2016 Cadillac ATS RWD 3.6 Premium: Hot rod Cadillac.
Price: $55,430 as tested ($48,110 base).
Marketer’s pitch: “The journey is the new destination.”
Conventional wisdom: For the 2014 ATS, Edmunds.com liked the “excellent handling; fun-to-drive character with either 2.0-liter turbo or V6 engine; cutting-edge interior design” but not the “weak acceleration with the base engine; 2.0-liter turbo engine is noisy; CUE electronics interface is slow to respond and often distracting; small backseat and trunk.”
Reality: ATS makes the journey pretty fun.
Sporty Cadillac? My first impression of the ATS was that it’s the most all-out fun I’ve ever had riding in a Cadillac. The low seating position, responsive steering and quick pickup made me think of BMWs, Infinitis and Acuras. The little hot rod tore up the first hill in no time. “Oooo, this is going to be lots of fun,” I thought.
Up to speed: The 3.6-liter V-6 creates 335 horsepower, which takes the little low-slung sedan up to 60 mph in a rocking 5.6 seconds, according to Car and Driver. And the exhaust note for high-speed maneuvers is a beautiful roar worthy of a Camaro.
Shifty: The eight-speed shiftable automatic is fairly unobtrusive. The shift capability functions less than perfectly. The lever manages to be both fairly soft and yet hard to move, especially for downshifting. Its awkward location made my tendons twitch.
Paddles on the steering wheel are another choice, but they don’t satisfy me. And, unfortunately, something in the transmission or control logic left me feeling a little bumpy on certain occasions.
Driver’s seat: The beautiful Kona brown semi-aniline leather seats ($1,295) are beautiful and wrap the driver in comfort, but they sure feel stiff to ride in for long periods. Perhaps the full aniline version would have offered more comfort. The cold weather package ($600) includes heated seats and steering wheel.
Friends and stuff: The people in the back seat have it worse; they will get an in-depth study in contorting. The corner positions have some foot- and leg-room, but there’s not a lot of wiggle room. The rear seat sits up high to offer as much space as it does, but that cuts into headroom. The middle occupant will simply weep, even more than usual, unless that individual is permitted to put his/her tootsies on the console.
Space inside said console is tight, and a small phone slot in front of the gearshift offers very little storage.
Play some tunes: Cadillac is sticking with its CUE interface, with ebony touch pad surrounding a touch screen. The sensors work fairly well, but not as certainly as knobs, real buttons and joysticks. Audiophiles will enjoy B+/A- sound quality.
Night shift: Lighting provides the beautiful ambiance one expects from a Cadillac. The headlights were aimed a little low, unfortunately.
Hello, up there: The only drawback of the expensive Kona leather seats is their inability to raise high enough. They tilt forward rather than raise, so I always felt like I was hidden deep inside the ATS.
Shaky startup: The model that I tested took a few moments to wake up fully. I felt a few shakes and thuds on my morning pullout. The morning I had to back it out from between two tightly parked cars was downright frightening. The engine hesitated and then raced, necessitating some brake slamming and a few expletives.
High tech: In addition to the other glitches, the lane-changing software (part of a $2,885 Driver Awareness Package) twice alerted me to a phantom vehicle, both times while passing exit ramps with no vehicles on them.
Fuel economy: The ATS traveled about 22 miles on a gallon of gas while I toured over country roads and around suburbs. Feed it regular unleaded, which is a bright spot. The ATS shuts down two of the cylinders on the highway and cuts the engine at stoplights, aiding in stretching the fuel.
Where it’s built: Lansing, Mich.
How it’s built: The 2013 model garnered a reliability rating of much worse than average from Consumer Reports.
In the end: The ATS offers a fun driving experience for people who don’t really need a rear seat much. But the problems I experienced and the reliability rating make it a sketchy choice.
Scott Sturgis, a freelance auto writer, writes the Driver’s Seat column for the Post-Gazette. He can be reached at mrdriversseat@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.