Step inside Nicholas Coffee & Tea Co. in Market Square, and you’d be one of a couple hundred customers who visit the landmark shop in a day.

Walk past the old-fashioned display of jumbo roasted peanuts, as well as the library of tea tins that line the shelves. Greet the baristas who are quick to pour a cup of coffee, make a cappuccino, or grind a pound of a proprietary blend, one of 20-something choices available to drink at home.

Many mornings, George “Jordan” Nicholas, the fourth-generation family member who’s now the head of the company, will walk down from the upstairs office to greet customers. Some are regulars he’s known since he was a kid helping out in the shop. From the second-floor window overlooking the retail floor, he can see people in line — just past the giant roaster his grandfather designed back in the ’50s.

Nicholas Coffee is more than just a coffee shop: It’s the company that helped fuel Pittsburgh’s passion for coffee well before Prestogeorge opened in Monroeville in the 1960s or La Prima debuted in the Strip in 1988.

Advertise with us

The Downtown Market Square headquarters is also the foundation for the family’s mini real estate empire, which includes 35 small buildings — some of which Nick Nicholas owns with his best friend, Jim Patrinos. Mr. Patrinos also has a hand with him in businesses like Primanti Bros. before they sold their majority stake in 2012, Nick said. Since then, the Nicholas family has dialed in on its original Pittsburgh brand, reinvigorating wholesale coffee and tea accounts and accommodating consumers’ tastes, from flavored coffees to single-origin, fair-trade beans.

This week is one of the biggest ever for Nicholas Coffee, which marks its 100th anniversary on Thursday. To celebrate the occasion, the shop will feature a limited-run bold Centennial blend, as well as a bulk coffee and loose-leaf tea buy-one-get-one-half-off sale. All week, it will charge $1 per cup of coffee, then on Thursday that cup is free. Also on Thursday, a bag of that Centennial blend rolls back to 47 cents, the price of a pound back in 1919.

Jordan has been waiting for this moment since he took over the Greek family’s business a decade ago. His taking the helm is the third changing of the guard since the shop first opened in 1919: from Nicholas Constantine Nicholas to his only son, Constantine “Gus” Nicholas, and from Gus Nicholas to Nick Nicholas, Jordan’s father.

“My grandfather stepped aside for my dad after World War II,” Nick said. “Then my dad stepped aside in 1976,” when Nick returned from college at Franklin & Marshall in Lancaster. “And then I stepped aside for Jordan,” he said. Nick’s older son, Constantine, who goes by Corey, worked at Nicholas for about six years until he went down to Delray Beach, Fla., to run another family business, a restaurant called Johnnie Brown’s.

Jordan, who says he started tasting cream with coffee when he was five, has coffee in his blood. And, “he was determined to get us to 100 years,” his father said. Also in this centennial year, he and his wife welcomed the next generation, their son, Theodore.

Advertise with us

Origins

Nicholas Coffee started in a spot that’s now Four PPG Place — and moved to its current location in 1957 when the block that housed the original burned to the ground. The new shop took over what had been Mercer’s Music Bar.

If you’re in the shop facing the baristas, to the right photos depict the family’s history, from a portrait of Nicholas Constantine Nicholas to the Pittsburgh flood of 1936. Later photos show the Market Street location as it looked in the late ’50s, as well as a depiction of the interior after Nick Nicholas renovated the place back in 1981.

Behind the baristas, among the blends, beans labeled “My wife’s blend” stand out: What had been Gus’ wife’s favorite is now one of the shop’s oldest blends and has served as the base for flavored coffees. That blend is transferred to a rotating barrel, where beans are lightly coated in a flavor such as chocolate essence.

There aren’t many more recent photos, such as those that would have shown the before and after of the fire of 2017. In the timeline of the company, it was a major event when the afterburner on the roaster was accidentally left on and caught a beam in the roof on fire, causing a four-alarm blaze that shuttered the landmark location for three months.

Advertise with us

Yet there’s a silver lining to this difficult stretch: Not only did the fire reinforce the neighborliness of fellow roasters, but also it reinforced the loyalty of its Pittsburgh clientele.

“It seemed like every roaster reached out to us and offered to help us,” Jordan said. He cited Iron Star Roasting Company based in West Mifflin (the parent company of Coffee Tree Roasters) as especially helpful during that time. And with the rise of artisan coffee roasters, the family was worried they’d lose customers.

“We’re grateful customers have supported us and came back,” said Jordan.

The coffee

First, let’s acknowledge that the shop is also one of the more prolific loose-tea sellers in the area, which warrants its own deep-dive piece. And, yes, there are the hard-to-find candies and those roasted jumbo peanuts for sale. But when it comes to coffee, the Nicholas family has been a force, having cut out the middleman, buying off the commodity exchange. Six times a year, a truck shows up with 44,000 pounds of coffee, filled with stamped burlap sacks of green coffee beans: from Papua New Guinea, Honduras, India’s Malabar region, Jamaica’s Blue Mountain, and Hawaii’s Kona District.

Advertise with us

The beans translate into a multitude of blends as well as single-origin roasts, with Brian Widmer, in charge of roasting for Nicholas for more than 20 years. Many years before Mr. Widmer, Gus was the roaster, who’d take off his suit jacket only when he was roasting, according to his obituary in the Post-Gazette in 2009.

As far as what the family drinks, Jordan will mix it up, from a Yirgacheffe to a blend like Sumatra plus Olde Vienna that “kicks it up a bit.” Nick likes the mocha java-French roast blend. And Jordan’s grandfather was known for drinking mocha java “like it was water,” said Jordan.

“Twenty cups a day,” said Nick of his father. The two of them on average drink four to five cups a day. “It doesn’t bother me to drink coffee at night,” said Nick.

Although the company’s wholesale business has ebbed and flowed, with the ’80s a peak, before Nick sold the wholesale business in 1990. Today, Nicholas Coffee is back in wholesale, representing two-thirds of the company’s sales, with distributors like the Verona-based Arbuckle’s Coffee and the Sewickley-based Aromatic Coffee Express stocking more than 100 restaurants and markets in a 30-mile radius.

As far as retail, Jordan estimates there are 50 to 100 regulars who come through a day, although customers are more traditional coffee drinkers than specialty-drink types looking for a pumpkin spice latte. Sales, Jordan said, have been going up, with more people drinking more coffee throughout the day.

Advertise with us

“We’ve had the 7 to 10 a.m. wave,” he said, “and then there’s the noon to 1:30 wave, but there’s a new one from 3 to 5 p.m.,” he says. The family also attributes good service from longtime employees and the shop redesign after the fire to increased sales. Retail coffee sales average about 250 pounds of coffee a day and about 500 cups sold.

In the days leading up to the centennial, Jordan offered his thanks to residents.

“We wouldn’t be 100 years old if it wasn’t for the city of Pittsburgh,” said Jordan. “Pittsburgh is a loyal city: If you’re good to Pittsburgh, Pittsburghers are good to you.”

Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.