Six cities – Pittsburgh, Detroit, Minneapolis, Milwaukee, Cleveland and Indianapolis – announced earlier this month that their respective tourism bureaus had partnered to bring the Michelin Guide to a collective region known as the American Great Lakes.
The announcement stirred a heck of a lot of buzz and debate, and also prompted a bunch of questions about what it means. The Post-Gazette has answers.
Who’s responsible for the Michelin Guide?
The same French company famous for its tires. Brothers Andre and Edouard Michelin started the guide in the late 1800s to encourage new automobile drivers to hit the road and explore (and, by doing so, wear out their tires and purchase new ones).
The guide's producers began hiring inspectors and awarding stars in the 1920s, expanding the hierarchy to up to three stars in 1936. Michelin Guides first entered the United States with New York City in 2006, and expanded to Asia the following year.
What do the stars mean and how do you get them?
Michelin offers a very broad set of criteria for the three levels of stars:
- 1 star recognizes restaurants that use top-quality ingredients and prepare dishes with distinct flavors to a consistently high standard.
- 2 stars go to restaurants where the team's personalities and talents shine through in expertly crafted dishes, with food that is both refined and inspired.
- 3 stars represent the highest honor. Again, stars belong to restaurants, not chefs, but three-star establishments tend to have chefs at the peak of their profession, with cooking elevated to an art form and some dishes destined to become classics.
Michelin’s shorthand for each level is even more obtuse: 1 star: A very good restaurant in its category. 2 stars: Excellent cooking, worth a detour. 3 stars: Exceptional cuisine, worth a special journey.
If you do a broad analysis of the guide, it tends to favor highly classic Western European cooking techniques, modern “cheffy” style and high-price menus at its top levels, though the inspectors have worked in recent years to incorporate a wider range of global excellence, especially in the one-star category.
What other awards are in the guide?
Beyond the famous stars, Michelin offers several other distinctions:
- Bib Gourmand: Named in honor of Bibendum, the famous Michelin Man mascot, it was introduced in 1997 to recognize restaurants serving outstanding meals at a lower price point.
- Green Star: Introduced in 2020, the recognition focuses on restaurants at the forefront of sustainable practices.
- Michelin also includes "recommended" restaurants in its guides — establishments vetted by inspectors but not yet deemed worthy of a Bib Gourmand or star.
What do the judges look for?
According to a summary from one of its inspectors, Michelin relies on five universal criteria to evaluate a meal: the quality of the products, the harmony of flavors, the mastery of techniques, the chef's personality and consistency across the menu and over time. The evaluation focuses on the food on the plate. Although it's widely assumed that elements such as the style of the restaurant, its level of formality, service, the wine list and the interior decor are factors, Michelin maintains those are excluded from the star rating process.
“We award Michelin Stars for the food on the plate — nothing more,” the guide says on its website.
The inspectors — former hospitality professionals who work full time for Michelin — maintain total anonymity and pay for their own meals to ensure they receive the same treatment as any other customer. They visit a restaurant multiple times during different seasons and times of the week to ensure the cooking is consistent. Final decisions regarding stars are made collectively by a team of inspectors to maintain a global standard, so a star in Pittsburgh carries the same weight as one in Paris, Tokyo or New York City.
In an emailed response to questions from the Post-Gazette, a Michelin representative said: “To compile a list of restaurants that warrant an inspector's visit, we utilize various sources including a deep and constant work directly in the field, which is vital, but also local and national media, social media and word-of-mouth recommendations. The Michelin Guide doesn't reveal specifics about the number of restaurants inspected, the destination assessment process or the inspectors' methods of evaluating a destination.”
Michelin also says a star belongs to the restaurant. If a head chef departs, the restaurant retains its status if the incoming team maintains the same culinary standard. Inspectors conduct additional visits during leadership transitions to verify that the quality of the cooking remains at the award level.
What locations already have Michelin Guides?
The guide currently covers major culinary hubs across Europe, Asia and the Americas. In the United States, the footprint has expanded significantly over the last few years. Beyond New York, Chicago and Washington, D.C., the guide now covers California, Florida, Colorado, Georgia and Texas. In 2025, Michelin added Philadelphia and Boston. American Great Lakes will be the newest addition when it publishes in 2027.
How did it come to Pittsburgh and why did it take so long?
The delay likely stems from the business model Michelin uses in the United States. The company often requires a financial partnership with local or state tourism boards to cover the costs of inspectors and marketing. VisitPittsburgh and other regional tourism districts secured the funding required for this multi-city guide.
Jerad Bachar, president and CEO of VisitPittsburgh, says Michelin has been looking to extend its reach beyond major coastal markets.
“It's been associated with larger markets while not giving a lot of attention to smaller cities in the center of the country,” he says. “It's one of the unique ways to push a collective food scene onto a global scale.”
According to the emailed response to Post-Gazette questions, “The anonymous inspection team has spent time assessing the culinary landscape throughout the six cities – and is continuing to do so — visiting numerous restaurants as they conduct thorough research. The Michelin Guide doesn't reveal specifics about the destination assessment process or the inspectors' methods of evaluating a destination.”
Bachar says the six-city coalition made sense given shared geography and goals, as well as the individual goal of boosting Pittsburgh’s tourism.
“We're somewhat an East Coast city, somewhat a Midwest city but we are often considered a part of the Great Lakes region, especially in the context of international tourism,” he says. “Football aside, we have a lot in common with these cities, too.”
How much did it cost us?
Cleveland Scene reports that Destination Cleveland contributed $150,000 and National Today writes that Minneapolis spent $250,000, funded by a 2% tax on large hotel stays via its Tourism Improvement District, for a three-year contract.
Bachar says VisitPittsburgh's contribution, approved by its board of directors, was “on the lower end of the range” and came from board approval to use the organization's existing budget.
Michelin declined to discuss the overall financial terms.
Will Pittsburgh get any stars?
Perhaps, but don’t get your hopes too high that Pittsburgh restaurants will earn many, if any, stars in the 2027 edition of the Great Lakes guide.
Just three restaurants in Philadelphia — Her Place Supper Club, Friday Saturday Sunday and Provenance — were awarded one star in the inaugural 2025 guide. A more realistic outlook is a handful of Bib Gourmands and a few more recommended listings.
“The online world has lit up with theories about Pittsburgh's food scene and what should be included,” Bacher says. “Hopefully Pittsburgh will be among the first round stars. Even Bib Gourmand and recommended restaurants are a win. This is a long-term play, though.”
Do we need a Michelin Guide in Pittsburgh?
Bachar makes a two-part case in the affirmative.
One is the expected boost in culinary tourism. Many travelers now build their trips around exploring restaurants, and a good number of those tourists use the Michelin Guide as their framework. I also think that we might see people in one of the cities in the American Great Lakes Guide making quests to visit honored restaurants in the other five.
The other is the broader visitor market Pittsburgh already targets, including convention business and a budding luxury travel market.
“This is another point we can make to them in our case to choose our city,” Bachar says.
A.A. Gill wrote about the flip side of the Michelin Guide’s dominance in a 2012 story for Vanity Fair. Nearly 14 years later, most of the points of the late Scottish food writer still hold up.
In his signature colorful prose, he writes about how chefs might stop cooking for customers and instead cater menus to “invisible, mercurial, undercover inspectors.” As a consequence, “Michelin-starred restaurants began to look and taste the same.”
Gill is most on-point with his critique of tourists who see the red book as the end-all-be-all of culinary travel.
“The Michelin guide also created a new type of customer, the foodie trainspotter, people who aren’t out for a good meal with friends but want to tick a cultural box and have bragging rights on some rare effete spirit,” he writes.
What this all means for Pittsburgh and the other cities in the American Great Lakes region will become clearer when the book is published next year.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.