The New York Times listed Fet-Fisk in Bloomfield as one of the honorees on its The Restaurant List 2024: Our 50 Favorite Places in America Right Now.

It is the second restaurant in Pittsburgh to have made the cut for the list, which is now in its fourth year. Apteka in Bloomfield was included in 2022.

Fet-Fisk was described by food writer Priya Krishna as feeling “lived in — and not just because of the vintage platters and wood paneling. The co-founders Nik Forsberg and Sarah LaPonte have created an atmosphere, and a Nordic-inflected menu, that is refined (the bright and fennel-y seafood salad is a far cry from the gloppy picnic version) yet comfortable and unfussy.”

The Bloomfield establishment’s menu, now prepared with co-chef Csilla Thackray, is also rooted in Western Pennsylvania foodways and deep seasonality. The Times praised Fet-Fisk’s thin-sliced scallop appetizer served with pickled strawberries and the restaurant’s chicken, which then was smothered in a tart lingonberry sauce; a couple of weeks ago, Forsberg and Thackray paired the juicy, crispy chicken with peaches and it is currently served with apples.

Advertise with us

Get there if you can to catch the tail end of the late summer/early autumn run of meaty chanterelles, which taste like a Sunday grill party in a reduction of Grüner Veltliner, chicken jus and lingonberry. Don’t skip the french fries (neither Nordic nor seasonal, but oh-so dreamy), either.

Forsberg and LaPonte launched Fet-Fisk as a pop-up in 2019, quickly gaining an enthusiastic following for its thematic, thoughtful meals meant for sharing. “It became so beloved that Mr. Forsberg was nominated for a James Beard award in 2023 even without a brick-and-mortar spot,” Krishna writes in her blurb on the restaurant.

Forsberg brought Pittsburgh food stalwarts Kate Romane and Greg Austin into the mix as he moved the concept from pop-up to brick-and-mortar, with LaPonte returning from completing graduate studies in North Carolina. The standalone restaurant opened at the end of March.

The ambiance at Fet-Fisk is a deft blend of influences, drawing from the building’s previous iteration as Lombardozzi’s, old-school neighborhood dives, nautical journeys and cozy, cosmopolitan comfort. I'm a big fan of the 45-seat lounge, either at the horseshoe-shaped bar or the tables, where streaming daylight gives way to moody red and green lighting. The more brightly lit dining room is better for larger groups.

4786 Liberty Ave., Bloomfield; fetfisk.net