With a slate of newer openings and more on the way, Bloomfield might be the most dynamic dining neighborhood in Pittsburgh right now.
Camino Coctelería just opened where Del’s Bar & Ristorante once stood. Dad’s Dog & Burger Bar started drawing steady crowds a few blocks away in April. Brothmonger, barely a year old, counts a multitude of fans for its soup-and-sandwich counter; it’s also one of our top five best quick-serve joints. Fet-Fisk, not yet 2 years old, keeps racking up national acclaim, and last month earned a spot on our Best Restaurants list.
Zack Shell and Kat Muscianesi saw the wave coming. They offically opened Baby Loves Tacos on Liberty Avenue in 2018, back when nearby Lawrenceville was still the epicenter of the Pittsburgh dining conversation and Bloomfield was just in the early stages of transitioning away from its roots as Little Italy.
Seven years later, Shell and Muscianesi are aiming to expand next door. The space is twice the size of the original, has room for a full prep kitchen and had previously housed a permitted restaurant.
It might have been a smooth transition. Instead, they’re still waiting on permits months after filing an application to move. Meanwhile, the original Baby Loves Tacos space is about to become someone else’s restaurant.
Dexter Edwards, who runs Phat Bagel with Tom Hermanowski, is preparing to open in that space following a year of building momentum at pop-ups and farmers markets. He and Shell worked out an arrangement about seven months ago that would allow Baby Loves Tacos the financial freedom to get out of its lease and open in the adjacent space while Edwards moved into its existing one.
Phat Bagel rising

Edwards has joked for years with his brother about opening a customizable spread bagel shop. In 2023, after getting sober, he decided to take the idea seriously. Encouraged by friends who run independent businesses, he began working out recipes at home, refining them through trial and error and plenty of YouTube videos.
He was also working at Square Cafe, where he shared early prototypes with co-workers.
His time there, he says, “got me used to waking up early,” which happens to be good training for a bagel baker.
Through his recovery network, Edwards also connected with Tony Daddabbo, a veteran of Columbia Bagels in New York City who had recently launched Auburn Bagel Company. The mentorship proved pivotal.
“He took me under his wing,” Edwards says. “He mentored me and helped me to develop the recipe.”
The bagels — big, hand-rolled and cold-fermented — are built on all-purpose flour fortified with vital wheat gluten, clocking in at about 12.5-3% protein.
“The addition of the vital wheat gluten lets us control the chew,” Edwards says. “It gets a good rip, but you’re not sandwiching out all the fillings.”
In December 2024, Phat Bagel started selling at the Bloomfield Wine Market, where his big, chewy bagels quickly found fans. This year at the Bloomfield Saturday Market his business regularly drew long lines. He also offers pickup orders at Trace Brewing on Friday and Saturday mornings.
It’s a return to the neighborhood for Edwards. He worked at now-closed Del’s and Lombardozzi’s during his late teens and 20s, lived nearby and hung out at many of the businesses along Liberty Avenue.
“Liberty Avenue has always had such good foot traffic, and it’s so easy to get in and out of town,” he says. “There’s a great food community here now, too.”
Edwards plans to open the Phat Bagel storefront at the end of November or early December.
He’s following a bit of a Cold Stone Creamery inspiration for the spot. Customers will pick their bagel — classics including plain, poppy, everything and sesame — and then a base such as cream cheese, goat cheese or avocado.
From there, you’ll be able to choose from a variety of mix-ins like pickled onions, hot honey, dill and pepper flakes to create a custom spread. Edwards says the establishment will also offer suggested combinations for those who don’t want to think too much about a morning bagel order.
“There can be preference, taste or dietary needs,” he says, noting that vegan and gluten-free alternatives are in the works. “We want to offer as many options as we can.”
A shift next door — but not quite yet

Moving into the space previously occupied by Nana’s Place by Gibson would allow Shell and Muscianesi to vastly expand Baby Loves Tacos’ production and prep space, something they’ve needed for a long time.
Shell was first approached about the space several years ago. He considered opening a Philadelphia-style sandwich shop, but didn’t have the financial runway to get it going. Paying to break the lease on the existing spot to move next door added another barrier. So the couple held off on submitting plans, figuring the move would have to wait.
That changed about seven months ago when Shell and Edwards worked out the plan for Edwards to take over Baby Loves Tacos’ existing space.
Shell says both operators submitted their paperwork around the same time. But while Edwards’ review advanced, his sat idle.
“They knew we were going to move next door, and we were told the process should be easy since the space previously housed a permitted restaurant,” Shell says.
It hasn’t been. Shell has returned in person to follow up and says the experience echoes the delays that marked Baby Loves Tacos’ original opening in 2018. He (and many other restaurant operators) say the sluggish permitting process puts independent operators at a disadvantage even when they’ve done everything by the book.
“I’m not trying to cause a problem, but come on,” he says. “We live in the neighborhood. We care about our neighbors. Can’t there be a little bit of common sense?”
According to Ronnie Das, public health information officer for the Allegheny County Health Department, the Food Safety Program didn’t receive an application from Shell until Oct. 1.
“The Allegheny County Health Department values the vital role that small businesses play in strengthening our local economy and contributing to the health and vibrancy of our communities,” Das says in an emailed statement to the Post-Gazette. “The Food Safety Program is committed to working collaboratively with all business owners to promote public health and provide clear guidance and support throughout the permitting and inspection processes. We remain dedicated to transparency, fairness, and partnership with the business community.”
“Our goal is to help every establishment in Allegheny County succeed while maintaining the highest standards of health and safety for residents and visitors alike.”
Meanwhile, Edwards needed to get moving on renovations for Phat Bagel. After delaying the move-in a few months, he’s now in the building, leaving Baby Loves Tacos temporarily without a home.
Shell says he hopes to reopen in the larger space by the end of November. Until then, he’s juggling the operation along. The Health Department granted permitting to allow for Baby Loves Tacos to continue to prepare food from an inspected and permitted location for pop-ups and catering while the restaurant is in limbo, and they launched over the weekend at Linea Verde Green Market, also on Liberty Avenue. Look for details on where and when more will take place on Baby Loves Tacos Instagram page.
Shell says it’s frustrating that there’s no process to account for business owners who have operated with clean track record and strong community investment who are looking to expand.
“I know that the Health Department is understaffed, but this is something that seems to be happening all the time,” Shell says. “Isn't this what everybody wants to have — two vibrant businesses next to each other instead of one sitting vacant like it has for a few years?”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.