Picking a single “best dish,” or even a handful of dishes, of the year is an impossible task. Pittsburgh’s restaurants offer a multitude of tasty options and I did my darnedest to explore as many as possible in 2023. What follows are the meals, dishes and moments that moved me most in the past year.

Apteka, bliss

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

There aren’t many seasonal dishes I long for enough to mark on my calendar for an annual return. The ultra-dreamy shake at Apteka’s “Crapteka” spinoff is one of those fleeting treats I look forward to every January, when Kate Lasky and Tomasz Skowronski transform their acclaimed Bloomfield restaurant into a whimsical burger and fry joint.

The twist here is that the Crapteka offerings are entirely vegan, reflecting the restaurant’s day-to-day menu. With no dairy at their disposal, the duo weaves magic from sunflowers, transforming the fatty seeds of the plant into a creamy concoction that’s better than what you’ll receive at the local ice cream drive-through. As always, Crapteka 2023 hit the mark.

Advertise with us

However, sunflower shakes and perfect fries accompanied by fantasy sauces alone don’t inform us about how the couple became the first finalists for the James Beard Award for Best Chef: Mid-Atlantic in Pittsburgh history. Peak-season, high-quality Western Pennsylvania produce was a full-tilt joyride on a June visit when a few friends and I devoured almost the entire menu.

Among the highlights of the meal: mizeria, crisp Kirby cucumbers marinated in caraway vinegar, dill, onion and parsley oil; letnia duszonka, a succulent summer stew with yellow-eye beans, yellow-wax beans, sauteed zucchini, tomatoes, beet zakwas and double-fat; and kotlet selerory, a hardy celeriac schnitzel with beet, leek and apple salad and horseradish sauce.

Pizza is life

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

I have a deep and abiding passion for pizza (this is pretty evident if you’ve followed my work for any time).

A friend observed how I’d dipped out of a lively conversation at Trace Brewing over the summer as I became increasingly entranced enjoying (and, I’m sure, analyzing) my margherita pie from Alberta’s Pizza. (Trace, by the way, gets my vote for 2023’s most engaging brewery in Pittsburgh.)

Advertise with us

I was thinking about how Beau Mitall’s mobile wood-fired pizza operation, which has long been quite good, had hit a new high, particularly in the mouthfeel of the dough structure. With its thin, pliant and caramelized base balanced by Mitall’s bright, tangy sauce and creamy-tart fresh mozzarella, the pie had me buzzing for the rest of the night.

It was so good that I added his mobile business and Sean Jefairjian’s A Slice of New York to my Best Pizza in Pittsburgh list. Jefairjian moved squarely into the Pittsburgh-area pizza conversation with his leveled-up New York City pies. Shortly after the opening of the new Murrysville spot, slice after slice of the cheese pie transported me back to my childhood in New York.

Along the way, there were must-do, craving-satisfaction visits to Rockaway Pizza, Pizza Lupo, Woodfired, Driftwood Oven and Gus Franco’s, as well as some new highlights. The calzone at Mercurio’s, which I’d never tried, rocked me, as did Tamilselvan Thangadurai’s Indian-fusion pies at Mintt Pizza and Indian Cuisine in Cranberry. Kudos to the stepped-up Badamo’s at its new digs in Dormont, too.

Angkor Cambodian Restaurant

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A pivotal moment this year started with a chance Monday night exploration. Little did I know that the spontaneous decision a friend and I made to eat at an unassuming restaurant in a strip mall in Oakwood would lead to several of my favorite meals (and my favorite story) of the year.

Advertise with us

Kim Hong and her son, Bo Meng, came to Pittsburgh as refugees in 1981, the only members of their immediate family to survive a genocide in Cambodia that took at least 1.5 million (and as many as 3 million) lives. They started operating restaurants in 1991 and now Angkor, which opened in 2002, is just one of two restaurants in Pittsburgh to serve Cambodian cuisine.

Among the many dishes I’ve come to love over several visits in 2023 is lok lak, tender beef served with an electrically marvelous dip called mak nao. Angkor salad is a vibrant mix of flank steak, vegetables and herbs topped with freshly grated galanga, lemongrass, lime rind, ginger and turmeric.

Another star is samlor ktiss manors, wherein chunks of pork spare ribs are braised to melt-in-your-mouth perfection in a velvety mixture of red curry, coconut milk, tomato paste, lemongrass, galanga, cinnamon, cardamom, star anise, toasted garlic, and shallots. This softly luscious dish is completed with bright pineapple chunks, cloves, tomatoes and straw mushrooms.

Feasts among friends

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

My dear pals and I have a long-standing tradition of gathering every couple of months for a fantastic feast at one of Pittsburgh’s outstanding Chinese restaurants.

Advertise with us

Amazing Dumplings is always a hub, as we marvel at Fengping Geng’s artistry in her dumping making. This year, her handmade dumplings became even more winsome as she delivered rainbows of color with her made-from-scratch vegetable dyes. Her holiday shapes (spooky eyeballs for Halloween, darling bunnies for Easter) proved a whimsical addition to her craft.

Her husband Feng Gao’s balance of bold and subtle flavors demonstrated a lot of growth, too, offering Xi’an and Shaanxi dishes such as chopped pepper biang biang, hand-pulled noodles and spicy sour soup with pork and napa dumplings. The couple also made their first appearance at Churchview Farm in 2023 to helm a multi-course dinner at the Baldwin farm. Geng’s delicious mountain of radish picked fresh from the farm, finely grated, studded with hot peppers and served with a tangy and sweet sauce was a highlight of a magical evening.

As always, I organized a few grand Sichuan banquets at Chengdu Gourmet and Yue Bai Wei. Were there specific standout dishes from our meals at any of them in 2023? Probably. But does it matter?

Sure, hyper-talented chefs Wei Zhu (Chengdu Gourmet) and Zhiyuan Tang (Yue Bai Wei) both offered some bonkers delectable bone-in lamb chops, and Zhu’s Chengdu Gourmet 2’s new fish tanks inspired some ultra-tasty bites, but when I look back on it now everything blends into a fever dream of deliciousness. What you want to do when you’re visiting these spots with a crew is to assemble a balance of hot, sour, mild and vegetal dishes.

New to the rotation this year is Little Corner Grill House, which opened in September. I have had a few incredible visits sharing hot pots with friends at the North Oakland spot. The basic gist is that a bowl of broth is kept simmering on a heating element at the center of a table, laden with a selection of meat, seafood, vegetables and starches. We all took turns dipping ingredients such as shaved pork, lotus root, fish filets and ramen noodles in co-owner Kevin Gao’s bubbling broths. I look forward to taking advantage of the restaurant’s extended hours (the BYOB spot is open until 2:30 a.m. nightly) in 2024.

Advertise with us

Now open

(Tim Robbibaro / For the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

There were shining moments at some of Pittsburgh’s other newest restaurants, too.

Foremost were the meals I had at Duo’s Taqueria. Ordering chicken is an underrated move at restaurants. When prepared properly, it offers exceptional bites and serves as a counterpoint to lighter vegetable dishes and bold hammers such as lush lamb shanks and double-cut pork chops.

Duo’s Taqueria pollo rostizado is my pick of the year for Pittsburgh’s chicken dish of 2023. The birds are marinated with lime and orange juices, dried chilies and vinegar and roasted to a crisp exterior with a succulent interior. Half chickens are served with a pasilla chile salsa and chicken juice finished with Maple Valley honey. The lush dish comes with creamy refried bayo beans and a heap of house-made tortillas.

Two meals at the beautiful Balvanera in the Strip District have me raring to go for more in 2024. My move is to start with lovely small bites such as gildas, add a few rotisserie-cooked vegetables and house-made sausages and perhaps a steak or fish dish. Then, go wild with the pastry chef Ginger Fisher Baldwin’s dessert menu. Her warm, sticky toffee cakes, fernet-infused, burnt-caramel flan and house-made ice creams are utterly delightful.

Advertise with us

You can find out what I love about all of 2023’s eight stellar openings on my just-released Best New Restaurants list.

Pop-up parties

(Hal B. Klein / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

2023 was an outstanding year for pop-ups in Pittsburgh. Of the many I attended, two stood out as the most memorable.

A dessert of poached and fresh peaches, corn custard, rye Genoise, hyssop and whipped cream (plus a noise maker) spotlighted the peak bounty of late summer in Pittsburgh. The dish was a gorgeous, fitting end for Fet Fisk’s run as a pop-up series. From its first iteration in January 2019 as a DIY happening in what would become the Pigeon Bagels space in Squirrel Hill, to its stunning finale in August at Black Radish Kitchen, Nik Forsberg, Sarah LaPonte and crew threw Ambrosian parties celebrating the intersection of delightful means and vibrant social spaces.

The lean-forward nature of Forsberg’s final menu showed why he earned his first James Beard Award, Best Chef: Mid-Atlantic, semifinalist nod this year.

Advertise with us

Other highlights of an all-bangers menu included a Niçoise salad spin that popped with smoked trout, crisp, peak-season green beans, briny olives, peppy summer tomatoes and luscious new potatoes. Seared steelhead spun similar ingredients – river fish, tomatoes, Romano beans and herbs – into an entirely different experience (brighter, intertwined with more bass notes) when pan-cooked together over high heat.

The standalone Fet-Fisk restaurant in the former Lombardozzi’s space in Bloomfield is expected to open very early next year.

Pop-ups are part of the ecosystem at Soju in Garfield, helping to fuel the creativity and verve in the kitchen. Chef/owner Simon Chough and Gary Marshall of GS Sando Co. (also a Soju chef) collaborated on several of them in 2023, and their October one stood out alongside the final Fet Fisk as my favorite of the year. It was a beautiful celebration of autumn and a different take on a seasonal dinner than a typical farm-to-table situation.

Their elegant menu mended some lighter touches of Japanese and Korean cuisines with bold flavors. The presentation of the dishes echoed these touches, with soft orange chrysanthemum, red trout roe and silver-gray saltwater eel topping a bowl of delicately oceanic chawanmushi.

Meanwhile, a bold beef-marrow bone topped a clay pot of crispy tallow-rich rice, bold nightshade dashi and savory, crispy scallions. That combination of starch, fat, umami and crunchiness shook me to my core, tasting like the best part of a hamburger without the weightiness of eating a hamburger. It even had a longtime pescatarian slipping in a few spoonfuls.

Advertise with us

Staples

(Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

One of the best parts about my job is that I’m always looking for new and new-to-me places, delving into projects such as my Best Bagels in Pittsburgh list or digging into neighborhoods for our ongoing Eat Pittsburgh series. The downside is that I don’t get to visit some of my touchstone restaurants as often as I should. When I do, I relish it. Do try to be a regular at one of your neighborhood restaurants if you can.

At Bar Marco, chef/owner Justin Steel received a December shipment of tennis ball-sized white truffles from a source in Alba, Italy. If I were pressed to pick the singular dish of 2023 that had me singing “Hallelujah!!” loudest, it was a profoundly pheromonal bowl of those truffles shaved over Steel’s airy potato gnocchi in Salva Cremasco fondita and black pepper sauce.

Among my other “it’s no surprise that these were among my favorite dishes of the year” from my Pittsburgh go-to's were Elysian Fields lamb shank and charcoal-cooked pork belly from Pusadee’s Garden, whole Laurel Hill Farm trout with salsa verde from Morcilla and the uncomplicated beauty of Madeleine Bakery and Bistro’s ham and butter baguette.

Final course for fun: Spirit’s Spaghetti Disco 

Advertise with us

File this one under “unnecessarily delicious.” There’s no good reason for the spaghetti and meatballs served at Spirit’s monthly(ish) Spaghetti Disco to be as delightful as they are.

It’s a free giveaway served at midnight to a crowd of dancing partygoers, so this could be prepped hours in advance and held in a warm oven and people would still happily eat it.

Yet, the kitchen crew at Spirit goes out of the way to serve spaghetti cooked, sauced and topped with juicy meatballs moments before event organizer Jarrett Tebbets, aka DJ Hoagie Dreams, triumphantly struts from the venue’s kitchen to share the goods with the evening’s revelers.

Day-by-day, Spirit also consistently serves some of my favorite, highly seasonal salads in Pittsburgh. The Lawrenceville bar and entertainment venue is capping 2023 with chicory, which highlights Coldco Farm’s impeccable winter bounty of bitter greens and sweet carrots, balanced with feta cheese, pepitas, Jannamico Super Punch-infused currants and black garlic vinaigrette.

Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, Twitter @halbklein and IG @halbklein.