“Why didn’t we start with this?” my friend exclaims ruefully when the dessert menu is presented after dinner.

With choices such as a lofty chocolate cake brightened with blood oranges at every bite, a sundae built with grapefruit macarons, a butterscotch cheesecake drizzled with Meyer lemon marmalade, and a passion fruit bombe amid candied hibiscus petals, we could have happily started our meal with desserts at Whitfield without hesitation.

Whitfield at Ace Hotel Pittsburgh

120 S. Whitfield St., East Liberty.

Advertise with us

412-361-3300; whitfieldpgh.com

  • Hours: Breakfast, 7-11 a.m. Monday-Friday and 7-10:30 a.m. Saturday-Sunday; lunch, 11 a.m.-3 p.m. Monday-Friday; brunch, 10:30 a.m.-3 p.m. Saturday-Sunday; dinner, 5-10 p.m. Sunday-Thursday and 5 p.m.-midnight Friday-Saturday..
  • Prices: Breakfast and brunch, $4-$21; lunch salads and sandwiches, $11-$23; dinner entrees, $22-$34; steaks, $21-$80; desserts, $3-$10.
  • Sound level: Oscillates between loud and louder when there’s an event at the gym in the evenings; quiet during breakfast.
  • Details: Full bar with cocktails and extensive list of whites and reds; coffee bar opens at 6 a.m.; wheelchair accessible through side entrance; parking on street and lot in the back.
  • Wild card: Blood oranges, hibiscus petals and croissants are expertly candied and used as garnishes for chocolate cake, bombe and creme brulee respectively.

The 95-seat tavern-style restaurant at the Ace Hotel Pittsburgh in East Liberty is a destination for a quiet breakfast, not-so-quiet brunch, quick lunch or meat-heavy dinner. Hipsters also meet up to grab a cup of morning joe at the coffee bar that features Stumptown Coffee Roasters or a late-night drink at the cocktail bar, along with the pooch. Or many simply hang out in the cool and cozy lobby of the boutique hotel chain, which occupies the former century-old YMCA.

But I would make a beeline to Whitfield for the desserts.

There’s nothing ubiquitous about head pastry chef Casey Renee’s creations, and one does not need to have an insistent sweet tooth to delight in them. Ms. Renee, who grew up in the South Hills, honed her pastry skills at the acclaimed Momofuku Ko and Del Posto in New York City. She also worked at The Meat Hook in Brooklyn, co-owned by Pittsburgh-born Brent Young, who oversees Whitfield along with the hotel.

Her moist olive oil chocolate cake ($10), layered with Nutella mousse and hazelnuts, goes for a glamorous spin with fresh blood orange segments, pipings of blood orange creamsicle and candied blood oranges and gets a crunch from thin shards of wafer cookies mixed with chocolate and sea salt.

Advertise with us

Chew, crunch and delicious creativity also co-exist in the passion fruit bombe ($8), made with passion fruit curd, whipped cream, brown butter cake, brittles and hibiscus petals that are cooked down until they are soft, dusted with sugar and dehydrated.

Redolent of ripe grapefruit, the sundae ($8) is built with grapefruit macaron slathered with grapefruit curd and topped with vanilla ice cream. A to-die-for ginger syrup trickles down the ice cream while tiny grapefruit macarons sit upright on it.

A creamy and light butterscotch cheesecake ($8) comes with a suave pumpkin puree-white chocolate ganache on a crumbly pepita crust. A saucy and sassy Meyer lemon marmalade covers the poised treat.

Ms. Renee emulates a carrot cake recipe for her parsnip bread ($7), which is a marvel of simplicity and good taste. Scented with cinnamon, all-spice and fresh ginger, the moist bread gets a crispy crust by being dabbed with butter on a griddle before being served for breakfast or brunch with a sweet-sour berry butter that tastes pickle-ish in a good way.

While a bruleed ruby red grapefruit ($4), crowned with raspberries and blueberries, also leaves a lasting impression with its simple deliciousness, main brunch dishes such as the pricey $15 Whitfield Breakfast (poached eggs, beet-potato rosti, pork and English muffins) and Mushroom Gravy & Biscuits ($11) do not. Both are victims of excess — the biscuits are loaded with baking powder, and the smoked pork is too salty. They do disservice to the earthy gravy and beautifully poached eggs, respectively.

Advertise with us

Make sure to have reservations for brunch because the cheery horseshoe-ish-shaped dining room fills up quickly, leaving diners to spill out into the comfy lobby area that intersects with the cocktail and coffee bars.

Whitfield, which opened in December 2015, retains the old charm of the Y by respecting original details such as the Corinthian column tips against the wall near the hotel entrance and ceiling molding. The terrazzo floor has been restored, and so has the marble lobby staircase. The former Y gym is used these days for staging plays and hosting table tennis tournaments, dodge ball nights and fundraisers. So on an event night, the noise level oscillates between loud and louder, but that only adds charm to the place.

A wire divider separates the rest of the first floor from the dining room, which has an understated elegance to it. The decor is kept to a minimum and feels familiar without being specific. Bare wood tables and schoolhouse-like chairs take up the floor space. Potted plants, framed tapestry and simple drapes on the tall windows create a homey yet chic backdrop to the haute yet homestyle cooking of executive chef Bethany Zozula, who was previously the executive sous chef at Eleven in the Strip District.

Ms. Zozula gets a party in the mouth started with the Sausage Party ($14) — creamy kasekrainer made with pork and beef and stuffed with Swiss cheese; lamb sausage with a pronounced rosemary flavor; and an all-pork kielbasa perfumed with marjoram. The nice snap of the casing, stringy mound of raw onions and pungent mustard make you want to hang out with the party until the last bite.

I’m generally not a fan of carpaccio, but the Jamison Farm lamb version ($14) is executed flawlessly. Thinly shaved raw meat is arranged like petals of a pretty flower and simply melts in the mouth. Beet slices and pea shoots complete the picture-perfect arrangement.

Advertise with us

An order of shrimp cocktail ($15) comes on a plate, with plump jumbo shrimp cooling on shaved ice with zippy Dijon-mayonnaise and cocktail sauces. Shrimp takes on a different role with the wild striped bass ($34) and comes in a spicy sauce along with toothsome black-eyed peas and pork tasso. Delicate arborio rice cakes round out the sides.

Meats decide and dominate the entrees except for a vegetable risotto ($22), which on one night doesn’t taste like anything but comes with a beautiful lacework of dried cabbage. On another visit, the bright red rice is creamy and shines with its sweet roasted beets and carrots. The lacework, however, is MIA.

You don’t have to like duck to warm up to the duck confit ($28). It’s crusty and succulent and teases the palate with honey beets and sweet-and-sour cabbage. But I could have done without the clumpy and heavy spaetzel.

I would pass on the braised rabbit porchetta ($32), with gnocchi and olives, the next time, not because it is bad but simply because I prefer to save the spot for the Berkshire pork shank ($32). It’s so well cooked that the meat falls off the bones, making it irresistibly the star of the entrees. The pork is braised with chilies and is served with whipped potatoes and mustard greens pickled in rice wine vinegar. So when the spiciness and tartness explode in the mouth, it leaves you sighing and smiling.

But at Whitfield, a meal is truly over only with something sweet, whether it’s a light and puffy doughnut dusted with matcha or ones with more panache. Ms. Renee is a semifinalist at this year’s James Beard Foundation Awards for outstanding pastry chef. She clearly deserves this nod, and more.

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1494 or on Twitter @arthisub.