A seven-dish, three-course vegetarian dinner is not what you expect at Tina’s, the Bloomfield neighborhood bar where $7 drinks are still on the menu.
“Family-style meals are a way to connect with the people you’re with. Put away your phones and eat together,” Daniele Brenci, the chef, says. “That’s Italian cooking. That’s my roots. And that’s how Sarah and I participate in hospitality.”
The set dinner menu is the latest addition at Tina’s, owned by Sarah Shaffer since 2017.
Brenci and Shaffer introduced the tasting menu in March.
“This has been a long time coming,” Brenci says. “Ever since Sarah and I met, we've talked about how we align as professionals in this industry and how we can move it forward. I respect what she's done here with the focus on sustainability and community.”
The couple decided to introduce a dedicated food program as a way to expand the reach of the business and offer more family-friendly and inclusive options for the neighborhood. Previously, the bar’s food was limited to a snacky selection of tinned fish and bread.
“When you only serve alcohol, you limit the scope of the community that you can serve,” Shaffer says.
To make the menu as accessible as possible, they’ve set the price at $55 — still a splurge for some, but one of the best value-for-dollar propositions in Pittsburgh right now — and made it all vegetarian.
Not serving meat helps keep costs down, as does Brenci’s focus on seasonality.
“It’s good for the body and kind to the planet,” Shaffer says.
“It’s how we both eat, too,” Brenci adds. “When I look at how I grew up, we didn't eat meat every day. Once a week, maybe. That's healthy eating that makes you feel good.”

On a hot August night, that meant tarts with foraged mushrooms, pasta made from leftover bread and a fruity semifreddo dotted with, of all things, a bittersweet onion reduction.
Brenci grew up in Rome and cooked in the kitchens of Michelin-starred restaurants abroad and in the United States early in his career. He then transitioned to work as a private chef for high-end clients. A job cooking for billionaire investor and minority Steelers owner Thomas Tull brought him to Pittsburgh eight years ago.
He stayed on as Tull’s private chef and also helped develop ice cream flavors for Rivendale Farms, the forward-thinking dairy Tull owned in the late 2010s and early 2020s. Recently, Brenci has sold bread and other baked goods at farmers markets alongside Shaffer under his Forno Brenci banner, worked as a U.S. brand representative for the Mondolfo, Italy-based oven maker Moretti Forni and written a cookbook.
While he’s been here for some time, “this is me introducing myself as a chef to Pittsburgh,” Brenci says.
His tasting menu makes for a nourishing meal, though there are still a few kinks to work out.
Brenci’s work at Michelin-starred restaurants gave him a mental map for methodically organizing a kitchen, but his culinary philosophy remains decidedly Italian: source ingredients that are at the peak of season, match them with staple grains and care about how you prepare everything.
“Sure, I have a million techniques and a million ideas. But how I design the menu is always centered on what's available at the moment,” Brenci says. “It tastes better. It feels better.”
Dinner in August started with a three-dish salvo.
Bread and butter using Brenci's toasted high-hydration focaccia, a compound herb butter and fermented garlic honey is something I'd like to eat every night. The mushroom tartlette, with foraged hen of the woods and pickled peppers, was a summer highlight, a balance of earth, herbs and tartness in a crisp shell.
The third dish in the course demonstrated how his goal and execution aren’t yet perfectly in line.
Cantaloupe with salted cucumber in a gazpacho dusted with sumac looked like the apex of summer in orange, yellow, green and red. Unfortunately, it was overburdened with salt, and the delivery wasn’t as thought out as the other dishes. Serving soup for two in a single bowl might be a romantic gesture for a couple, but a table of pals would probably prefer some side bowls and a serving spoon for this family-style course.
Shaffer created the new kitchen in what was previously a raw basement space.
“She had a good vision for how to maximize each little corner and how the structure would work,” Brenci says.
He then used his experience as a brand representative for Moretti Forni to furnish the small area with the most efficient systems he could find. He couldn't use fryers or gas burners because the space doesn't have a hood, but he didn't particularly want to anyway. Instead, he's using a modern convection oven and induction stovetop with time-honored preparation techniques such as fermentation and maceration.
The basic idea is to front-load the prep work to make service as seamless as possible.
“Right now, we have an abundance of fresh ingredients. So it's very simple ... two or three steps before we send it out,” Brenci says.
The second course was a beautiful frisée and romaine salad with herb vinaigrette and two dishes that showcased Brenci’s respect for cucina povera, the Italian cooking philosophy of zero-waste resourcefulness.
Dinner hit the highest mark with sourdough gnocchi in plum tomato sauce with basil pesto. Brenci started making the dish as a way to turn leftover bread into something useful but now is making extra bread for this dish because the technique is a hit with anyone who’s had it.
While regular pasta is basically one step away from candy in terms of simple carbohydrates (no shame; pasta is still heroic), these chewy dumplings carry all the benefits of long-fermented bread with the joy of eating pasta. The luscious, bright sauce it was served in was spiked with tomato slices that tasted like fruit.
Pappa al pomodoro with whole-grain sourdough and a salsa of summer tomatoes was nice enough, but it rang a little too similar to the gnocchi. Summer squash and green beans were also at their peak when I visited, and I wondered why he didn’t take advantage of those vegetables. Brenci is doing terrific work in a very small basement kitchen, but there’s opportunity here to push a little deeper.
The final course — strawberry and tomato semifreddo with crumbled streusel — was well composed, with dots of reduced onion vinegar adding a bittersweet zing that rounded out the sweeter notes.
The menu adheres to Shaffer's sustainable business practices, which include a zero-waste philosophy and a fiercely localized approach to the bottom line.
“The economy here in this building is ours,” she says. “There is no developer we're paying. We don't look to outside funding. That means we can be adventurous, and we can make decisions about our program that don't have to have profitability right at the forefront. That's empowering.”
While the zero-waste ethos is a laudable keystone, occasionally it goes a bit too far — like handing out menus that are actively falling apart. A little Scotch tape would go a long way to keep things cute, and eventually it’s time to send the paper to the compost bin and print new ones.

Even with the ambitious new menu, Tina's remains a steadfast neighborhood bar. It continues to draw elements from its dive roots — the space previously housed Tea Bag's — blended with mid-century modern decor and subtle, intentional touches like tilting bar seats toward each other to encourage patrons to skip the contemporary practice of leaving an empty seat between groups.
Tina's has continued to innovate its drinks offerings without losing the core of its beverage program. The cocktail menu leans toward classics such as martinis and negronis, but also has low-ABV options and old-time, almost no-alcohol, housemade phosphate soda drinks. There are still $7 drinks on the menu (in this economy!) and some upscale twists. Shaffer oversees the wine program, which is focused on bottles and glasses from biodynamic producers across the world.
Dinner is currently served Thursday through Sunday, with advance reservations recommended.
Now, they are looking to expand into lunch service, with the tinned fish program moving to the center of daytime hours. No date for that phase is set yet, but the couple are already planning more upgrades.
“In the spring we'll bring in new technology and keep growing,” Brenci says, noting a desire for a gelato machine.
A dumbwaiter is coming as part of a January remodel, too. It’ll save thousands of steps up the narrow staircase from the basement to the main floor.
“We're all excited about that,” Shaffer says.
4114 Main St., Bloomfield; tinaspgh.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.