At dinner the other night at Cucina Alfabeto, Canadian scallops the size of a 50-cent piece were seared with precision, their caramelized edges giving way to tender, just-cooked interiors. A crisp fried artichoke heart and a bittersweet artichoke purée with ginger-lemon dressing offered contrast to the sweet bivalves, hinting at what the new kitchen team at the North Side restaurant could be capable of.
Jonathan Pruett is the latest chef to lead the kitchen in the Alphabet City building on North Avenue. He follows Maurizio Esposito, who ran Cucina Alfabeto for less than a year following a rocky transition in the wake of the sudden closure of its predecessor, the lauded 40 North, in July 2024.
Pruett and owner Woody Ostrow have stripped Alfabeto of its white tablecloths and consolidated the menu into something they describe as more approachable than the upscale Northern Italian cuisine designed by Esposito.
“Elevated casual is my ethos with food,” Pruett says.
Yet for all its cosmetic and culinary shifts, Alfabeto still seems to be grappling with its core identity: Is it a restaurant that supports a cultural center, or a cultural center that happens to serve dinner?
Few restaurant spaces in Pittsburgh carry the kind of conceptual burden that comes with operating inside Alphabet City, which also houses a performance venue and bookstore run by City of Asylum.
On a Tuesday night in late July, a pal and I were one of just two parties seated in Alfabeto’s dining room, which does indeed feel more comfortable than when I dined there last November. The service was warm and professional, and the crusty house-baked bread, a welcome start.
However, the first 45 minutes of the experience felt muted. A literary reading and talk in the performance space went unlisted on Alfabeto’s major events calendar. (You could find it by digging a bit deeper into the City of Asylum website.) And with the dining room already quiet, we felt like we had to whisper through dinner. Lowering the curtains between the spaces might have helped, as would a heads-up when the reservation was made.
Henry Reese, City of Asylum’s co-founder, said the goal has always been to operate a restaurant that complements the organization’s literary and cultural work.
“The idea was to create an atmosphere that was different than other cultural events and to animate the space with extra vibrancy,” he says.
He acknowledges that programming and dining can sometimes create tension.
“We need an atmosphere that people recognize when we have programming, that’s part of the experience,” he says. “When there aren’t programs, you want it to be competitive with other restaurants.”
The restaurant closed for several weeks after 40 North shut down before reopening last August as Cucina Alfabeto under the direction of Esposito. According to Ostrow, Esposito faced serious health issues from the start, including a major surgery that required weeks of recovery.
Pruett, who had worked with Esposito for the previous two years at Fish Nor Fowl, stepped in.
“I learned a lot of fundamentals from him. He had extensive experience all over the world,” Pruett says of his Australian mentor, who came to Pittsburgh after working in restaurants for more than three decades.
Pruett was promoted to executive chef following the departure of Esposito and his wife, former City of Asylum executive director Caro Llewellyn, a couple of months ago. The couple have since relocated to New York City.
There are glimpses of promise on the new menu, like those scallops which were the highlight of the evening. It’s clear, though, that there is still a lot of work to do.
Ravioli, technically well-executed with delicate pasta and tender chard, suffered from an over-seasoned filling. It felt like Pruett had the right intentions with an elegantly plated duck entrée, but its preparation didn’t quite work with a breast that, while tender, ate dry. It’s a dish that is better suited for a braised leg than what should have been a pink-centered breast.
And for a restaurant that bills itself as local, farm-to-table and sustainable, I have no idea why “new season” asparagus is on the menu when the last spears of locally grown crops have long since gone to fern.
Pruitt says the menu is still a work in progress, and he plans to apply a little more of what he’s learned over the entirety of his career, which includes a stint as sous chef at the since-closed Acorn in Shadyside. He expects to bring back brunch service sometime soon, too.
40 W. North Ave., North Side; cucinaalfabeto.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.