My spirit relished the transformation of pecorino Romano, black pepper and pasta water into luscious, luxurious sauce as my friends and I gleefully noodle-pulled house-made spaghetti from a bowl of cacio e pepe at Bar Marco last week.

Later, as my pals and I lingered comfortably drinking a milk-clarified Campari digestivo in the newly upgraded chairs that finally replaced the original schoolhouse metal seats, my brain mused about why we keep returning to restaurants we love year after year, after year, after year, especially in the midst of a sustained period when our social media feeds are ablaze with new spots worthy of attention.

What exactly makes a restaurant a classic?

Is it because we’ve grown attached to a specific dish? Is it steadiness and reliability? Or is it simply a matter of endurance, the restaurant surviving long after others in its cohorts have closed?

Advertise with us

By traditional standards, Bar Marco hasn’t yet achieved classic status.

Operating for just over 13 years is impressive — indeed, many of its chef-era establishments are no longer around — but it doesn't carry the historic weight of an institution like the 89-year-old Hyeholde or 82-year-old Chinatown Inn.

Nor does it have an irresistible signature dish or two that draws diners back with predictable regularity. The saffron-infused arancini at Bar Marco — golden-fried, mozzarella-filled and served atop a classically vibrant tomato sauce — is delightful, yet not something I'd beeline to the restaurant for just because I’m hard-craving it.

And Bar Marco has moved through quite a few distinct phases, some of them rather chaotic.

Bar Marco owner and executive chef Justin Steel (John Colombo / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

When chef/owner Justin Steel opened Bar Marco with three childhood friends from Greensburg on New Year’s Eve 2011, the vision was to create a wine bar. Pittsburgh (and the nation) wasn’t thinking much about wine back then — the craft cocktail movement was in its heyday — so the team shifted gears toward spirit-forward drinks, but without a defined culinary direction.

Advertise with us

The kitchen went through numerous iterations over the first few years, and the roots for what Bar Marco is today didn’t really begin to take shape until Steel took over as executive chef in 2016. Since buying out his final business partner in 2021 and stepping into his full agency as proprietor, he's steadily guided the Strip District restaurant into clearer, calmer waters, though he had to navigate the turbulence of the COVID-19 pandemic to get to where he is today.

Last month, Steel reintroduced a la carte dining for the first time since the pandemic. For the past years, Bar Marco offered a $45 two-course prix fixe meal, with supplemental options for an additional fee. The set menu guaranteed a minimum check average for the 35-seat restaurant, but also left Steel and his team constrained as to what they could offer guests.

Customers can still order an appetizer and pasta and land at a similar price point, but tables are now free to dig deeper into what the culinary team is offering, and the kitchen has more flexibility with menu changes.

The new menu is an expansion of the vision Steel was developing prior to the pandemic. He’s working in a generally Italian expression, but in a fashion similar to other destination restaurants such as Apteka and Fet-Fisk that are rooted in a European culinary tradition (Poland and Sweden, respectively) but driven by micro-seasonality of what farmers in Western Pennsylvania are producing.

That philosophy came alive beautifully on the cacio e pepe visit, especially with the dishes on the antipasti e insalata (small plates and salads) section of the menu.

Advertise with us

A plate of crisp, verdant asparagus lightly dressed with basil-almond pesto and topped with a gently poached egg demonstrated the delicate transition from early to late spring. Tuna crudo, featuring grassy Ligurian olive oil, tarragon-scented saba vinegar and sharp, bittersweet orange peels, underscored Steel’s commitment to showcasing premium ingredients without getting in their way.

House-made pastas formed the core of the two-course menu, and they remain bright spots on the new a la carte list. Even though a competent home cook could put most of the components together in their kitchen (though probably not be able to, or even want to, make the bronze-die extruded pasta) the Marco kitchen is able to coax an extra layer of flavor that illustrates careful attention to detail.

The broccolini in the orecchiette was a master class in vegetable cooking, drawing out the sweetness of the tender-crisp spring vegetable in the garlicky sauce, even if the heat and salinity in the optional sausage we added was a bit too much (the only swing and miss of the meal).

There are a few larger plate courses on the new menu, and you should consider those as a sharable for the table, too.

Cacio e pepe is a tough dish to get right at a restaurant. Bar Marco nails it. (John Colombo / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Steel credits former executive chef Jamilka Borges (Lilith) with laying the foundation for Bar Marco’s culinary clarity, and emphasizes the continuity and collaboration of his current kitchen team is pivotal in making the restaurant what it is today.

Advertise with us

This stability is mirrored in the front-of-house staff, thanks in part to Bar Marco’s long-standing no-tip model. Even when turnover happens, such as longtime bar manager Jason Renner recently departing after a decade, the baton is passed seamlessly to the next leg of the race.

(Bar Marco’s legacy extends beyond its walls now, too; its alumni have gone on to open or influence at least a dozen restaurants, bars and businesses around Pittsburgh.)

The journey toward classic status for this relatively young restaurant is ongoing.

Replicating dishes like the deceptively simple cacio e pepe night after night poses technical challenges but, all in all, the new a la carte menu demonstrated to me that Bar Marco’s newest phase is another step toward cementing its place as a pillar in Pittsburgh’s restaurant history. (Steel, in a phone call following my meal, said putting a dish like that on the menu “is like playing with fire.”)

Bar Marco may not have checked all the boxes of a classic restaurant quite yet, but if Steel and his exceptionally talented team keep the ship steady, it’s well on the path toward becoming one.

2216 Penn Ave., Strip District; barmarcopgh.com