In 2015, Don Mahaney bought what had been Billy’s Troy Hill Bistro and opened Scratch Food and Beverage in a seemingly improbable location for a restaurant with a menu beyond burgers, wings and bar-food fare. Four years later, Scratch is on its way to becoming an essential Pittsburgh restaurant, with the owner in the building every night, and a chef with accolades, Chris O’Brien, steering the kitchen.

Who’d go to a hilltop without a view for dinner? Beyond residents, people who are curious about the neighborhood’s revival, fueled by a main drag with infrastructure and a cadre of people moving here for good housing stock, a community feel and close proximity to Downtown.

Scratch Food and Beverage

1720 Lowrie St.

Advertise with us

Troy Hill

412-251-0822

www.scratchfoodbev.com

  • Hours: 5 to 9 p.m. Tuesday and Wednesday; 5 to 10 p.m. Thursday; 5 to 11 p.m. Friday and 5 to 9:30 Saturday.
  • Prices: Snacks $4 to $8, small plates $7 to $11, soup and salad $6 to $10, large plates $19 to $31.
  • Sound Level: Just right
  • Details: Street parking, reservations on OpenTable, bar menu.
  • Wild Card: Happy hour cocktails are $9, wine is $7 and beers are $1 off menu price. Karaoke Friday nights, live music on Thursdays, 8 to 10 p.m.; Jazz, the last Saturday of the month, Sunday brunch, coming soon.

Newbies also are drawn to Troy Hill by art collector Evan Mirapaul. Having assisted the neighborhood’s revival, Mr. Mirapaul commissioned the Troy Hill art houses, La Hutte Royal and Kunzhaus. Both are private spaces that have been redone by German artist Thorsten Brinkmann and Polish artist Robert Kusmirowski, respectively, and are open by reservation for docent-led tours. More of these are on the way.

Mr. Mirapaul has also shepherded the opening of Spaces Corners from Melissa Catanese and Ed Panar, an art book store and event space open to the public on Saturdays. He also owns the building that houses daytime restaurant and coffee shop, The Pear and the Pickle.

Advertise with us

All of this feeds energy into the neighborhood for which Scratch has become a hub. In 2017, it brought on Brandon Blumenfeld, a young chef with a healthy ego, turning out a menu of romantic-plated dishes with lots of stems and garnishes, color and smears. This wasn’t tweezer food, but it was showy in a different way — and it was often delicious.

In late fall, Mr. Blumenfeld left to pursue other endeavors, replaced by Mr. O’Brien, a chef most recently with the Rick DeShantz Group in the kitchen at Poulet Bleu in Lawrenceville. He comes to the position with deep Pittsburgh experience, having led kitchens at Hyeholde in Moon, Restaurant Echo in Cranberry and Poros in Market Square, the latter two now closed.

The space at Scratch is part of the charm, a woodsy nook with warm lighting in the dining room and homey touches like cafe curtains and cat pillows along the window seat banquette. The bar is a touch more casual, with its own menu and a spiffed-up rec-room feel.

One evening from the dining room window seat, we enjoyed a table of 12 as they celebrated the family matriarch’s birthday, her wheelchair closest to servers and the family tucked into the expansive table around her. They set the tone for a lovely night, with every table in the dining room filled at 9 p.m. on a Friday: couples on dates, families here for dinner and friends out for snacks.

It’s what you’d hope for, for an independently owned neighborhood restaurant, with a chef who can please many tastes — from the conservative diner out for a special occasion to the one who’s a regular at too many restaurants to count.

Advertise with us

Though Mr. O’Brien’s menu is less risk-taking than Mr. Blumenfeld’s, he has assembled a collection of compelling dishes — both retro and modern — at prices that are more accessible than Downtown tabs.

Not all of them are great, like a pastrami special that was a little wan, overdressed with a side of liver pate, but many dishes are very good. If I had my way, I’d come here with a group of four and order every snack — pickled vegetables, baccala eggs, olives, marinated mushrooms — a few small plates, pasta and a simple dessert, like creme brulee or stewed pears in red wine.

At the start, those snacky mushrooms are especially addictive, seasoned with cascabel pepper, paprika, sherry vinegar and lemon. A server called out my usual order of ful medames, favas with cumin and tahini with a side of crudite. It’s a creamy vegan dish that I love (though I wouldn’t mind more salt). Linguiça sausage starter is satisfying for me but might be a bit small for someone looking for a more hearty serving.

The soup and salad selection is a standout, from the Elysian Fields lamb stew that’s great for these still-cold nights, to roast beets and carrots with star anise honey and thyme vinaigrette that makes late winter, early spring vegetables far more interesting. Baby greens keep it simple with bitter escarole, frisee, radish and a butternut shrub dressing.

Of seven main courses, three are vegetarian-friendly, from the plate of king trumpet mushrooms with fingerlings and chard, to that pasta I was telling you about, with ricotta, walnut, egg and parsley, that, with a douse of citrus, is brighter than you’d expect. There’s also scallop noodles, with caulilini, a newish sweeter variety of cauliflower, and a pistachio-fennel vinaigrette. Meat eaters can appreciate local Laurel Hill trout, Locust Point Farm chicken served with poblano verde and polenta and, yes, sausage. There's also the decadent beef Bourguignon with whipped truffled potatoes and heirloom carrots that, at $27, is among the most expensive dishes on the menu (which, I think, is pretty reasonable, comparatively speaking).

Advertise with us

Service is generally spot-on, casual and engaging but not overly so. Mr. Mahaney often checks in on tables, and it’s clear that service is a team effort, with servers not assigned to a table, as well as management, stepping in when needed.

We haven’t talked about the drinks yet, which, we should, since Scratch is certainly a place to drink and is one of the better people-watching venues around — whether it’s for happy hour or Friday karaoke that starts after 9 p.m.

There’s something to be said for a good cocktail list, with aged Negronis, Old-Fashioneds and a few outliers with music-named references, for around $11. I tend to stick to a glass of white, like the Trebbiano- or Vermentino- blends, or reds like Pinot Noir for $10 to $14. Beers range from low-brow Genesee for around $4 to Mikkeller, or PA-based ShuBrew and Troegs.

With great service, a dining room that’s long on charm and a menu of food and drink that will mostly win you over, Scratch Food and Beverage raises the bar for Pittsburgh neighborhood restaurants.

Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com.