the Whiskey Rebellion, the 230th anniversary of which will be celebrated July 12-13 at the Whiskey Rebellion Festival in Washington, Pa. There will be historical tours and reenactments as well as music and food and drinks, including whiskey, of course.

Some will be rye whiskey, which must contain at least 51% of rye in the mash. Bourbon, meanwhile, is sweeter because it contains at least 51% corn. So why was this the home of Old Overholt instead of Jim Beam?

Advertise with us

Our climate and rocky soil was more suited to growing rye than corn, says Jim Hough, whose family-run Liberty Pole Spirits released its Old Monongahela Full Proof Rye Whiskey ($64) in May. Each 750 ml bottle is 108 proof and nearly 75% Pennsylvania-grown rye with 13% each of wheat and barley malt.

The distillery in North Strabane, Washington County, also makes Liberty Pole Spirits Rye Whiskey ($47), which is 92 proof with an identical mash bill.

“If you’re a distillery in Western Pennsylvania, you should have a rye,” Hough says.

In fact, Pennsylvania rye is Liberty Pole’s flagship product.

Hough and his family — wife Ellen and sons Rob and Kevin — started the distillery in 2016 and moved last year to a newly built, much larger facility.

Advertise with us

They consulted with Pennsylvania whiskey historians before making their version of Monongahela rye, the name of which comes from the river that starts in West Virginia and runs through southwestern Pennsylvania before joining the Allegheny to become the Ohio River in Pittsburgh.

Besides being a favorite in early American taverns, rye whiskey was liquid capital when Western Pennsylvania was the western frontier.

In 1791, when the federal tax was imposed on whiskey and the stills used to make it, most farmers didn’t have cash to pay it. They used the whiskey they made from excess grain as currency or to trade for what they needed, and collection of the tax was spotty in the beginning.

Lawyer Hugh Brackenridge, who helped start The Pittsburgh Gazette, forerunner of the Post-Gazette, brought out Monongahela rye to try to pacify the region’s anti-tax distillers.

“The people were mad,” he wrote. “I thought it safest to use good words and good drink, rather than balls and powder. It cost me four barrels of old whiskey that day, and I would rather spare that than a quart of blood.”

Advertise with us

By 1794, however, President George Washington could no longer tolerate the scofflaws’ disobedience and defiance of federal authority. Attempts to collect the tax were met by rebels who tarred and feathered tax collectors and destroyed the stills and property of farmers who paid.

The rebellion came to a head in mid-July, when over 500 rebels attacked and burned Bower Hill, the home of tax collector John Neville in what is now Scott Township. Neville retreated to Woodville, his other estate that still stands in Collier.

Later that year, Washington himself led troops to put down the rebellion, which dissolved before the troops reached Pittsburgh.

It’s difficult to recreate Monongahela rye, Hough said, because its mash bill and distillation process were never written down. But we do know it was made in pot stills from a sweet mash (with fresh yeast) rather than sour mash, which uses spent stillage. It was aged in oak barrels, unlike other early whiskeys.

Though rye was once a staple crop in this part of Pennsylvania, it has been surpassed by corn and other crops. Liberty Pole uses winter rye grown in Bucks County, where Hough got to see just how durable it is.

Advertise with us

“When we were filling our bin, some of the rye was dumped onto a bed of river rock, and it grew,” he says. “It will grow anywhere.”

So what does Monongahela rye taste like?

It’s herbal and spicy, Hough says, with a nose that hints of caramel, oak, citrus, and pine. Its taste has notes of pepper, allspice and apricot with a spicy yet buttery finish.

It’s a unique whiskey that has inspired its makers at Liberty Pole Spirits.

“It’s fantastic to be in a region that honors its history,” Hough says.

Kevin Kirkland: kkirkland@post-gazette.com