A chef at Casbah recently was developing a new dish and thought a lemon-tarragon beurre blanc would complement the fish well. But there was a problem. Customers would very likely order the fish for takeout, and that emulsified sauce could be counted on to separate by the time it reached its final destination.
Before COVID-19, that wouldn’t have been a consideration. “Putting an item on the menu at Casbah, we wouldn’t ask ourselves how it would travel,” said Bill Fuller, president and corporate chef of Big Burrito Restaurant Group, which counts the Shadyside restaurant among its holdings.
Nowadays, that’s a must. Delivery across the country is up 25% for the year ending in November 2021, according to Port Washington, N.Y.-based research firm NPD Group. That increase is on top of the wild gains of the year ending November 2020, when delivery was up 108%.
The fish? It ended up paired with a light aioli.
This is menu planning during a pandemic.
As restaurants near two years of operating against a constantly shifting backdrop of rising food prices, supply chain disruptions, staffing shortages and increased demand for takeout and delivery, the need for nimble adjustments has impacted what ends up on your plate.
Read More
Due to supply chain issues alone, 75% of restaurants nationally have had to change menu items in recent months, per a November survey by the National Restaurant Association in Washington, D.C. That percentage rises when looking at sit-down restaurants, according to the study, with 85% of fine dining and 81% of casual dining spots adjusting menus.

Disruptions in the supply chain are ongoing — and hardly predictable.
“It’s literally case by case, sometimes day by day, sometimes week to week,” Soju chef-owner Simon Chough said. Staples for his Korean restaurant, including tofu, have been challenging to find at times. And if there’s no tofu, that means he can’t serve several items on his menu, including the Killer Tofu appetizer.
“It impacts me tremendously,” the Garfield restaurateur said. Ahi tuna has been so difficult to procure, Soju hasn’t offered it.
This sometimes daily search for supplies, from ingredients to paper products, covers the gamut. For Nicky’s Thai, Singha beer was temporarily unavailable and rice noodles became hard to get, general manager Dave Brunner said.
At Mad Mex, the hot sauce used for its wings stopped being available — “the shipper stopped shipping it,” Mr. Fuller said — as did the favored brand of diced tomatoes (for salsa). When their black bean supplier went dark for a bit, “we went back to cooking beans in-house.”
About a month ago, lamb proved particularly difficult to find, Tana Ethiopian owner Seifu Haileyesus recalled. Since that’s an important protein at the East Liberty establishment, “We tried many stores and many different suppliers” with no luck.
In that situation, there was one choice: “We just notify customers, as soon as they come in, we say it is not available,” he said, adding that the shortage has ended for now.
Prices are up, way up
When items are in stock, they’re very likely to cost more. The Consumer Price Index for overall food prices saw a 6.1% year-over-year uptick for the period ending in November, a 12-month increase that’s the largest since 1982, per the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
That tracks with the 92% of Pennsylvania restaurants that reported, in a September National Restaurant Association survey, they were paying increased prices for food as compared to pre-COVID.
The results play out in myriad ways, from how much cost a restaurant is willing to absorb to potentially removing a dish altogether.
Crab, for instance, has been so expensive that Mr. Fuller removed it from menus. It’s also, he noted, difficult to obtain.
Across Big Burrito’s restaurants (Eleven, Kaya and Umi among them), he said menus have shrunk by 20-25%.
Crab meat is still on the menu at Nicky’s Thai, but it may not remain for long. “It’s just been so pricey that we’re contemplating removing it,” Mr. Brunner said. “It’s gone up about 50%.”

A more common protein that’s inched toward being cost-prohibitive is a game day MVP: chicken wings. And those prices have flapped all over the place.
“The sticker shock of some of the wings really pushed some people away,” said Matt Cercone of The Original Big Shot Bob’s House of Wings in Avalon. “That’s understandable. Chicken wings are up there with prices of steak and sushi.”
Pre-pandemic, a dozen wings at Big Shot Bob’s were $13.99. In more recent months, the same would have set patrons back $22.99. Six weeks ago, Mr. Cercone said, he was able to reduce the total to $19.99.
“We’ve raised the prices of wings more in the past nine months than in the past nine years,” he said.
A House of Wings, of course, has to offer wings. At Nicky’s Thai, Mr. Brunner said, the price surge was such that “we didn’t even touch that item.” The restaurant, with three Pittsburgh locations, occasionally had offered Thai wings, but, he said, “We still are avoiding putting wings on because it’s still a little elevated.”
For Mr. Cercone, the choice was try to find a different product or raise the price to keep the same quality. He chose the latter, but that meant pretty much eating the cost.
“We’re operating at a loss. Not a crazy loss, but a big enough loss that it didn’t feel good.”
‘To go, please’
The thing about foods like wings is that they’re great for takeout, and restaurants have been taking stock of menu items that travel well.
In addition to the surge of food deliveries, carry-out increased 2% for the year ending in November 2021, according to the NPD Group. Looking at year-over-year from 2019 to 2020, takeout was up 3%.
Pre-pandemic, Mad Mex saw about 6 or 7% of its food production leave the restaurant via takeout. These days, “it’s settled at a pretty steady 20% takeout,” Mr. Fuller said.
When Pennsylvania shut down indoor dining — Allegheny County first shuttered eateries on March 16, 2020 — about 30-40% of state restaurants had already been offering delivery, said Ben Fileccia, director of operations and strategy with the Pennsylvania Restaurant & Lodging Association’s Philadelphia region.
“What the pandemic did do is make so many more people aware of the options that were available for delivery. Looking forward, restaurants are building takeout and to-go as part of their pro forma,” he said.

During COVID, Mr. Chough said, “There was a really high demand for stuff like chicken sandwiches and nachos and all that, so I started delivering that.” Those proved so popular that Soju’s Kimchi-Chi Nachos (built on fried wontons) and fried Spicy Chicken Sandwich are now permanent menu items.
With a let’s just ride this thing out attitude, he said, “You can do fun things.”
Nicky’s Thai has navigated consumer shifts from the perspective of serving patrons at multiple locations — the Downtown location’s business slowed by about 80% during the early days, the North Side site was a bit better, and “the Mt. Nebo location in the suburbs was busier,” Mr. Brunner said.
But while offering delivery initially, when all three restaurants saw customers returning in earnest in August, he said it made sense for the business to halt delivery altogether.
“Because all the restaurants were busy again, and we were a little bit short staffed, we weren’t able to keep up with the demand,” he said.
With delivery apps like GrubHub, DoorDash and UberEats taking a 25-30% commission, ending delivery “was one way we saved money.”
Hanging in there
Profit margins for restaurants are overwhelmingly down, with 90% of state operators reporting slimmer margins since the outbreak’s start, per the National Restaurant Association’s September survey.
While locals make adjustments in varying ways, restaurateurs are holding onto what we all are: That this too shall pass.
“The price changes definitely has affected our profit margin, because we cannot justify increasing the price,” said Tana Ethiopian’s Mr. Haileyesus, who, for now, is absorbing increased costs.
“We have to hold back. And hopefully things will change.”
Polly Higgins: phiggins@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1960, Twitter @higginspolly, IG @pollyhig.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.