Two Pittsburgh restaurants, a luncheonette and pizzeria, made Bon Appetit magazine’s top 50 nominees of this year’s “America’s Best New Restaurants”: They’re modest in comparison to million-dollar, over-the-top culinary destinations that also made the list.
Yet Bitter Ends Garden and Luncheonette in Bloomfield (4613 Liberty Ave.) and Driftwood Oven (3615 Butler St.) in Lawrenceville share a common value in that they both go to great lengths to source hard-to-find ingredients — and they’re both baking bread.
At Bitter Ends, co-owners Becca Hegarty, Jason “Jodo” Oddo and Lou DeVito run a pesticide-free farm in conjunction with the restaurant, where they’re growing esoteric varietals of chicories, lettuces, zucchini, tomatoes and more on a half-acre of land in Verona.
The daytime restaurant offers toast with, say, blueberries paired with Calkins Creamery brie from Honesdale, Pa. — that just won first place at the American Cheese Society competition — or a breakfast salad with pole beans and Nebraska Wedding tomatoes. Sandwiches start with baguettes Ms. Hegarty is making in-house, layered with those vegetables harvested from the Verona farm.
Bitter Ends Luncheonette in Bloomfield, which opened in November, cost less than $20,000 to get up and running and may be one of the smallest restaurants in the city, with about 10 seats, not counting the outdoor picnic tables.
Over in Lawrenceville, Neil Blazin and Justin Vetter are sourcing some of the same flour Ms. Hegarty is using from Central Milling out West and Weatherbury Farms in Avella. They’re using it to make the pizza that has garnered a following since 2015, with the debut of their mobile pizza oven. The Lawrenceville restaurant opened in the spring.
Ms. Hegarty had been named as one of this year’s Eater Young Guns semifinalists and has made the semifinalist list for the James Beard “Rising Star Chef” for the past two years. Driftwood Oven has gotten nods for best pizza in Pittsburgh from Thrillist and recognition from Star Chefs.
The Bon Appetit list was put together by Bon Appetit’s editor at large Andrew Knowlton, who “hits the road for weeks at a time, crisscrossing the country and eating everything in sight, in search of the top standout spots,” said Savannah Jackson, spokeswoman for Conde Nast.
The criteria for the list is any restaurant that has opened in the past year, reviewing not just the chefs and what’s on the menu but also the full dining experience.
Beyond this top-50 list there’s more: On Aug. 14, Bon Appetit will announce its short list of which 50 favorites earn a place in The Hot Ten.
Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.