John Edward Graf collects historic buildings in Pittsburgh for fun, preservation and profit, not necessarily in that order.

Breathing fresh air into distinctive, dust-laden landmarks appears to energize the congenial executive, who is following a trail blazed by his parents, Ed and Mary Ann. In 1986, the Grafs opened The Priory, a Benedictine monastery they transformed into a North Side bed and breakfast. Almost a decade later, in 1995, the couple opened the adjacent Grand Hall in the former St. Mary Roman Catholic Church.

Mr. Graf, who runs both, is investing in the North Side again. He is a one-third partner in October Development’s renovation of the former Workingman’s Savings Bank at 800 E. Ohio St. When finished, the Beaux-Arts-style building will accommodate 150 people for receptions while its third-floor roof will become an outdoor brew pub with an excellent view of the Downtown skyline.

Last year, crews spent four months demolishing walls, bathrooms and showers, the remains of an era when the bank building was used as a residential recovery center for alcoholics. After the center closed in 2006, Pittsburgh City Council designated the building a historic landmark. Later this year, a new Comfort Inn & Suites is scheduled to open next door.

Advertise with us

Designed by architect James T. Steen and built in 1902, the former bank is “a more intimate space. We see this as a good adjunct space to the Grand Hall,” Mr. Graf said.

Pittsburgh's Grand Hall at the Priory rises above the North Side. The event space in a former church was converted by John Graf's parents, whose interest in historic buildings sparked his own. (Stephanie Strasburg / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The East Ohio Street building, which will be called The Vault, has a grand staircase leading to a balcony overlooking the first floor. Four skylights, each 11 feet square, will be installed. On the first floor, marble counters where customers once wrote deposit slips will become a space for cocktails. Cast-plaster rosettes and wooden dentil molding will draw visitors’ eyes to the first-floor ceiling.

It’s just one of several projects that demand Mr. Graf’s attention.

Last year, he bought The Mansions on Fifth, a Shadyside compound with 22 hotel suites in two Gilded Age homes, one on Fifth Avenue, the other on Amberson Avenue.

He also purchased The Castle, the former headquarters of Westinghouse Air Brake Co. in Wilmerding. The $11 million project will use historic preservation tax credits, $5 million in financing and private venture capital and a $3 million state redevelopment assistance grant.

Advertise with us

“Someone will need to buy those credits,” Mr. Graf said, adding that Chevron bought historic tax credits from The Mansions on Fifth project.

Despite all these responsibilities, the 52-year-old Ben Avon resident wears a ready smile and blue jeans, giving him the relaxed air of a rock ‘n’ roll roadie. His appearance and wardrobe are a 360-degree turn from the suit and tie he wore when he was a lawyer with Tucker Arensberg. He chose hospitality and historic buildings over law briefs and court dates.

When Mr. Graf isn’t working with developer Allie DePasquale, or contractor Chris Senko on the former bank, he is a regular at gatherings of the Vistage Group, a local group of small business executives. Mr. Graf is also past chair of the Pennsylvania Restaurant and Lodging Association.

He and his staff are retooling the menus for The Mansions on Fifth, adding filet, tilapia, salmon and food stations to reflect what is offered at the Grand Hall.

“Millenials like the party aspect of it. Dinner slows the party down for about an hour,” Mr. Graf said.

Advertise with us

A Pittsburgh-themed menu may include mini sandwiches with meat, cole slaw and French fries, she-crab soup recipe from the late Poli’s restaurant, a Maurice salad, crabmeat hoelzel, Turkey devonshire and a pecan ball or Clark bar cake for dessert. Menus themed with Latin, Eastern European or German foods will be offered, too.

As for The Castle in Wilmerding, Mr. Graf believes its baronial spaces will one day rival the interior of the Omni Bedford Springs Resort in Bedford, about 100 miles from Pittsburgh. Assembling the financing for the $11 million project has been a complex task. He knows the job will require nothing short of an Olympic effort.

“I don’t know that there’s anyone else out there who is crazy enough to do this,” he said.

By offering shuttle service to The Castle, Mr. Graf is confident that businesses will want to gather at there for retreats, and that the venue will draw reception business, too.

“Event business is not going to go away,” he said.

Marylynne Pitz: mpitz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1648 or on Twitter: @mpitzpg.