Revel + Roost is all about being R & R.
The downstairs and upstairs fraternal twin restaurants off Market Square, Downtown, define themselves to be places of resting, lodging and merrymaking. But they also are about being refined breakfast, lunch, brunch and dinner destinations that introduce you to a whole world flavors.
Revel + Roost
Tower Two-Sixty, 242 Forbes Ave.
Downtown
412-281-1134
revelandroost.com
Food:

- Hours: 5-10 p.m. Monday-Thursday; 5-11 p.m. Friday and Saturday. Closed Sunday.
- Prices: Appetizers, $9-$34; add-ons, $4-$6; entrees, $20-$26; desserts, $6-$8.
- Sound level: Constant hum of conversation that can get quite rackety at peak time.
- Details: Cocktails are seasonal in spirit, and there's a long list of wine, bottled beers, Scotches and whiskeys. Wheelchair accessible. Parking available in an underground garage and on street.
- Wildcard:Vinaigrette and croutons in salads such as beet and kale. Thyme croutons are tossed over beets, dried cranberries, blue cheese, candied walnuts and drizzled with maple-tahini dressing. Kale is topped with baked grapes, apple, pumpernickle-garlic croutons and vanilla-pumpkin vinaigrette.
Both kitchens knock out creative dishes by hautifying the homespun and amping nontraditional concepts. Although there are a few overlaps in their menus, the dining experiences are different, especially when it comes to the tab. While a dinner for two can be around $30 for a burger and half order of fried chicken coated with raspberry-maple hot sauce at the casual Revel (open all day) at street level, it is the price of a premium steak or Ora King salmon farmed in New Zealand at the upscale Roost (serves breakfast and dinner) upstairs.
Millcraft Investments opened the restaurants in March, and they occupy a split-level space at Tower Two-Sixty that also houses Hilton Garden Inn. You can get to Roost through the hotel, but it’s easier doing it by entering through Revel.
As you walk up the stairs from Revel, leaving the college football game noise behind, a two-story wine rack gets your attention and so does Roost’s large dining area. A cozy bar area sits on one end, and there are three private dining rooms that are tucked away from the main room on the way to the bathrooms. Natural motifs of tree rings fill out a back wall, and drift wood light fixtures that look like large bird nests emit a warm glow.
While the rustic theme is a common denominator, there’s also a hodgepodge of elements such as a weather vane with an eagle on top that sits smack in the middle of the dining room; plaques detailing the history of Market Square and defining what Revel and Roost mean; and photographs of the building during its construction.
A wall of glass windows on one side of the dining room lets you look down on Forbes Street, and also across the street into the gym at the Downtown PNC YMCA. That’s when my brain started sending mixed signals. Should I feel guilty about scarfing down the warm cheese puffs and small slices of Grandma’s bread that I alternatively smeared with a piquant red pepper relish and whipped cinnamon-honey butter? Or eat like there’s no tomorrow and then exercise after dinner?
I didn’t have to agonize for long because when it gets dark, it’s difficult to see the activities in the gym, and I could revel in the first starter — velvety soft scallops on pork belly ($16). The boneless meat is brined for 48 hours, fried to get a crispy finish and caramelized with butterscotch glaze. When they are dabbed in a swoosh of earthy celeriac puree, what sounds overly complex is pure pleasure in the mouth.
That pleasure extends to the short ribs ($14), which are melt-in-your-mouth tender. It comes with a stone-ground mustard that is a wonderful counterpoint to the sweet tomato-based St. Louis barbecue sauce.
Not counting the salads and add-ons, the only vegetarian item on the menu is an onion tart with goat cheese filled with cranberry mostarda ($9). On one visit, the mostarda is cloying sweet, and even the soft cheese can’t redeem it. But on a second time, it is amazing, and the nest of greens on top of the light tart adds a lovely touch. I only wish it was served warm and not on the cooler side of room temperature.
Executive chef Vincent Perri, who was the former executive sous chef at Jacksons Restaurant + Bar (also of the Millcraft Investments group) in Canonsburg, pays an ode to the season with sides such as celeriac puree, brandied apples, butternut squash in the form of cubes and batonets, and sweet potato gratin and souffle. They are elemental and make a fine case, but the broccoli rapini is an enigma.
Potent with red chili pepper, and sharply bitter and tough, the rapini isn’t exactly a team player in the mountainous pile of cavatelli with duck confit ($20), muscling out the creamy leek confit. But if you start with crispy duck skin, which has been dried in the oven and then deep fried, you would find peace.
Nor does the rapini exactly cooperate with the pan-roasted Ora King salmon ($32), yelling over the black pepper-crusted fillet, sweet potato souffle heavily perfumed with spices, artichokes, braised apples and buttery white grapes.
A flaky grilled cobia ($27) wears nothing but its perfect delicate taste and shares the plate with meaty black trumpet mushrooms, butternut squash, punchy chili pepper relish and fennel panisse, which doesn’t taste much like anything. Crisp outside and soft inside, the chickpea fries are dusted lightly with sugar and cinnamon but come up short on the fennel flavor.
Mr. Perri brilliantly executes the meat dishes. The ribeye ($33) is a marvelous chunk of Angus beef from Iowa Premium farm and gushes with juices. He lets the meat do its job by perfectly searing it and simply seasoning it with salt and pepper. And that’s all it needs.
Order Murray’s Chicken Breast just for its crust — it’s worth every bit of its $20. It gets a crunchy skin from being pan-roasted in brown butter and is served with a crusty-topped pouffy sage bread pudding, haricot verts, delicate French breakfast radishes and butternut squash cut into long sticks.
The waitstaff is pleasant and courteous, but the service is uneven and poky. On one visit, despite having a reservation, it took a while for us to be seated, but another time everything goes like clockwork; even our silverware is changed after every course. A third time, we have to make do with a regular knife to cut the ribeye because the steak knife never makes it to the table even after a request.
Then there’s the time where our waitress not only forgets to bring our sides of wild mushrooms and mashed potatoes, but also never serves our dessert. After a 40-minute wait, we ask another waiter for our check, explaining we need to head out ASAP for a show, and 5 minutes later, the manager shows up with the check, a sincere apology and the desserts. He even removes the cost of the Oreo Brownie Sunday (sic) and Citrus Semifreddo off the tab and pleads with us to come back and have them after the show.
When we return later that night, the sundae and semifreddo are served promptly, actually within minutes. But the only problem is that they come frozen, so rock solid that we can’t cut them, even with a knife. When I finally could fork it up, it was hard to taste the flavor or texture as it stuck to my tongue.
Coffee + Doughnuts ($6) belongs in the whatever category. The oomphless coffee tastes like a cup of hot water drizzled with a hint of espresso, and the doughnuts were on the dry side. But the interplay of maple-cinnamon and espresso in the custard drizzle over the doughnut is fantastic. The menu should probably drop the doughnut act and just serve Coffee + Custard.
The Salted Caramel Panna Cotta ($6) makes me realize why Roost is a destination for R & R. It bridges the haute and the humble together in a big goblet. Even though I don’t crave Cracker Jack, the caramel popcorn and peanuts along with the layers of chocolate mousse, salted-caramel panna cotta and fresh cream coo comfort. And I can just keep pecking on it all evening long.
Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1494 or on Twitter @arthisub.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.