Red the Steakhouse debuted in the fall as the newest Downtown meat destination from the Indianapolis-based restaurant group that also runs a couple of Red locations in Ohio as well as Miami Beach,Fla.

Just under 10,000 square-feet — it’s enormous — on the ground floor of the U.S. Steel Tower, the Pittsburgh spot includes a well-designed bar, private dining and potentially outdoor seating should the weather ever allow it.

There are things to like about Red, in particular the service, which was terrific during my visits. If you go in with a strategy there’s a good chance you’ll enjoy the whole experience.

But first, a concern: There are too many steakhouses in the neighborhood, with at least 10 and two on the way.

Advertise with us

I get it. People love steak. And Pittsburghers like steakhouses, where you know what you’re getting for the money. There’s no frou-frou, science-y stuff going on in a kitchen run by an egomaniac chef using xanthan gum and space powders or blow torches for cooking. There’s no three-hour tasting menu, with portions so small you’ll leave hungry and end up going out for pizza afterward. A steakhouse is a safe bet.

For a steakhouse, Red offers a perfectly fine experience, generally speaking.

And a shoutout to the locally trained executive chef, Jamaican-born Rowan Murray, who went through the culinary program at the Art Institute of Pittsburgh and has taken the position within the past of couple months. I am hoping he will tighten things in the kitchen as he gets comfortable, which is one reason why this review is not starred.

Red the Steakhouse

U.S. Steel Tower

Advertise with us

600 Grant St., Downtown

412-745-6328

redthesteakhouse.com

Not starred. 

  • Hours: Lunch 11 a.m. to 3 p.m weekdays; happy hour 3 to 6 p.m. weekdays; dinner 5 to 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday and until 11 p.m. Friday and Saturday.
  • Prices: Dinner: Raw bar, $18 to $100+, appetizers $12 to $19, salads $10 to $12, pasta $26 to $100, steaks $42 to $129, chops and such $29 to $54, seafood $29 to $100, sides $9 to $24, desserts $7 to $16.
  • Sound level: Quiet to buzzy.
  • Details: OpenTable, corkage fee, handicapped-accessible, private dining.
  • Wild card: The restaurant will soon have outdoor dining; consider grabbing a bite during happy hour and lunch to save a few dollars.

Red the space

Advertise with us

Stick to the bar if you’re looking for a cozy room, where cushy booths could double as daybeds; they’re so oversized and semi-luxe. The space is framed by plate glass nearly entirely, both in the bar area and in the dining room, creating a fishbowl that looks out to Grant Street. Should that not capture your attention, there’s always the game on the TVs over the bar, or your charming companions.

Through the bar and past the host stand, the dining room is vast. There’s little to cut the line of vision, so it’s as if tables are positioned in a very nice airport. Dressed in white linens, they are dwarfed in a room of dark chairs and dark walls with red and white accent lights. Should you plan on going to the lavatory, allow enough time to get there as if you were changing terminals. I exaggerate, but it’s a trek.

Red the experience

There are three paths I’d suggest for the deal seeker. One, there’s a bar menu with items $12 or less from 3 to 6 p.m. weekdays offering crab dip, poutine, oysters and shrimp. Well drinks, beer and wine range from $3.30 to $6.

The second is the $22 three-course power lunch that begins with Caesar or house salad, includes the main course such as the fish of the day or filet medallions, and dessert such as doughnut holes made to order. That’s a spread for a good value.

Advertise with us

Beyond lunch and happy hour, dinner pricing can be fair if you strategize, although sometimes the food is a minefield. One dinner started with close to stale rolls with a texture as if they’d been heated and reheated over and over. They were served with olive oil drizzled on a plate over crumbled Parmesan spiked with guajillo pepper.

House salads are better in that they’re edible. Arugula is dressed with restraint, with prosciutto wrapped around leaves like a blanket, garnished with frico. Another starter, shrimp cocktail ($19 for five) — it’s back — is as satisfying as it was when you had it decades ago.

One thing I don’t love about Red is that servers seem to be encouraged to aggressively pitch diners to order Certified Angus Beef or Signature Selections like a Cadillac salesman from the ’50s.That’s not the servers’ fault: It’s the corporate structure that has created this approach to an upsell.

They’re generally describing steaks from an 8-ounce filet to a 24-ounce porterhouse that run from $42 to $129 for a shared cut, with the premiere product that’s wet- then dry-aged for as long as Lent. There is also the veal chop, lamb, chicken and salmon if you so choose.

In my visits, I preferred what my table called the workingman’s steak, the New York strip for $46 for a choice cut that’s less tender and has less marbling than prime. We split it without the server adding a per-person plate charge, which is standard. And while the strip was served solo on a dish — it looked a little lonely — it was perfectly satisfying, medium rare. The sauces, on the other hand, were a disaster, with truffle demi-glace that had not emulsified in one case and the black peppercorn sauce that looked as if it had been sitting in another.

Advertise with us

The sides just might be the most satisfying aspect of the menu. They’re the most straightforward and — unlike the pastas like the carbonara or the Bolognese, which tastes like made-for-volume wedding fare — they’re just right. I’d suggestion the cauliflower gratin ($12) and the sauteed mushrooms ($14) that require no decoding of the menu as the case is with the steaks. There is no overreaching. Nothing was overdone. No sauces were broken.

If you must go for dinner past the happy hour, here’s what I’d do: Hit the bar and split a steak and a bunch of sides with a companion. Save room for dessert, and consider the doughnuts or fried Oreos for novelty ($10, $9, respectively) and splurge on a glass of tawny port.

Melissa McCart: mmccart@post-gazette.com.