There are few foods that evoke as much passion as pizza: Ask a dozen people their favorite and you might get a dozen answers, and everyone has a fierce loyalty for their neighborhood pizza shop.
Matt Porco, Donnie Amman and Chris Clark can rattle off theirs without batting an eye — Casa Del Sole in Aspinwall, Don Campiti’s in Dormont and Napoli in Bridgeville, respectively. It’s a combination of that neighborhood nostalgia along with a career’s worth of experience at top restaurants in Pittsburgh and New York that they’ll bring to Doughbar Pizzeria & Rotisserie, slated to open March 17 at 1831 E. Carson St. on the South Side.
Though whole- or half-bird rotisserie chicken and wings will be on the menu, pizza is the star.
“When you look at Pittsburgh’s pizza historically, we have a neighborhood pizza culture. We are bridging the gap between that and a full-service restaurant with the experience we have, the ideas that we can present, and creating an environment that is a destination,” said Porco, executive chef and co-owner.
“We’re hoping that you can get a little bit of nostalgia,” Clark said. “We’re incorporating ideas from the pizzas we liked when we were young.”
“Our menu is going to be a riff on a neighborhood pizzeria,” Mr. Porco said. “We’re doing our version of a New York-style pizza and then we’re gonna do a sourdough pan, kind of reminiscent of Pizza Hut from when we were kids, back when it was still good,” he said, laughing.
Of course, that’ll come with some restaurant-worthy flourishes.
A menu of specialty pies, like the Sugo, with braised pork in tomato sauce and house-pulled stracciatella cheese, will be cooked in an Italian-made Cuppone electric oven. It’s the Michaelangelo model that has become an industry standard.
“It's a more consistent heat than the old gas ovens. You don’t have to keep moving them around. It has air flow like a convection oven,” Porco said. “We’ll pull our own mozzarella, bake our own hoagie buns. All the dough we can do in house. We’ll make our own sausage.”
“Outside of the pizza, we’re doing rotisserie stuff,” Amman said. “We have a really cool rotisserie oven we’re gonna do some whole birds that are brined and cooked with butter under the skin, and rotisserie wings.”
J.P. Alton, who previously worked at Kevin Sousa’s acclaimed Superior Motors in Braddock, will run the bar, which will feature a slate of composed cocktails and $5 craft draft beers.
Early in his career, Porco spent two years as chef de cuisine at elite Veritas in Manhattan’s Flatiron District before coming home to start his own restaurant, Mio, in Aspinwall, in 2007. Five years later, he joined the Downtown dining renaissance with the COVID-shuttered Sienna Sulla Piazza on Market Square, where Amman was his right-hand man. They went on to open the three-floored, multi-concept Sienna Mercato on Penn Avenue in 2014 and Clark joined the team after several years at the iconic WD-50 in New York City. He also helped to open Superior Motors in 2017.
The trio had started looking for spaces for a new project prior to the pandemic and landed on the South Side.
“We couldn’t be happier with the space,” Porco said of the century-old building that has housed restaurants for decades, from Josie’s Pasta Palace in the 1970s and ’80’s to Bruschetta in the 1990s and 2000s and most recently the defunct local chain Steel Cactus.
Artists Shane Pilster and Max Gonzales have decked the walls with colorful graffiti murals. There is a second-floor outdoor patio and they intend to eventually develop the space into a separate “Late Night” concept for a post-COVID world.
“I think when you get older and you have more life experience, you find that you just want to do what you love. We’re fortunate to create our own environment for that,” Porco said. “As I get older, I've done it all in terms of types of food that I’ve cooked and places that I’ve worked. I just want to make dough. I just want to make pizzas.”
“I’ve been with Matt for 12 years and been side by side with Chris for 10,” Amman said. “There’s no two other guys I’d rather roll the dice with. We’re excited and ready to get open and blow the dust off.”
Carnegie pizza
Carnegie is suddenly an epicenter of crust.
Chef Greg Alauzen has added a pizza offshoot of his highly regarded red sauce temple, LeoGreta. L&G Pizza is open from 3 to 8 p.m., Wednesday through Sunday at 301 W. Main St. for takeout only, offering 16-inch, eight-cut pies including a traditional Margherita, pepperoni and a specialty pie with housemade mortadella and a tapenade sauce.
Just two blocks away at 221 2nd Ave., Dave Anoia and Aimee DiAndrea have opened the third location of their uber-popular Pizzeria Davide. They’re known for their “old world”-style pizza and signature pie with Lebanon sweet bologna and hot pepper relish, along with sandwiches made on house-baked hoagie rolls, Pizzeria Davide is open Tuesday through Sunday from 11 a.m.
They’ll join longtime neighborhood favorites Slice, Raya’s and Sunset Pizza.
Dan Gigler: dgigler@post-gazette.com; Twitter @gigs412




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.