If you think it’s getting hard for the average Joe to open a restaurant in Pittsburgh, it seems to be tougher for the average Jane, especially if Jane is a woman of color.
The American Restaurant Association reported in 2017 that more than half the restaurants in the U.S. have women as full owners or co-owners. It also reported there are more women-owned restaurants in the industry than there are women-owned businesses in other sectors. Between 1997 and 2007, the number of women-owned restaurants jumped by 50 percent.
What’s good for women is good for everyone: “Diversity leads to greater innovation and creativity, largely due to the lack of ‘group think’ — in which individuals from similar backgrounds tend to approach problems the same way and propose similar solutions,” industry trade site QSR reported earlier this month.
But the landscape is changing as the cost of doing business goes up, as it has in Pittsburgh since Zagat named Pittsburgh the country’s most burgeoning restaurant city in 2015. Rents were raised accordingly. Today, Downtown rents hitting $30 to $40 a square foot, which translates, conservatively, to $15,000 a month rent for 6,000 square feet.
As a result, fewer independent spots can afford to open and stay open. This affects those with the fewest resources, like creative, DIY restaurants, shoestring operations and independent restaurants in general — many of which are run by women.
We talked about this and more during last week’s panel on Women in Food, the first in a series of food-focused events I put together with Wall Street Journal food and drink editor Beth Kracklauer, in conjunction with Abby Lembersky, program director at City of Asylum on the North Side.
Read More
Everyone on the panel is or was an owner, including Kate Romane of Black Radish Kitchen in North Point Breeze and Becca Hegarty, the James Beard semi-finalist, of Bitter Ends in Bloomfield. Longtime owner Amy Enrico, of coffee shop Tazza d’Oro in Highland Park and other locations, along with Courtney Lynch-Crawford, owner of the recently closed Nine on Nine, Downtown, joined them on stage.
Here’s what we learned:
It has always been tough to get a bank loan for a woman-owned restaurant.
Ms. Enrico opened her first Tazza d’Oro in Highland Park nearly 20 years ago, transitioning from a career in pharmaceuticals, when she had been commuting to Seattle for work. While in Pittsburgh, she found the site of her first location when she was walking her dog and fell in love with the building that was for sale.
Her biggest surprise? The bank she was seeking a loan from asked what her husband did for a living. “That was really interesting to overcome,” she told the panel. “I was making a lot of money. I was in pharmaceuticals. My mom had to co-sign on a loan because I was considered a single woman opening a business.”
At the time, she had not encountered other women coffee shop owners in her travels around the country. “I was kind of out there,” she said.
She went on to open locations at Carnegie Mellon University and in Millvale and wants to expand more. Today, “My businesses have been successful. We pay our bills. We paid our loans,” she says. Yet with more banking regulation today than 20 years ago, “if you don’t fit into the box, you don’t get a loan.”
She says she was recently denied a bank loan for expansion. “Most of the people I know are going through private investors or crowdfunding.”
Even with a proven track record of a successful restaurant, it’s a challenge to get investors.
Kate Romane of Black Radish Kitchen catering in North Point Breeze has been cooking in Pittsburgh since 1997. She owned E2 in Highland Park from 2010 to 2016, which she originally intended as a catering commissary, not a restaurant.
“I really enjoy catering because you get to be a part of someone’s special occasion,” she says. It wasn’t until she started talking to the neighborhood that she changed the model. “I had $4,000 to start that thing. I didn’t take out a loan, and I have a lot of great friends,” she says.
By 2016, between issues with the building and going month-to-month for over a year without a lease, she realized that if she were to keep E2 a restaurant, she’d have to move.
“But the rents were too much. And to move even a successful restaurant is going to be half a million dollars at the end of everything,” she says.
Her 28-seat restaurant was drawing lines out the door, and Sunday dinners were selling out the day tickets went on sale. With this kind of popularity, Ms. Romane says, “you would think that would help us get to the next level.”
She put out a call for investors, but “it was silent,” she says. She took out a home equity loan that helped her open Black Radish in a coworking food space in the X Factory.
There may be fewer explicit biases today compared to 20 years ago, but many implicit ones.
As far as whether there’s bias in the industry, Ms. Romane says, “It’s just as difficult being a woman in the restaurant industry as it is being a woman anywhere.”
Ms. Hegarty noted that as a woman restaurant owner, “the focus is shifted on how cute or how twee of a concept I’ve got going on and what my color palette is,” she says, “instead of talking about the point of the restaurant, which is food and food availability.”
She noted that she has a tall guy cooking for her, and “everyone thinks he owns the place,” which sometimes makes it easier to run the restaurant instead of talking to customers.
Ms. Enrico notes that she no longer gets questions about “what my husband does for a living,” she says, but there’s still a lot of “implicit bias.”
She told a story of having brought a guy in as the company’s chief financial operator. “When Bob is sitting around a table with me, everybody talks to Bob,” she says. “I’ve been doing this for 20 years, working my tail off, and Bob’s with me doing his thing — really smart guy and really amazing — but it’s apparent in meetings with banks and investment people,” she says.
When Ms. Kracklauer asked whether Pittsburgh restaurant scene has a macho edge to it — “There is in other cities, so I wouldn’t be surprised,” she said —The panel answered in unison, “Yes.”
“I think, especially in this city, it’s very much a man-run situation,” says Ms. Hegarty. “And there aren’t many young people able to open restaurants here anymore. So it’s mostly older men who have grown up in the industry when it was OK or at least not so in the public eye to be horrible. And because [the #MeToo movement] is so publicized, it’s not very welcoming, because nobody wants to be outed as a bad man.”
Ms. Romane said, “When I opened the restaurant in 2010, there was definitely more of a camaraderie. I think it’s still happening depending on where you are. But overall, it is pretty macho,” she says.
“But there are some badass ladies out there doing some really cool stuff, and I want to support them,” she said. “I think people want to put us against each other. Like there can only be one token, or there can only be a handful of [women], and I refuse to participate in that sort of climate.”
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.