They came, and when the last vote was counted, an all-Greek team ended up conquering the crowd with its simple and traditional Greek flavors.
A team composed of Michael Smalis of Greek Gourmet, Matt Bournias of Pastitsio and former chef and Pittsburgh Magazine restaurant critic Valentina Vavasis walked away with the People’s Choice Award at Sunday’s second Western Pennsylvania Lamb Cook-Off at Ace Hotel Pittsburgh in East Liberty. And talk about a squeaker: the team won by a single vote.
Tasked with turning two whole lamb carcasses into hundreds (and hundreds) of delicious bite-sized portions for a discerning crowd of lamb lovers, the chefs prepared the classic Greek foods they grew up with. To that end, the winning plate included four different bites: miniature gyros topped with Pastitsio’s housemade yogurt tzatziki, pickled onions and chopped tomatoes; grape leaves stuffed with basmati rice and lamb and artfully perfumed with herbs; chunks of grilled lamb nestled on a bed of garlicky skordalia (mashed) potatoes; and three different varieties of hummus.
“We are thrilled,” Ms. Vavasis said via email. “We had a great time and hope we did the lamb justice.”
What made her booth extra fun, she adds, was the fact they brought their families along, “which is a very Greek thing to do.”
Coming up with a clear-cut winner for the Critics Choice Award proved a little harder. Judged by 12 food writers, critics and other food professionals, the vote ended in a three-way tie.
The team composed of Roger Li of Umami, Derek Burnell of Round Corner Cantina, both in Lawrenceville, and Dan Kern of 1201 Restaurant in Erie — who won last year’s inaugural People’s Choice Award — ended up having to share it with Ben Sloan of Kaya, Brandon Fisher of Union Standard and Will Randall of The Rivers Club; and the all-female team of Jennifer Gerasole of Girasole, Kate Romane of Black Radish Kitchen, Jessica Lewis of Or, the Whale and Merchant Oyster Co., and Jamilka Borges of Independent Brewing Co., Lorelei and Hidden Harbor.
Mr. Li’s team prepared lamb robatayaki (skewers) with mint tare; roasted lamb and burrata on sourdough topped with pistachio salsa verde, honey-vinegar, crispy shallot and red sorrel; and one of the prettiest dishes of the day, shredded za’atar braised lamb with anchovy, ricotta and a summer pea salad dressed with yuzu and truffle oil.
Mr. Sloan & friends dished up a jerk lamb paratha taco with mango slaw and cucumber aioli; peach barbecue lamb on top of a pimento cheese biscuit; and the event’s only dessert (and a spectacular one at that): blueberry parfait with lamb tallow-toasted oats.
Ms.Gerasole’s team impressed the judges with lamb fett'unta (a type of Italian garlic bread) topped with a pine nut and currant relish.
Co-sponsored by Table Magazine and the Ace Hotel, the cook-off aimed to raise awareness for the prized Pennsylvania lamb donated this year by Pure Bred, a high-quality brand of “holistic lamb” developed by Chef Thomas Keller of The French Laundry and Keith Martin of Elysian Fields Farm near Waynesburg.
An expanded footprint allowed the festival to double in size from last year. It sold out at 1,000, and guests got to sample more than a dozen lamb-centric dishes.
Gretchen McKay: gtmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.