They vowed they’d be back.
The sign that hung in the window at Pizzaiolo Primo in Market Square Downtown and the business’ only social media post since June 30 said as much. The restaurant closed indefinitely last summer in the face of a second wave of COVID-19 restrictions on bars and restaurants. The future looked bleak, and the business was put on the market.
But with a change of heart (aided by an influx of investment) Pizzaiolo Primo will make good on that promise to return with a grand re-opening May 11.
“We all knew what a special place this was and we weren’t going to let the virus take it from us,” general manager Michael Zimmerman said.
“Guys are coming back and high-fiving each other like ‘We’re back, we’re back,’” co-owner Ron Sofranko said. “The team is back together and it's pretty cool. There’s a tremendous enthusiasm throughout the staff.”
Sofranko has been in the restaurant business for 33 years and a decade ago was approached by investors wanting to open an Italian place Downtown. He teamed up with Ron Molinaro of Il Pizzaiolo in Mt. Lebanon and in 2013 opened in Market Square featuring some of the best Neapolitan pizzas and Italian food in the city.
Read More
“We put $1.8 million into the whole thing,” he said of the restaurant’s opulent Italian marble and tile.
Then there’s the centerpiece, a wood-burning oven hand-crafted by Italian oven-makers Forno Napoletano. It's made from Italian materials, including volcanic stone from Sorrento.
The restaurant was an immediate success, but Molinaro left the partnership and Sofranko was bought out. The name was changed to Pizzaiolo Primo and it became an anchor of a bustling Market Square.
Early last year, several restaurants on or near the square closed, including Molinaro, a separate Italian restaurant owned by Molinaro. Then the pandemic hastened the demise of others, including NOLA and Sienna. It looked like Pizzaiolo Primo was next.
But Sofranko said he wasn’t ready to give up on the restaurant he’d started.
“I came back in as a partner,” he said. “It’s a 10-year story. I love the concept, the brand and the food.”
Richie Sphatt will reprise his role as executive chef, as will Zimmerman, the general manager.
“I put the A Team together with Richie on the food, Michael on the management. It’s a great organization and great team,” Sofranko said. “I can’t tell you how excited we are.”
They’ve done remodeling, refurbishing and refinishing, and bought some new equipment. They built a temperature- and humidity- controlled “dough room” where they’ll make the pizza dough and fresh pasta.
Zimmerman said he’s geeked to be reopening.
“We aren’t in the restaurant business, we are in the business of Pittsburgh,” he said. “We kind of always thought of ourselves as the front porch of the community, that place where everybody gathers and all walks can come together and have a great time.”
Pizzaiolo Primo: 8 Market Square, Downtown; 412-575-5858; pizzaioloprimo.com
Alta Via Pizzeria
The prolific Big Burrito Group will make its first official foray into the world of pizza when they open Alta Via Pizzeria in the East End’s Bakery Square complex in the fall. Company president Bill Fuller has a succinct answer as to why: “What do people like more than burritos? Pizza.”
It’s a spinoff of their popular Alta Via Italian restaurant, which opened in Fox Chapel in 2019.
“When we were planning and developing Alta Via, people would ask us why we didn’t have pizza and we’d say because it's a pasta place,” he explained. “But as we were playing with dough for our focaccia, we started to experiment, and there are some great flavors and ingredients that I cannot wait to get on to a pizza.”
He said they’ll feature two kinds of pizza, a square pan and a round “California” style with a hearth-baked thin crust that’s fermented for two days.
“That really makes the crust more tasty, with more souring,” he said.
The pizzeria will be located within a new public conservatory in Bakery Square built to connect the former Nabisco baking factory to the newly-constructed building housing Galley-Bakery Square. They’ll also feature sandwiches and salads that emphasize seasonal vegetables, and have a full bar. The concept was originally slated to open on Butler Street in Lawrenceville but “that got COVID-ed,” Fuller said.
“I could eat pizza every day all the time,” he said. “We are looking for ways to give people what they want. We love our places like Eleven, but sometimes you want to go out to dinner and get some good pizza in a restaurant setting.”
Woodfired by Lorelei
The restaurant industry is rife with superstitions about locations and buildings that have good or bad histories, luck and mojo, but what about pieces of equipment?
At Woodfired by Lorelei in East Liberty, they’ve taken over the space — and more importantly the woodfired oven — from the bygone Pizza Taglio, which produced some of the best pizza in Pittsburgh until last year when owner Anthony Giaramita closed the business and moved to Europe.
Pete Kurzweg and Adam Henry, co-owners of Lorelei next-door, as well as the Independent Brewing Co. and Hidden Harbor in Squirrel Hill, couldn’t pass up the opportunity to move in.
“We’re not gonna go do what Tony did — he was literally world-class,” Kurzweg said. “We can’t replace what he did. It’s unattainable. We want to have pies that are paying homage to the Neapolitan tradition, but there are things we’ll do that will make a Neapolitan pizzaiolo lose their mind. It’ll be a mix of classic and modern.”
At present, it operates as a weekend pop-up, with outdoor seating only and the menu is limited to a decadent seven-cheese pizza ($14); pepperoni ($16) and a pair of rotating pies. Recent offerings have included the Salsiccia ($16) with a house-made pork sausage, rapini, red onion, mozzarella and a Taleggio crema; and a perfectly Pittsburgh “Beans & Greens” pizza with spinach and a whipped bean ricotta, Calabrian chiles, rapini, honey and hazelnuts.
They recently brought aboard Dan McGhee, most recently a sous chef at the uber-popular Iron Born Pizza and an alum of Scratch and Morcilla, to further refine the concept, and Kurzweg hopes they’ll be at full bore by mid-June.
Woodfired by Lorelei: 126 S. Highland Ave., East Liberty; 412-214-6926; www.woodfired-pittsburgh.com
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.